IEA - Government should scrap apprenticeship levy, focus on improving education
Len Shackleton responds to Public Accounts Committee report
Commenting on a Public Accounts Committee report, which finds that apprenticeship reforms are failing to deliver, the IEA’s Editorial and Research Fellow Prof Len Shackleton said:
“The failure of the government’s policy on apprenticeships, like so many other schemes in the past, is no surprise; it was widely predicted. The levy has turned out to be a crude payroll tax. Businesses – which have no obvious need for or means of generating apprenticeships – are simply subsidising others. Even those who want to develop apprenticeships have found the inevitable bureaucracy debilitating and disincentivising.
“The essentially mediaeval concept of an apprenticeship made sense in a world where career paths were clear and industries lasted for generations. It is much more suited to manufacturing and to craft skills, which is why it continues to be of some significance in countries like Germany. The skills needed in Britain, with its focus on innovative services and high-tech start-ups, cannot in the main be taught by time-served graduates of apprenticeship systems.
“The levy should be scrapped. In areas where genuine apprenticeships – rather than schemes cobbled together to attract government funding – still make sense, the focus should be on potential apprentices rather than businesses. A form of loan system could enable young people to access high-quality training schemes which employers voluntarily provide.
“Government efforts should be confined to improving the quality of general education in schools – which would do more to boost future employment prospects and productivity than yet more attempts to recreate a mass apprenticeship culture.”
View report: The apprenticeships programme: progress review
Latest News from
IPPR North: 1 in 4 North East Public Sector Jobs Lost Since Austerity Began20/06/2019 11:35:00
Stark figures released yesterday show that the North East has seen the biggest percentage cut to public sector workers of all of England’s regions.
NIESR reacts to the latest ONS CPI inflation statistics20/06/2019 11:33:00
According to figures released yesterday by the ONS, consumer price index inflation decreased by 0.1 percentage points to 2.0 per cent in the year to May 2019.
IFS - Big increases in in-work relative poverty rate are about much more than just low pay20/06/2019 10:35:00
Big increases in in-work relative poverty rate are about much more than just low pay
Employ migrants in jobs that match their qualifications to boost economy by £7bn, says IPPR20/06/2019 09:35:00
Investing in integration would boost productivity by using the untapped skills of migrant workers
IEA - UK farming industry can prosper unshackled from the Common Agricultural Policy18/06/2019 11:35:00
IEA report sets out proposals for agriculture, post-Brexit
IEA - The Chancellor is right to emphasise the importance of fiscal responsibility18/06/2019 09:35:00
Kate Andrews, Associate Director at the Institute of Economic Affairs responded to the Chancellor’s plea to keep national debt falling every year
IFG - Candidates for Prime Minister must prepare now13/06/2019 10:35:00
Conservative MPs who want to become Prime Minister must think beyond the immediate leadership contest and face the practical challenges of being head of government.
NIESR Monthly Wage Tracker: Public sector earnings growth provides a temporary boost to whole-economy wages12/06/2019 11:51:00
Public sector earnings growth provides a temporary boost to whole-economy wages.