Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Lords debate Committee's report on security and police cooperation after Brexit
On Tuesday 7 February, the House of Lords debates the Committee's report on tools that currently facilitate police and security cooperation between the United Kingdom and the European Union, and the options available to the Government for retaining or replacing them when the UK leaves the EU.
- Parliament TV: Brexit: future UK-EU security and police cooperation
- Report: Brexit: future UK-EU security and police cooperation (PDF)
- Report: Brexit: future UK-EU security and police cooperation (HTML)
- EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee
Maintaining the strong security cooperation the UK currently has with the European Union has been identified by the Government as one its top four overarching objectives in the forthcoming negotiations on the UK's exit from, and future relationship with, the European Union. Only two years ago, many of the measures and agencies the UK is now due to leave were deemed vital by the then Home Secretary in order to "stop foreign criminals from coming to Britain, dal with European fighters coming back from Syria, stop British criminals evading justice abroad, prevent foreign criminals evading justice by hiding here, and get foreign criminals out of our prisons." These measures and agencies include the European Arrest Warrant, Europol, Eurojust, the Schengen Information System (SIS II) and the European Criminal Records Information System.
The debate follows the publication of a report by the EU Home Affairs Committee which examined the main tools and agencies that underpin security and police cooperation between the UK and EU, and explored the options available to the Government for retaining or replacing them when the UK leaves the EU. The report was published on the 16th December 2016.
The Committee's main conclusions included:
- The UK and the EU-27 share a strong mutual interest in sustaining police and security cooperation after the UK leaves the EU. In contrast to other policy areas, all parties stand to gain from a positive outcome to this aspect of Brexit negotiations.
- It seems inevitable that there will in practice be limits to how closely the UK and EU-27 can work together if they are no longer accountable to, and subject to oversight and adjudication by, the same supranational EU institutions, notably the CJEU.
- The Government will need to devise and secure agreement for a future relationship with Europol that protects the capabilities upon which UK law enforcement has come to rely, which goes further than the operational agreements with Europol that other third countries have been able to reach thus far.
- Access to EU law enforcement databases and data-sharing platforms is integral to day-to-day policing up and down the country. Were the UK to lose access to them upon leaving the EU, information that can currently be sourced in seconds or hours could take days or weeks to retrieve, delivering an abrupt shock to UK policing and posing a risk to the safety of the public.
- The data-sharing tools that witnesses identified as top priorities for the UK - SIS II (the Second Generation Schengen Information System) and ECRIS (the European Criminal Records Information System) - are also those it may be hardest to negotiate access to because they are currently used by Schengen or EU members only.
- The European Arrest Warrant (EAW) is a critical component of the UK's law enforcement capabilities. The most promising avenue for the Government to pursue may be to follow the precedent set by Norway and Iceland and seek a bilateral extradition agreement with the EU that mirrors the EAW's provisions as far as possible. An operations gap between the EAW ceasing to apply and a suitable replacement coming into force would pose an unacceptable risk.
Speakers in the Debate
- The Rt Hon. Baroness Prashar CBE, Chairman of the EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee, will open the debate on the report Brexit: future UK-EU security and police cooperation.
- The Baroness Williams of Trafford, Minister of State at the Home Office, will respond for the Government.
Other members of the House of Lords who are due to speak in the debate can be viewed on the Speakers' List.
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
School absence crisis: Education Committee publishes Govt’s response to report07/12/2023 12:10:00
The Education Committee has published the Government’s response to its recent major report on persistent absence from schools (summarised below).
“A false economy with a terrible price” - JCNSS chair comment on Government response to Conflict, Security and Stability Fund report06/12/2023 13:20:00
The Committee is today publishing the Government response to its September report on the Conflict, Stability and Security Fund (CSSF).
Targeted ten-year plan needed for National Disability Strategy, WEC warns ministers06/12/2023 12:20:00
The Government “has not learnt lessons” from the concerns raised over the development of the National Disability Strategy (NDS) and its efforts to engage with disabled people are “perceived to be superficial”, the Women and Equalities Committee has warned.
Committee proposes raft of measures to stabilise Stormont05/12/2023 09:25:00
A new report by the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee into the effectiveness of the institutions of the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement has issued a raft of proposals aimed at restoring and stabilising Stormont.
The Committee on Standards has released a report on the conduct of Stephen Flynn MP04/12/2023 16:25:00
This report arises from an investigation by the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards into whether Stephen Flynn MP had breached paragraph 8 of the 2023 Code of Conduct for Members of Parliament and the Rules for the use of House of Commons stationery.
Council tax – councils should not be chasing arrears from households that can least afford it, say MPs01/12/2023 17:10:00
The Government should act to ensure local councils are not aggressively chasing council tax debt from those who can least afford it, says the cross-party Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (LUHC) Committee in a report published today.
Government warned to proceed with caution on AI in autonomous weapons01/12/2023 16:10:00
The Artificial Intelligence in Weapon Systems Committee publishes its report Proceed with Caution: Artificial Intelligence in Weapon Systems.
UK government responds to calls for Scotland to be promoted ‘beyond the tartan’30/11/2023 15:25:00
The Scottish Affairs Committee has published the UK Government’s response to its report on Promoting Scotland Internationally, in which MPs found the UK and Scottish Governments often collaborate well when promoting Scotland’s interests abroad but more work is needed to highlight modern Scottish successes.