IFS - Government to take big spending decisions with little idea how sustainable they will prove
With pledges on schools, further education, the NHS, defence and overseas aid, day-to-day spending on these public services is already set to be at least £9 billion higher next year than this year.
The Chancellor will need to find a way to fund an extra £5 billion of spending next year, relative to plans published at the Spring Statement, just to avoid cuts to other public services. Increasing spending on other priority areas would require even greater funding.
OBR figures at Spring Statement time gave the government £15 billion of headroom against its target to keep borrowing below 2% of national income next year. This looks like plenty to allow a decisive break with austerity. Given that the spending round will not be accompanied by new OBR forecasts the Chancellor is likely to announce spending increases and claim he is meeting his fiscal targets.
But with economic forecasts deteriorating, even when a Brexit deal is assumed, if we do get such a break with austerity the next OBR report could show that we are not on course to keep borrowing below 2% of national income. Whether that would be consistent with the fiscal target to keep borrowing below 2% of national income on a cyclically adjusted basis would depend on the OBR’s view of the extent to which any slowdown represented just temporary weakness as opposed to a permanent hit to the economy.
With a no deal Brexit borrowing is likely to be much higher – by £30 billion according to the OBR even in a relatively optimistic scenario.
Making major fiscal announcements without new OBR forecasts risk a return to the bad old days when chancellors could make fiscal claims not based on the best available independent forecasts.
These are among the findings of a new report looking at options for this week’s spending round. Other findings include:
- Government borrowing last year was at a 17 year low. This follows a reduction in total public spending from 45% of national income in 2009−10 to 38% in 2018−19 (which is where it was in 2003−4);
- In real terms public spending is at about the same level as it was in 2009-10, but population increase means that spending per person has fallen by more than 6%.
- Spending by the Home Office, Ministry of Justice and local government was more than 20% lower in 2018−19 than in 2009−10. Not surprisingly services provided by them have suffered particularly badly;
- Health spending, by contrast, has risen by nearly 20%. By 2022−23 health spending is set to account for 42% of all departmental spending, up from 23% in the year 2000;
Ben Zaranko, an author of the report said “Significant sums are already pledged for schools and the health service, more is coming for the police, and there are commitments on defence and aid spending. This spending round will, though, also need to consider very carefully the clear and growing need for funding in our justice system and in local government, including social care, where cuts over the past decade have been particularly severe”.
Rowena Crawford added “Based on OBR forecasts from the spring it looks like the Chancellor has plenty of room to meet his spending pledges, increase spending in some other priority areas and avoid any further cuts, while keeping to his pledge to keep borrowing below 2% of national income. But growth has slowed since the spring and in reality he may have a lot less than the £15 billion of headroom he seemed to have back then”.
Paul Johnson commented “Making big fiscal announcements in a period of great economic uncertainty means we will have little idea how sustainable or costly decisions made this week will be. The risks are exacerbated by not having up to date forecasts from the OBR. Fiscal events and forecasts should occur together if we are to maintain faith in a fiscal framework which has served us well in terms of transparency since it was introduced in 2010”.
Latest News from
Public sector pay freeze “appropriate” at this time, says IEA expert24/11/2020 11:35:00
Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at the free-market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to reports that the Treasury will announce a public sector pay freeze in this week’s Spending Review
IFS - Minimum unit pricing works better if implemented alongside reformed alcohol taxes24/11/2020 10:35:00
The UK government has put out a call for evidence, seeking views on how well the alcohol duty system currently works and how it could be reformed. In new IFS research – funded by the European Research Council and the Economic and Social Research Council and published last week- we show that minimum unit prices for alcohol are reasonably well targeted at heavy drinkers, but come at the cost of hindering competition and reducing tax revenues. A minimum unit price, combined with a more coherent set of taxes on alcohol, would be just as well targeted at heavy drinkers and would limit the fall in revenue for the exchequer.
£164 billion stimulus needed to stave off permanently shrunken UK economy, IPPR warns Chancellor24/11/2020 09:35:00
The UK economy needs an ambitious cash injection of £164 billion in the year 2021-22, according to new analysis by IPPR, to restart it fully after the Covid crisis and set it on course for a fair, strong and green recovery.
IFS - Lack of job opportunities helps drive record rise in solo self-employment19/11/2020 11:40:00
Self-employment has risen dramatically in the UK. This rise has been entirely driven by ‘solo’ self-employment – sole traders and owner-managers with no employees. By the end of 2019, there were nearly 4 million solo self-employed workers, up from 2.3 million in 2000. The level and growth of solo self-employment in the UK are among the highest in OECD countries.
IPPR - Winter Covid debt warning: young people, ethnic minorities, and renters at most financial risk19/11/2020 10:35:00
Think tank reveals 10 per cent were behind on bills before pandemic hit and people expect a one in seven chance of falling behind on bills
IEA responds to the Prime Minister’s plan for a green industrial revolution19/11/2020 09:35:00
Mark Littlewood, Director General of the free-market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to the government’s 10-point plan for a green industrial revolution
JRF - 2.5 million households worried about paying rent over winter, with 700,000 already in arrears and 350,000 at risk of eviction17/11/2020 10:35:00
Protections put in place at the start of the pandemic are not working for large numbers of renters. Renters on lower incomes are being hit hardest, and many are using up their limited savings, cutting back on essentials and borrowing money to stay afloat.
Road pricing should not be a ‘post-covid cash cow’, says IEA expert17/11/2020 09:35:00
Professor Philip Booth responds to road pricing proposals