IFG - Spending more is no guarantee of success – the impact of 20 years of devolution on public services across the UK
With just one week to go before Scottish and Welsh elections, a new Institute for Government report, published today, has revealed big differences in the performance of public services across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland over the last two decades.
Since their creation in 1999, the devolved governments have chosen to fund and run public services in very different ways. While the way they also choose to compile data is a real obstacle to comparison, our report Devolved Public Services: The NHS, schools, and social care in the four nations reveals the extent to which public service performance has diverged across the UK from 1999 to the start of the coronavirus pandemic in 2020. All the devolved nations spend more than England but all three have higher rates of treatable mortality – deaths that could be prevented through timely and effective health care interventions – and by 2018 all three had lower maths and science results.
Spending per person in Scotland and Northern Ireland is 29% higher than spending per person on comparable services in England, and 23% higher in Wales. Scotland spends the most per person on health and schools – and also has the most doctors, nurses, teachers and care workers. But this is not matched in performance.
The biggest differences are in education. The IfG paper reveals that:
- As of 2017/18, Scotland spent 9% more per pupil than England but Scottish pupils achieved significantly lower results in international PISA maths and science tests.
- Welsh pupils consistently achieve lower scores in international tests than pupils in the other three nations.
- By age 15 Welsh pupils’ reading ability is now about six months’ worth of schooling behind pupils in the other three nations.
There are also striking differences in health performance, with the report showing that:
- In March 2020, almost 40% of patients on waiting lists in Northern Ireland had been waiting longer than a year just to get an appointment – compared to only 0.1% of patients on waiting lists in England.
- In March 2020, the median waiting time for elective care in Wales was eleven weeks, over two weeks longer than in England.
- After 2015, Scotland consistently admitted, discharged or transferred a higher proportion of A&E patients within four hours than England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.
The last 20 years provide a fascinating – and sobering - experiment for policy makers to learn from each other. For the four nations to do so, the IfG report recommends:
- The Treasury regularly publish its analysis of the level of spending on comparable public services in each nation and region of the UK.
- The four governments work to improve the comparability of public service performance data.
- The four governments must work to fill key data gaps in unpaid social care, private funding. of social care, and educational attainment before age 15.
- The Treasury and devolved administrations jointly conduct or commission a new assessment of the relative spending needs of each part of the UK.
IfG senior researcher and report author Graham Atkins said:
“Devolution offered Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland the opportunity to run public services differently. After two decades, public services now look very different. Some policy decisions have been had beneficial results while others have not – in particular, Scotland spends more on schools but does not appear to deliver better outcomes.
Unfortunately, it has become increasingly difficult to compare performance. The four governments must now prioritise improving data comparability to allow policy makers to collect and analyse data to improve public services in each nation.”
Notes to editors
Latest News from
Healthy meals, healthy planet – IPPR calls for food system shake up to fight climate crisis and food poverty07/05/2021 11:25:00
Think tank calls for expansion of free school meals, healthy food voucher scheme and end to environmentally harmful foods
King's Fund - New analysis shows ‘widespread decline’ in adult social care06/05/2021 15:05:00
New figures reveal the dire state of England's social care sector before the pandemic, with more people requesting support but fewer getting the help they needed. The data puts further pressure on the government to commit to reform of social care in next week’s Queen’s Speech.
“Excellent news”: IEA Fellow comments on UK-India trade and investment deals05/05/2021 12:15:00
IEA Fellow and Competere CEO Shanker Singham responded to the Prime Minister’s announcement of new trade and investment deals with India
IEA - No need for “emergency measures” to manage national debt, says new research04/05/2021 10:35:00
New IEA research paper ‘UK Debt in Perspective’, authored by Professors Forrest Capie and Geoffrey Wood, gives historical context to the current UK debt figures, which currently stand at around 100 per cent of national income.
Adam Smith Inst - UK Gov will miss Brexit chance to make 2030 smoke free04/05/2021 09:30:00
In the UK, around 78,000 people die every year as a consequence of smoking with and many more live with the misery of debilitating smoking-related diseases. While the number of smokers has fallen in recent years the Government is not on track to meet its target of being ‘smoke-free by 2030’, which means having an adult smoking prevalence of 5% or less.
Proposed ban on zero-hours contracts “completely the wrong move”, says IEA expert03/05/2021 09:15:00
Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to the TUC’s demands for the government to ban zero-hours contracts
JRF hails High Court bid to end discrimination against legacy benefit claimants30/04/2021 09:15:00
The High Court has granted claimants of Employment Support Allowance permission to challenge the Department for Work and Pensions’ decision not to increase their benefit in line with Universal Credit.
Modern Monetary Theory cannot deliver long-term growth, says new IEA research29/04/2021 14:25:00
New IEA research, authored by the Director of the Institute of International Monetary Research Juan E. Castañeda, highlights shortcomings of Modern Monetary Theory (MMT).
IFS - The growing size of inheritances is set to reduce social mobility for younger generations29/04/2021 12:25:00
Inheritances have been growing as a share of national income in the UK since the 1970s. That trend looks set to continue: older generations hold more wealth than their predecessors and younger generations have incomes no higher than the generations born just before them. As a result, inheritances will be an increasingly important part of lifetime income and wealth.