Is Raissouni's Pardon Simply Playing Politics in Morocco?
Under pressure from both Islamist and secular groups - and the wider world - the decision to release a journalist looks like an attempt by Morocco's regime to restore control.
Moroccan journalist Hajar Raissouni is greeted by her boyfriend Rifaat Al Amine upon leaving prison after being granted a royal pardon (Photo by FADEL SENNA/AFP via Getty Images).
The decision by King Mohammed VI to grant a royal pardon for Hajar Raissouni - a Moroccan journalist detained along with her fiancé, a gynecologic doctor and his staff for allegedly 'illegal abortion' – has been pitched as an example of the 'clemency and mercy' of the king. But in reality, it appears the pardon has wider intentions - and is intended to try to kill three birds with one stone.
The first target is to try to end the current regime’s isolation, and prevent further media attacks against its restrictive practices. The accusations were never admitted by Raissouni and the others involved, resulting in wide criticism from both local and international media at a time when the regime was already under fire from human rights organizations for cracking down independent journalists and activists. It is being regularly claimed that the application of the country’s “penal code” is being abused as an instrument for political control of the regime’s opponents and outspoken journalists.
Certainly the Raissouni case does resonate with those claims because she is a journalist with outspoken Moroccan newspaper Akhbar Al Yaoum whose founder Taoufik Bouachrine was sentenced to 15 years prison for accusations of human trafficking, abuse of power for sexual purposes, rape and attempted rape. Accusations which he continues to deny and claims are politically motivated.
There were also suspicions that Raissouni’s arrest was motivated by her work as a journalist and her family ties. While in custody, she wrote a letter describing how she was interrogated about her political writings and about her two uncles: Ahmed Raissouni, the president of International Union of Muslim Scholars, and Soulaiman Raissouni, an outspoken and critical journalist. Her defence lawyer has even accused police of torture.
Growing public anger
A second perceived benefit of the pardon is to dissolve growing public anger over perceived abuses of individual and public freedoms. This incident sparked wide-range sympathy on social media and created a rare unanimity among different social forces around this cause.
Women and human rights activists as well as Islamists condemned the detention. Leila Slimani, a famous French-Moroccan author, and Sonia Terrab led an online campaign called hors la loi (outlaw), which called for the abolishment of article 490 of the penal law that punishes premarital sexual relations. Signatures to the campaign swelled to more than twelve thousand in just a few days.
Meanwhile, the AMDH, Morocco’s biggest human rights NGO, also launched a campaign of solidarity with Hajar Raissouni, calling for protests in front of parliament. Criticism came not only from independent activists, but also from voices inside the regime itself. The National Center for Human Rights (CNDH), the official human rights body, criticized media attacks on Hajar Raissouni and urged authorities to release her promptly. And the King’s cousin, Moulay Hicham expressed his concern about the future of the freedom of expression in the kingdom.
Finally, the third target for the regime is to try and kill off any chance of increased understanding between secular and Islamist groups, as the social mobilization around the case has led, albeit unintentionally, to a rapprochement between Islamists and seculars. Despite their disapproval of abortion and premarital sexual relations, Islamist movements adopted positions in favour of Hajar Raissouni.
The major Islamist group Adl wal Ihssan condemned the arrests with one of its leaders even stating the objective of it was 'to avenge opponents, opinion leaders and journalists'. Montada Karama for Human Rights, a close NGO to the PJD, argued the Hajar arrest was illegal and called for her immediate release. And the Unicity and reform (MUR), also close to the PJD, organized a conference on individual freedoms and criticized authorities' attempts to limit public freedoms.
Disagreements between these groups in regards of sexual and individual freedoms endure, yet the arrests of Raissouni was perceived by both of them as transgressions of freedom of expression and instrumentalization of individual liberties. Secular forces called for the abolition of these articles in the penal code and specifically article 490 that limit sexual and individual freedoms, while Islamists criticize the use of individual liberties to limit public freedoms.
Interestingly, both social forces started to coordinate around this issue, and it has been claimed meetings to coordinate their efforts were also held.
By releasing the journalist, the regime has certainly regained its upper hand. The king was praised on social media and news outlets and, more importantly, the release came at no cost to the existing penal code.
Divisions between Islamists and seculars have also re-opened since, as Ahmed Raissouni wrote an article criticizing individual freedoms, which has been widely criticized by seculars. Under pressure from the Islamists and seculars, and the wider world, the regime’s strategy appears to have been effective, with the three birds it has targeted successfully killed.
Latest News from
Climate, Food and Land14/11/2019 14:25:00
Tim Benton reflects on the relationship between land, food and climate change, and considers the challenges created by competing demands for the services land produces.
Brexit in a Historical Context: Pursuing a Global Vision at the Expense of Domestic Harmony?13/11/2019 09:20:00
The panel discusses how the notion, and rhetoric, of ‘Global Britain’ fares against different readings of Britain’s international history.
Five Lessons From the New Arab Uprisings12/11/2019 12:15:00
Georges Fahmi examines how protesters across the region have adapted their tactics after the experiences of the Arab Spring.
Why We Build Walls: 30 Years After the Fall of the Berlin Wall11/11/2019 13:20:00
Robin Niblett recently (08 November 2019) talked to Gitika Bhardwaj about the physical and psychological significance of border walls and their role in politics.
Why Britain’s 2019 Election Is Its Most Unpredictable in Recent History11/11/2019 09:20:00
Leadership concerns and a collapse of traditional party loyalties make the December vote uncommonly volatile.
Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi: What His Death Means For ISIS in Syria29/10/2019 12:20:00
Following the announcement of the death of ISIS group leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi in a US military raid, Lina Khatib explains what is likely to happen next.
Getting to a New Iran Deal: A Guide for Trump, Washington, Tehran, Europe and the Middle East22/10/2019 15:33:00
In the context of recent developments, this paper reviews US President Donald Trump’s Iran strategy and explores possible pathways to a new nuclear agreement with the Islamic Republic.
Is There a Way Forward in Hong Kong?22/10/2019 14:43:00
Tim Summers examines how to de-escalate the situation and balance competing interests in the territory.