HCLG Select Committee report shows children’s services are in crisis
Today’s report from the Housing, Communities and Local Government Select Committee doesn’t pull its punches: children’s services need an extra £3.1bn in funding to survive, and that’s just the start. Coming on the back of highly critical reports from the Public Accounts Committee and the National Audit Office, the report paints a picture of malign neglect of children’s services on the part of Central Government. The result is a perfect storm of increased expectations, rising demand and cost pressures which local authorities cannot control.
We are pleased to see much of our evidence to the committee reflected in the final report. We’re particularly pleased to see the Committee recognise that additional funding alone is not sufficient, and that “increased funding must go hand-in-hand with systemic change if local authority children’s services are to be sustainable in the long-term”. The report is highly critical of the Department for Education’s failure to tackle the variation in children’s services and its inaction on universal cost pressures such as recruitment and residential care. The Committee has echoed the Commissioner’s concerns that the Troubled Families programme (which provided support to the families of 404,000 children last year) is withering away because Government has failed to come to a decision on how to renew or replace it.
All of this gives the Government quite a to-do list, and it’s not one the Department for Education can duck. Much more work is required to understand the drivers of demand in children’s services and why spending varies at the same time as urgent action needed to address social worker recruitment and to increase the supply of residential care. Looking forward, the Department for Education and Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government have been told to ensure that further ‘obligations’ on children’s services are fully funded (obligations that are actually vital services for children, including care leavers support and care for children with SEND).
Yet the Housing, Communities and Local Government’s report only tells half the story. Their report, quite understandably given their remit, was looking at the pressures on local authorities. The more fundamental issue – what is required to meet the needs of children – is a huge challenge for children’s services (and Government). This is partly because we know very little about the children for whom services are provided. Until the Children’s Commissioner’s vulnerability framework was first published in 2017, no one had ever attempted to understand how many children or families were out there who needed help. We only have limited information on how many get help (we have no information, for example, on how many families access ‘early help’) and we have no information at all on the outcomes these children achieve. All of this means that we are often unable to connect the spending pressures facing councils with the impact on children.
So what do we know about vulnerable children and their outcomes? Firstly, the Children’s Commissioner’s vulnerability framework identifies 2.1m children living in families with significant additional need. Over a three year period, about half of these children will reach the threshold for statutory children’s services, and we estimate that each year about 700,000 get some form of help. And yet their educational prospects, the only outcome we can track, are extremely poor. Of the children reaching the threshold for statutory intervention, only a quarter reach the expected standard of development at primary school. Average attainment at the end of secondary school is half that of the rest of the population.
This is the real challenge for children’s services: 10% of children are reaching the threshold for statutory children’s services, and for these children their prospects are still being determined by their family circumstances, because of our failure to make meaningful and lasting interventions. The Children’s Act, thirty years old this year, set out an obligation on local authorities to help children reach “a reasonable standard of health or development”, including health and well-being. Yet on this evidence, it’s not working. This year’s expected Spending Review needs to put children’s services on a sustainable footing. But the biggest challenge is how we change the life course for these children. And for the moment, this remains a black hole in Government policy.
Latest News from
The paralysis currently affecting much of Whitehall and Westminster is letting down Children in Need17/06/2019 16:12:00
Today’s Children in Need (CiN) review is important for two reasons. Firstly, it shines a light on the hundreds of thousands of children in England who are growing up in need, supporting the argument I have been making since I became Children’s Commissioner that identifying vulnerability in children is essential if we are to improve outcomes for those who are being held back, or worse, completely failed.
Universal Credit – “Children are going hungry. It’s not a myth, it’s a fact.”14/06/2019 15:47:00
As Universal Credit rolls out across the country, we have been checking in regularly with a foodbank in an area which is transitioning to UC to see if there has been any noticeable impact on the number of families with children using their services.
New report suggests significant group of children are being denied advocacy despite having a statutory entitlement to it13/06/2019 14:51:00
This year marks the 30th anniversary of two significant breakthroughs in children’s rights legislation: The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Children Act 1989.
Too many vulnerable young children are missing out on the vital speech and language help they need to get ready for school11/06/2019 17:05:00
Anne Longfield, the Children’s Commissioner for England, is today (Tuesday) publishing a new report “We need to talk: Access to speech and language therapy“, which shines a light on spending on speech and language therapy services (SLT) for children across the country to help identify where children who need support are falling through the gaps.
The first step in redressing the balance of power between children and the tech giants28/05/2019 15:10:00
This year marks two important anniversaries: it is thirty years since the creation of the World Wide Web, and of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.
Many vulnerable children with learning disabilities are stuck in mental health hospitals for too long in poor conditions21/05/2019 09:20:00
Anne Longfield, the Children’s Commissioner for England, yesterday published a new report, ‘Far less than they deserve: Children with learning disabilities or autism living in mental health hospitals’.
The World Wide Web at 30: Re-imagining a web built for children20/05/2019 13:20:00
Between 9 – 10 May, the Children’s Commissioner for England, Anne Longfield, hosted a conference on children’s digital rights at BBC Salford for ENOC – the network of Children’s Commissioners and Ombudsmen from all over Europe.
Almost 1,500 children in England are locked up by the state at a cost of a third of a billion a year16/05/2019 16:05:00
Anne Longfield, the Children’s Commissioner for England, is today publishing a report shining a light on the hundreds of children in England who are locked up in institutions across the country.