IFG - Costs of creating a new government department revealed
The incoming – or returning – prime minister may want to stamp his or her authority on government by rearranging departments, but new research lays bare the total costs involved in creating new departments.
Creating and dismantling government departments finds the direct costs of creating a new department start at £15 million, with a further estimated cost of up to £34 million when including loss of productivity as staff adjust to the new organisation.
Moving policy areas between government departments – or creating completely new departments – is one of the prime minister’s key levers of power. But many of the most recent changes seem to have been made without proper forethought and have – in some cases – ended up costing more than any benefits returned.
The authors argue that, while creating a new department can be useful to focus on a high priority issue or to bring together related policy areas, most changes are rushed through either to send a political signal or to reward allies. These changes can end up causing confusion and the hassle of setting up a new organisation distracts from the problem the government wanted to solve.
Tim Durrant, Institute for Government associate director, said:
“Whoever becomes prime minister may want to signal change by moving departments and creating new ones. Instead of making rapid changes and expecting the new department to be up and running immediately, the incoming prime minister should think through what exactly the new department should do, spending time and money to get it up to speed.”
Gemma Tetlow, Institute for Government chief economist, said:
“Jeremy Corbyn has previously suggested two new departments – for labour and housing – and senior Conservative figures, like Dominic Raab, have suggested merging international development into the Foreign Office. But unless these changes are properly planned, the costs can largely outstrip the benefits.”
Notes to editors
Latest News from
NIESR: Boosting digital infrastructure will help close regional gaps05/12/2019 14:20:00
Significant investment in digital infrastructure to increase the coverage of ultrafast and full fibre internet for everyone in the UK may help to reduce regional disparities as the access is unevenly distributed across the country, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Social and Economic Research.
NIESR: Productivity improvement needed to raise living standards05/12/2019 10:20:00
The next government must follow a robust, methodical and wide-ranging approach to kickstart a recovery in productivity growth in order to mend the “slow puncture” in UK economic growth, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Social and Economic Research.
Researchers need to work harder to combat misinformation online, says Demos04/12/2019 14:20:00
A new report from Demos looking into how research and development is discussed and communicated about online shows the need for researchers to work harder to be a bigger part of the online conversation, in order to combat the rise of misinformation.
IEA: Evidence so far suggests minimum pricing in Scotland has been “an expensive flop”04/12/2019 13:15:00
Head of Lifestyle Economics at the Institute of Economic Affairs Christopher Snowdon commented on new evidence from the Office for National Statistics showing that the number of alcohol-related deaths fell in England by 145, fell in Wales by 13 and rose in Scotland by 16
Manifesto Promises: CSJ reports03/12/2019 11:35:00
Election manifestos provide an important reality check for organisations like the Centre for Social Justice. It is a clear indication, in black and white, as to whether government is listening to us and whether we are having an impact.
The King's Fund comments on new GP workforce figures and NHS vacancy data03/12/2019 10:35:00
Sally Warren, Director of Policy at The King’s Fund commented on new GP workforce figures and NHS vacancy data from NHS Digital
Policy Exchange - Time to plant – and harvest – more trees03/12/2019 09:35:00
All political parties agree that the UK needs more trees, but stimulating markets to support forestry and supporting sustainable wood use also needs to be part of land policy after Brexit, argues a new paper from Policy Exchange’s award-winning Energy and Environment unit.
NIESR: Tough lessons for new government on raising education standards28/11/2019 11:25:00
The incoming government must embark on a wholesale reform of the education from nursery schools through to adult education to help close gaps between the UK and other comparable economies, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Social and Economic Research.
NIESR: Hiking minimum wage too fast may undermine policy’s success27/11/2019 11:20:00
Raising minimum wage levels too quickly risks undermining the strong consensus between employers, workers and political parties that has been built up during the past two decades, especially if the increases lead to falls in employment that are difficult to reverse, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR).