Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Local services will continue to decline until Government tackles £5 billion funding gap
- Decade of funding cuts and uncertainty over financial settlement for 2020/21 has left council services at breaking point
- Social care system on verge of collapse. Transport, culture, housing and planning spending slashed by over 40%.
- Government must act quickly to end needless uncertainty over spending and provide a long term funding settlement to enable councils to provide high quality local services.
- Funding gap for local authorities widely calculated at £5 billion and growing.
- Read the summary
- Read the conclusions and recommendations
- Read the full report: Local government finance and the 2019 Spending Review
The Government has been derelict in its duty to local authorities by failing to set out a funding settlement that addresses immediate service pressures or plan for future challenges. In a report published today, the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee calls on the Government to end its piecemeal approach to local authority funding and revenue raising. It calls on the Government to provide a financial settlement that adequately supports local authorities to serve their communities and close the multi-billion gap in local authority funding.
A decade of funding cuts and increasing pressures on ‘safety net’ services, particularly social care, has gutted funding in a range of ‘non-essential’ services including transport, housing and culture. This is likely to be exacerbated by the Government’s failure to set out plans for future funding, with the current four-year funding settlement coming to an end this financial year without a replacement in place.
The rising demands for social care, for both adults and children, is placing an intolerable financial burden on local authorities. Years of reviews and deliberation have failed to produce concrete measures that adequately address the level of day-to-day demand or plan for future need. Without new dedicated revenue sources at a local and national level, social care will continue to dominate local authority spending at a cost to other services.
According to LGA figures, the annual funding gap is £5 billion and growing. The continual squeeze on funding has given local authorities little choice but to provide ‘bare bones’ levels of service. The Government must clarify what services it expects local government to provide and be prepared to set a level of funding sufficient to facilitate it.
Business rate retention lacks transparency in how it operates and is too complex in trying to promote development at the same time as rebalancing funding across local authorities. The Government should consider bringing back the Revenue Support Grant to give extra funding to struggling councils.
Review of the Council Tax system is long overdue. It has become a regressive tax disconnected from the true value of properties. A review should consider the case for creating new tax bands at the top and bottom of the scale. Any changes should be implemented without dramatic increases for individual households and be revenue neutral at a national level, however they must produce a progressive tax system in the long term.
In the longer term, local authorities must be given greater freedom to pursue their own solutions to ensure financial stability. The Housing, Communities and Local Government will continue investigating how devolving greater powers and responsibilities, particularly over revenue raising, in its current inquiry into devolution in England.
Chair of the HCLG Committee, Clive Betts MP said:
“There is a disconnect between the services taxpayers expect their local authorities to provide and the level of service possible under current Government funding. People expect well maintained roads, regular refuse collections and cultural services, yet funding rarely stretches beyond meeting the urgent needs of social care services.
“The largest proportion of spending goes on services that most people do not use. Taxpayers are paying more but getting less, and this comes at a cost to continued confidence in local authorities to provide the services they need. Democracy and accountability in local government is paying the price for central government spending decisions.
“The Government has a duty establish a funding settlement that enables local authorities to provide services to meet the needs of their local communities. Over the last decade we have seen a regular chipping away at funding, while adding further statutory obligations for them to meet.
“This constant stress on local government is now compounded by a failure to even set out how much money they will be allocated in the next financial year. The time has come for the Government to get real with local government funding. They must make clear exactly what services they expect to be provided and dedicate sufficient funding for this to be achieved.
“The battle to meet ever increasing demand for social care has left few further sources of revenue to divert towards it and will now need a dedicated funding solution. The haphazard approach to broader funding has equally created an opaque source of revenue, partially funded by tax systems that don’t spread the burden equally. The Government’s attention has been elsewhere for too long and it must now establish a system of funding that both addresses immediate need and supports local authorities in meeting challenges of the future.”
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Arches sale not a good deal for taxpayers and tenants13/09/2019 12:25:00
Sale conducted well but we are unconvinced that it represents the best value for the taxpayer in the long term.
Too much secrecy over Brexit consultancy spend13/09/2019 11:25:00
The Public Accounts committee report says there has been excessive secrecy over the use of consultants by government, with confusion over how much is actually spent.
Immersive and addictive technologies report published13/09/2019 08:15:00
Call to regulate video game ‘loot boxes’ under gambling law and ban their sale to children among measures needed to protect players, say MPs. ‘Lack of honesty and transparency’ reported among representatives of some games and social media companies in giving evidence.
Fundamental shift away from single use packaging necessary, say MPs12/09/2019 16:15:00
The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee has today called for the government to focus on reducing all single use packaging – not just plastic – in its latest report on Plastic food and drink packaging.
Committee calls for research excellence to be spread across the UK12/09/2019 12:33:00
The Committee believes that research excellence needs to be encouraged outside of the ‘golden triangle’ of concentrated research funding (between London, Oxford and Cambridge) and recommends that UKRI significantly increase the size of the Strength In Places Fund to address this issue.
European Union Committee draws special attention to UK-Swiss Agreement11/09/2019 11:25:00
The European Union Committee has published its fifteenth report on Brexit-related international agreements.
Chair disappointed by Government’s lack of commitment to North Wales following Wylfa Newydd collapse10/09/2019 16:25:00
The Chair of the Welsh Affairs Committee, David T.C. Davies MP, expresses disappointment at the lack of real commitment to North Wales in the Government’s response to the Committee’s report on the suspension of nuclear works at Wylfa Newydd.
Irreparable harm caused to children whose mothers are in prison10/09/2019 11:25:00
The Joint Committee on Human Rights publishes report on the Right to family life: Children whose mothers are in prison.
MPs recommend ban on pavement parking across England09/09/2019 16:25:00
The Transport Committee has today criticised the Department for Transport for failing to take action on pavement parking, which MPs have been told has a detrimental effect on people’s lives and can lead to social isolation.
Committee Chair critical of Government’s refusal to devolve Air Passenger Duty to Wales09/09/2019 11:25:00
The Government has responded to the Welsh Affairs Committee’s report on Air Passenger Duty by rejecting the Committee’s recommendation to devolve APD to Wales, claiming that it is not an issue of trust in the Welsh Government.