Kings Fund - Cornerstone of NHS reforms faces uncertain future
Clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) have secured better engagement from GPs than previous forms of commissioning but still face numerous barriers to putting power in doctors’ hands, according to a new report published by The King’s Fund and the Nuffield Trust.
A survey of GPs and practice managers in six areas of the country, conducted annually since 2013, found that more than 70 per cent of CCG members were at least ‘somewhat’ engaged with the work of their CCG. This compares favourably with engagement levels under practice-based commissioning, the previous approach to involving GPs in commissioning that was implemented in 2005.
Despite the progress made, the report warns that CCGs’ clinically led model of commissioning is at risk if barriers to effective clinical involvement are not addressed. The research found that CCGs feel they need more autonomy to involve GPs in decisions about service design. There are also concerns that inadequate resourcing of CCGs is undermining efforts to develop high-quality, clinically led commissioning and that there is a lack political support when making tough decisions about priorities.
The report highlights concerns among GPs about their influence on commissioning decisions. In 2016 only 20 per cent of GPs without a formal role in their CCG reported that they could influence the work of their CCG if they chose to – down from 35 per cent in 2014. GPs felt that CCG managers still had more influence over commissioning decisions than GPs and that there had been little or no change in the quality of care in general practice as a result of their CCG.
The report, Clinical commissioning: GPs in charge?, is the culmination of a joint research project undertaken by The King’s Fund and the Nuffield Trust. Researchers followed six CCGs from their creation in 2012 to where they are today. The report aims to share learning from their experience about securing effective GP involvement in commissioning.
Ruth Robertson, Fellow in Health Policy at The King’s Fund, said: ‘Our research shows that while CCGs have made good progress in engaging GPs in local commissioning decisions, there remain significant barriers to effective clinical engagement and to translating this into improvements in quality of care.
‘The NHS must now build on CCGs’ achievements and do more to embed clinical involvement in planning decisions across the health care system. As well as properly supporting GP commissioners within CCGs, this means ensuring that GPs and other clinicians have a strong voice in the sustainability and transformation planning process and in the vanguards.
‘Engagement with GPs and other clinicians is crucial to efforts to transform out-of-hospital health and care provision and to move the NHS to a more financially sustainable position. In these challenging times for the health service, it is more important than ever that clinical engagement in commissioning decisions is properly supported.’
Holly Holder, Fellow in Policy at The Nuffield Trust, said: ‘Involving doctors and their colleagues in decisions about how NHS money is spent is very important. It won’t be possible to make the kind of changes at the front line we need to see without buy-in from people who actually deliver care.
‘We are now moving into a complicated world of multiple and overlapping organisations taking on some of the responsibilities that GP-led clinical commissioning groups were given in the 2012 reforms. This must not mean diluting the voice of GPs and alienating those who have contributed to CCGs over the past few years. We want to see national leaders say clearly that clinical commissioners will still have an important place in the future NHS. They must support CCGs to make taking part an attractive, rewarding career path for GPs – which we know it sometimes is not.’
Notes to editors:
The King’s Fund is an independent charity working to improve health and care in England. We help to shape policy and practice through research and analysis; develop individuals, teams and organisations; promote understanding of the health and social care system; and bring people together to learn, share knowledge and debate. Our vision is that the best possible care is available to all.
The Nuffield Trust is an independent health charity. We aim to improve the quality of health care in the UK by providing evidence-based research and policy analysis and informing and generating debate.
For further information, or to request an interview, please contact The King’s Fund Press and Public Affairs team on 020 7307 2585 (if calling out of hours, please ring 07584 146035).
Latest News from
JRF - Do leadership candidates’ plans match the scale of the coming emergency in the cost of living?09/08/2022 16:15:00
The latest analysis carried out by the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) shows families needing £2550 to meet extra costs from the current crisis.
IFS - Significant regional inequality in the effectiveness of cardiologists treating heart attack patients in England09/08/2022 13:25:00
New IFS research published today shows that there was considerable regional inequality in the effectiveness of doctors treating heart attack patients in different parts of England between 2005 and 2018. This suggests that people living in some parts of the country have access to lower quality NHS healthcare.
IFS - School spending per pupil in 2024 to remain 3% below 2010 levels in real-terms once you account for actual costs faced by schools02/08/2022 15:20:00
Between 2009-10 and 2019-20, we estimate that school spending per pupil in England fell by 9% in real-terms. In the 2019 and 2021 Spending Review, the government allocated extra funding to schools and explicitly stated that this would restore spending per pupil to 2010 levels in real-terms by the end of the parliament in 2024-25. Unexpectedly high cost pressures on schools mean that the government is no longer on track to deliver on this objective.
“Junk science”: IEA expert rubbishes claim TfL ‘junk food’ ad ban prevented almost 100,000 obesity cases02/08/2022 14:20:00
Christopher Snowdon, Head of Lifestyle Economics at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs responds to a study published in the International Journal of Behavioural Nutrition and Physical Activity claiming that Transport for London’s ban on ‘junk food’ advertising may have prevented 100,000 cases of obesity
IEA - Raise interest rates to 1.75 per cent immediately, votes Shadow Monetary Policy Committee02/08/2022 13:20:00
During the July 2022 Shadow MPC meeting, the key area of debate concerned the scale of the rise in Bank rate.
IFS - 110,000 workers missing from work as a result of long COVID at a cost of £1.5 billion a year in lost earnings27/07/2022 13:25:00
The number of people with long COVID (defined as reporting symptoms more than four weeks after infection) has been on the rise – with the latest ONS figures showing that there were almost 2 million people with the condition as of May 2022, around double the number a year before.
IPPR - Over £3 billion in unspent apprenticeship levy lost to Treasury ‘black hole’ new data reveal27/07/2022 12:25:00
Apprenticeships experts warn that the Treasury must be more transparent on how it spends the billions returned to its coffers
IEA - Save families £9,000 a year by cutting red tape in housing, childcare, and energy27/07/2022 11:25:00
The next Prime Minister should focus on radical supply-side reform over handouts to dramatically reduce the cost of living.