IFG - Government underspending puts investment plans at risk
As Rishi Sunak prepares the Johnson government’s first budget, a new Institute for Government report finds that departments may struggle to spend the money they are allocated as part of Johnson’s ambitious infrastructure investment plans.
The 2019 Conservative manifesto committed to investing up to an additional £100bn over the next five years on areas such as de-carbonisation, further education, and research and development.
But previous governments have struggled to meet their investment plans. The Major, Blair, and Brown governments did not spend as much as they planned. Continuing this pattern, the coalition, Cameron and May governments all underspent on their capital budgets every year from 2011/12 to 2018/19. Underspending stood consistently at 3–6% in this period. In 2018/19, the latest year for which data is available, £2.8bn went unspent, representing 4% of the total budget.
Capital Investment: Why governments fail to meet their spending plans outlines how government can better set capital budgets that will actually be spent – and spent well – by analysing the problems that have caused persistent underspending:
- Over the last 10 years, governments have transferred money intended for capital investment to meet day-to-day spending pressures.
- Over-optimism in planning construction projects has caused delays down the line.
- Reductions in civil service staff numbers mean that some departments lack enough, or the right, staff to spend capital budgets efficiently.
- Departments have struggled to agree contracts with private companies because they have tried to transfer excessive risk to construction companies.
Ramping up investment spending will also be difficult. The construction sector may not have enough engineers, project managers and construction workers to deliver a rapid increase in government projects – a problem that may be made more difficult by post-Brexit immigration policy.
Graham Atkins, Institute for Government senior researcher, said:
“The Johnson government has ambitious promises to invest in infrastructure, but promises do not complete projects. Successive governments’ persistent underspending over the last decade suggests these plans will be difficult to implement.
The government will need credible plans – realistic expectations about the time and cost it will take to complete projects, and appropriately qualified staff within departments – in order to spend capital budgets.”
Notes to editors
- Capital investment: Why governments fail to meet their spending plans can be found on our website.
- The Institute for Government is an independent think tank that works to make government more effective.
- For more information, including data to reproduce any charts, please contact firstname.lastname@example.org / 0785 031 3791.
Latest News from
IEA - Steps to help self-employed “unlikely to be the last” Chancellor has to take27/03/2020 15:15:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on Chancellor Rishi Sunak’s plans to support the self-employed during the Covid-19 pandemic
JRF - Government must go further to protect people on low incomes from impact of coronavirus27/03/2020 13:15:00
New JRF briefing briefing urges the Government to go further to protect people on low incomes from the impact of coronavirus.
IPPR - Take a 30 per cent stake in virus-hit airlines, and hold shares in a new UK wealth fund, Chancellor urged26/03/2020 11:35:00
Price of ‘bailing out’ any companies should be equity which will generate long-term returns, say economists in IPPR discussion paper
IEA - Gender pay gap figures “never fit for purpose”26/03/2020 10:35:00
IEA responds to government decision to suspend enforcement of gender pay gap reporting in light of the Covid-19 pandemic
Lift restrictions on migrants’ rights to help limit the spread of Covid-19, says IPPR26/03/2020 09:35:00
New IPPR analysis reveals migrants are more vulnerable to economic and health fallout of the virus outbreak
Civitas - Human rights laws should be decided democratically in Britain – the constitution needs rebalancing24/03/2020 11:35:00
The Human Rights Act should be abolished as Britain seeks to regain the ability to decide its own human rights laws within its own democratic public sphere, a new Civitas publication argues.
IPPR - Think tanks call for bailout conditions for airlines to secure jobs and deliver climate justice24/03/2020 10:35:00
New analysis shows that two major airlines have paid out dividends in excess of £2.6 billion since 2014, while the sector is underpaying corporation tax
JRF - Coronavirus: supporting our partners24/03/2020 09:35:00
Many are deeply concerned about the fast-moving situation with Coronavirus. At JRF we know we are a just and compassionate society, and we rely on one another for support in difficult times.