Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC - formerly IPCC)
Improvements to how domestic abuse is investigated by Hertfordshire Constabulary made following the deaths of Lee Guntrip and Sarah Nash
Improved training, information sharing and policies on investigating domestic abuse allegationsare in place at Hertfordshire Constabulary following an IOPC investigation launched after the deaths of Sarah Nash and Lee Guntrip.
Mr Guntrip, 25, and Ms Nash, 37, were found dead at her home, in Berkhamsted, on 23 June 2016. Due to prior contact with Hertfordshire Constabulary a referral was made to the IOPC and an investigation was launched.
Our investigation, completed in November 2017, identified areas where improvement could be made to how the force handles allegations of domestic abuse.
We made seven learning recommendations, of which six were accepted.
The learning centered on improvements to the systems in place, and training of staff working within Hertfordshire Constabulary’s domestic abuse investigation and safeguarding unit (DAISU), to the sharing of information between the DAISU and custody and how risk assessments of domestic abuse victims are made and recorded.
They can be read in full here
We also concluded that three officers may have breached standards of professional behaviour and, following discussions with Hertfordshire Constabulary, it was agreed they would attend a misconduct meeting.
In May 2018 at the misconduct meeting it was ruled two officers had committed misconduct. One officer was given management advice and the other a written warning. The allegations against the third officer were found not proven by the chair.
IOPC regional director Sarah Green yesterday said:
“Investigating this tragic incident, we found evidence the police were aware of the abusive relationship, in which Ms Nash was a high risk victim.
“It became apparent that improvements could be made to how situations like this were handled by Hertfordshire Constabulary and I am pleased that the force has taken these on board and implemented them.
“We also concluded that three officers may have breached standards of professional behaviour and a panel later ruled that two of the police officers, tasked with investigating an allegation of attacks made by Ms Nash, failed to do so to an acceptable standard.
“Figures from the Office of National Statistics show that two women in the UK are murdered by a partner or ex-partner every week. Ensuring people who are in an abusive relationship have the confidence to seek police help, and then are afforded proper protection, is clearly a vital step towards reducing the number of terrible incidents such as the murder of Ms Nash.”
Our investigation found Hertfordshire Constabulary first became aware of domestic abuse against Ms Nash by Mr Guntrip on 21 August 2015.
Police were called after Mr Guntrip assaulted Ms Nash, and he was arrested and charged. He pleaded guilty to assault by battery and causing actual bodily harm and was sentenced to a community order with rehabilitation requirements in January 2016.
On 3 June 2016, Ms Nash reported further assaults to police. Mr Guntrip was arrested but, after spending time in custody, was bailed without charge on 4 June. He was bailed to return to the station on 22 June, and then was re-bailed on 22 June.
His bail conditions were to not contact Ms Nash, directly or indirectly, and not to enter her road. He was bailed to his home address, which was eight doors away from Ms Nash’s home.
Our investigation examined the actions by officers involved in the arrest, detention and investigation of Mr Guntrip, and the decision not to refer him to the Crown Prosecution Service for a charging decision. We also examined the decision making by officers with regards to Mr Guntrip’s bail conditions.
Finally we examined the actions and decision making of officers when Mr Guntrip was re-bailed on 22 June, the day before the pair died, instead of being charged with any offence.
The two officers for whom misconduct was found proven were found to have breached standards in how they investigated the allegations made by Ms Nash, the breaches of bail conditions, and Mr Guntrip’s re-bail on 22 June.
The result of our investigation, completed in 2017, is being published now following the conclusion of an inquest into the deaths.
The full investigation report can be read here.
Latest News from
Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC - formerly IPCC)
IOPC re-emphasises warnings about the dangers of swallowing packages following investigation into the death of Oghene Abboh21/08/2019 16:20:00
The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) is re-emphasising the dangers of swallowing packages of drugs to avoid prosecution following the conclusion of an inquest into the death of Oghene Abboh.
Police pursuit before fatal Leicestershire collision was carried out appropriately21/08/2019 12:20:00
Our investigation into a fatal collision at Oadby in Leicestershire concluded that a police pursuit which preceded it was carried out appropriately and in accordance with force policies.
Five officers referred to the CPS following the death of a man in Greater Manchester21/08/2019 09:10:00
Following an investigation into the actions of Greater Manchester Police (GMP) prior to the death of 30 year-old Portuguese man Andre Moura, evidence will be referred to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in relation to the actions of five of their officers.
Changes made to North Wales Police policy for domestic abuse incidents following Laura Stuart investigation16/08/2019 13:15:00
Improvements have been made to how North Wales Police deal with domestic abuse following an investigation into prior police contact with murder victim Laura Stuart.
Metropolitan Police Officer charged with common assault15/08/2019 10:10:00
A Metropolitan Police Service officer will appear at City of Westminster Magistrates Court on Thursday 29 August 2019 charged with common assault.
Investigation following fatal fire in Greater Manchester is complete14/08/2019 16:30:00
Our investigation into the contact Greater Manchester Police (GMP) had with a family, before a fatal fire, is complete.
Fresh appeal for witnesses to arrest and restraint of a man in Poplar13/08/2019 09:05:00
A fresh request for witnesses to an incident involving Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) officers and a member of the public on Abbott Road, Poplar is being issued.
Investigation following the death of Shukri Abdi in Greater Manchester09/08/2019 10:05:00
We have begun an investigation following the death of a 12-year-old girl in Bury.