Ministry of Justice
Hiring technical people in government is (not that) hard
There were more than 50% of contractors in technical roles when I joined MoJ in April 2018. In a technical workforce of about 200 that’s a lot of contractors.
Hiring technical people in government is hard, they said. Let’s find out, I thought.
MoJ had a recruitment freeze when I joined. It thawed in October 2018 and I began recruiting technical roles the following month. By July 2019 the results exceeded my expectations:
- 55 offers
- 3 declined
- 52 accepted
The numbers break down as follows:
- 43 male*
- 12 female
- 13 BAME (11 male, 2 female)
*7 existing contractors applied and became permanent staff.
I started by using the recruitment freeze to my advantage and used that time to gather information, ask for help and form a plan.
I wanted to find out why people felt technical recruitment in government was so hard. The dominant themes were:
- civil service salary bands were too low to attract technical talent
- background checks can take a long time, causing candidates to drop out
- the internal process was unclear and confusing for interview panel members.
Asking for help
Next, I needed to find people willing to help. I asked the technical community for volunteers. 30 software developers, web operations engineers and technical architects stepped forward. I proceeded to arrange recruitment training for them all.
Forming a plan
Step 1: Create a partnership with our Recruitment team
I formed a close working relationship with our Recruitment team. The team was instrumental in my success.
Three key changes proved critical to achieving great results:
- a new recruitment platform giving hiring managers real-time access to candidate applications
- faster turnaround of candidate background checks, reduced from three months to about five weeks
- a new interim Digital Data and Technology salary framework offering competitive market rate salaries.
Step 2: Design a clear internal process
I knew I'd be managing concurrent campaigns for several months (as many as 15 at one point!). I was looking for mids, seniors and leads in software development, web operations and technical architecture. Campaigns would be aligned to our UK regions; London, Birmingham/Nottingham and Sheffield. My process had to be slick and purr away in the background, I still had a day job after all! Here’s what worked:
Staying on top of things
- I met weekly with a contact in each MoJ agency/business unit to plan requirements and update on progress.
- I met weekly with the Recruitment team to track offers and discuss new and ongoing campaigns.
- We ran rolling campaigns and kept them open until available roles were filled.
- Tracked campaign details and offers in a shared spreadsheet.
Managing interview panels
- I assembled diverse interview panels (three members) before each campaign went live.
- I asked each panel to agree a day-of-week they would hold as flexible for possible interviews.
- I managed communication with panels in temporary private Slack channels set up for each campaign.
- I shared the job advert, job description and CV sift sheet with each panel so they understood the role(s) to be filled.
CV review and interview scheduling
- I ensured quality and consistency by reviewing every CV submitted to every campaign, along with a member of each relevant panel (Mondays and Thursdays weekly worked best).
- I entered CV review outcomes into the recruitment platform.
- I emailed our Recruitment team to request interviews for shortlisted candidates immediately after each review (the panel had agreed a day-of-week to be flexible so there was no need to wrangle diaries!).
- I reviewed panel scores and feedback for all interviews across all campaigns.
- Agreed salary figures based on panel feedback.
- The Recruitment team made offers and negotiated with candidates.
In time, I was able to delegate hiring responsibility to the leads I had recruited in each MoJ agency/business unit.
Step 3: Advertising
As well as appearing on our MOJ job board, our vacancies were cross-posted on some technical job boards. We also promoted them on social media, highlighting the benefits of joining the civil service:
- average 22% employer contribution (percentage depends on salary)
- flexible working through the Civil Service Smarter Working initiative
- outstanding access to learning & development.
I’ve started creating detailed role-level definitions. I’m publishing these to help candidates prepare for their interview. They will also help interview panels assess and score candidate answers consistently.
Here are our role level definitions for the technical architecture profession:
Expectations for each behaviour are clearly defined. Within each behaviour I define one or more complementary strengths.
Expectations for each technical skill are clearly defined. These are based on the Skills Framework for the Information Age (SFIA). Each skill is linked back to the Digital, Data and Technology Capability Framework.
I’ve also created a new bank of 100 interview questions. Each question relates to a behaviour and strength or technical skill in the role-level definitions. We can use these to create bespoke interview questionnaires for each campaign. Panel members can check each interview question against the relevant role-level definition for guidance on scoring candidate answers fairly.
Hiring technical people in government is not that hard...if you can offer market rate salaries, run a slick process and properly support the people involved.
I am committed to ensuring MoJ has the clearest, most open and supportive recruitment experience government can offer. For both candidates and colleagues who agree to take part in this important process.
Latest News from
Ministry of Justice
16 jails to receive X-ray scanners24/01/2020 12:05:00
Tough new security measures will be introduced at 16 of the most challenging jails – a major part of the government’s crackdown on crime behind bars.
Serious violent and sexual offenders to spend longer in prison22/01/2020 15:15:15
Serious violent and sexual criminals will face more time behind bars under Government plans to better protect the public and restore confidence in the justice system.
Tougher sentencing and monitoring in government overhaul of terrorism response22/01/2020 11:12:00
Tougher sentences, an end to early release and a review of the management of convicted terrorists among measures announced to strengthen the UK’s response to terrorism.
Court fee refund scheme now open20/01/2020 10:15:00
Applications are now open for anyone who believes they may have paid too much for some court services between April 2014 and March 2018.
Lord Chancellor welcomes new Queen’s Counsel17/01/2020 10:15:00
Her Majesty The Queen has approved the appointment of 114 new Queen's Counsel.
Cameras to broadcast from the Crown Court for first time16/01/2020 13:15:00
Television cameras will be allowed to broadcast from Crown Courts in England and Wales for the first time, following draft legislation due to be laid by the government today (16 January 2020).
Challenges faced and techniques used for onboarding 120 prisons15/01/2020 13:15:00
Blog posted by: Ansgar Kupper, 14 January 2020 – Categories: Our services, User research.
Accessibility profession project10/01/2020 12:15:00
Blog posted by: Beverley Newing, 9 January 2020 – Categories: Accessibility, Our services.