How can we ensure that enterprise and trading is fair for people experiencing homelessness? Survey responses needed
Blog posted by: Martin Burrows, Tuesday, 22 March 2022.
New research commissioned by Homeless Link explores how social enterprise and organisations with trading activities can ensure that the way they work is fair for those involved.
In a system that can often be ‘unfair’ it’s important that organisations working with people experiencing homelessness embrace fairness in the way they work. Our new research explores how involvement in charitable trading can be fair for all.
During my time working at Groundswell I witnessed the incredible contribution that my colleagues, many of whom had current or very recent experience of homelessness, made towards tackling inequality. I also saw the transformative power volunteering could have on people’s lives. However, it was an ongoing challenge to ensure that what people ‘give’ balances with what they ‘get’ in return. When people have got used to the raw deal of homelessness, they may feel indebted or lack the confidence to speak up. And when that balance isn’t right it can create feelings of unfairness and resentments. Our work can have unintended consequences that it would pay to be mindful of.
For social enterprise and trading where there is an inherent tension between business objectives and social goals, the issue becomes further apparent. At the forefront is how people are compensated for their contribution, clarity of roles and managing expectations. A common question (and sometimes criticism) is why aren’t people being paid? The answer is never simple, particularly when navigating the benefit system. However, ensuring that the offer of support, training, expenses and a positive experience is counterbalance to the contribution is essential.
Initial research by our team at Inclusive Insight has revealed that this topic is not a fringe issue and that many organisations with trading activities are battling with this dilemma. However, there is a lack of evidence and shared good practice. In recent years we have seen an increase in organisations exploring trading models as a means to diversify income or offer opportunities to service users with the best intentions. We are striving to support those intentions with implementable models of best practise, but we need your help to get there.
We are looking for social enterprises and charitable organisations with trading activities or business models that offer training, employment or volunteering opportunities to participate in this research. First by completing a survey that will help us map the types of enterprise, understand involvement opportunities and to identify good practice. By taking part it will help to address one of the major issues in charitable trading and enterprise and create an aspirational framework for social enterprises working towards ending homelessness.
In this research we plan to explore the grey areas, where issues with fairness and power imbalances can present themselves. A key example is when volunteers have similar duties to paid members of staff. Some of the existing literature tells us that the closer a volunteer role is to a paid role, the more likely it is to move people towards being ‘employment ready’. However, at what point does this become unfair, or even exploitative?
Our work so far has also revealed the sheer diversity of enterprises and trading activities that involve people experiencing homelessness. The survey we are launching will map and investigate different models of working, opportunities for involvement, support offered and how different approaches can impact on social outcomes. This is the first time a mapping exercise of this type has been undertaken in England. Survey responses are anonymous and takes around 20-30 minutes to complete and there’s a £100 prize draw for participant organisations. We hope it will provide the evidence needed to improve practice for all.
Response from Murphy Hopkins-Hubbard:
During my time at Homeless Link we have worked across two cohorts of the Enterprise Development Programme. Now, in the next phase of our work we are looking for ways to share our knowledge, challenge assumptions and support our membership to access the best advice and frameworks to develop their work. This research project hopes to explore how we can best engage service users, to provide a framework for organisations questioning the right thing to do and to support people to map the impact and theory of change of this engagement.
We hope that the sector will support us to do this well and based of our findings we plan to create a small grant pot to support organisations using trading models to implement the best practice frameworks identified.
Latest News from
New member: Impact Initiatives30/01/2023 14:10:00
We're delighted to welcome Impact Initiatives as a new member of Homeless Link!
Third episode of new series of Going Beyond podcast with Ben Neal30/01/2023 13:10:00
This is the first episode of the second series of Going Beyond, a podcast for people working in the homelessness sector.
New episode of going Beyond podcast with Andy Phee23/01/2023 15:25:00
In the second episode of Season 2, we speak with Andy Phee, mindfulness practitioner and teacher at Oxford University’s Mindfulness Centre. Andy also works at EASL (Enabling Assessments Service London), a community interest company and mental health team who work collaboratively with homelessness services across London in providing assessments for homeless individuals experiencing poor mental health and in helping staff teams to develop psychologically informed environments.
Energy bill discount scheme: More uncertainty and less support leaves the sector vulnerable23/01/2023 14:25:00
Since October last year, the Government has provided relief on rapidly rising energy costs for businesses including charities through the Energy Bill Relief Scheme (EBRS). This support has been vital, but earlier this month the Treasury chose to ignore our calls for further assistanceand announced it will be significantly reducing the level of support from April onwards, in a move that marks yet more uncertainty for the homelessness sector.
Homeless Link signs joint letter calling for greater energy support for charities23/01/2023 11:15:00
Homeless Link has signed a letter together with NCVO, Hospice UK, Age UK and Women's Aid Federation England, calling on the Government to introduce increased support for charities struggling to pay inflated energy bill.
Advocating to protect local homelessness budgets19/01/2023 13:10:00
Across the country, local authorities are working to finalise their budgets for 2023/24. While many will have already published their draft budgets, these are not set in stone. January and February of each year represent an intense period of negotiation, with different sections of local government all putting their case forward to avoid cuts to their funding.
Accredited qualification applications now open19/01/2023 12:10:00
Applications are now open for the new Level 3 Certificate in Providing Homelessness Services qualification.
Leading homelessness organisations warn of devastating impact of not extending energy support16/12/2022 15:20:00
On 15th December 2022, 34 of the country's leading homelessness organisations wrote to to the Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Grant Shapps, warning of the “devastating” impact of not extending the Government’s Energy Bill Relief Scheme (EBRS) beyond March 2023.