MEPs call for tax harmonisation and transparency on national tax rulings in 'Lux leaks' debate
Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker appeared in person for Parliament’s extraordinary debate on the fight against tax avoidance, prompted by the recent revelation of secret deals granting preferential tax treatments to multinational companies in Luxembourg.
Mr Juncker underlined that the tax rulings in Luxembourg were not illegal even though he admitted that "there probably was a certain amount of tax avoidance in Luxembourg, as in other EU countries. We find this everywhere in Europe because there is insufficient tax harmonisation in Europe", he explained, adding that Commissioner Moscovici will initiate proposals for an automatic exchange of information regarding national tax rulings."
EPP President Manfred Weber (DE) said he was confident that Jean-Claude Juncker will resolve the problems that are now on the table, adding that "it is not the EU that failed, but the member states themselves who have made no efforts to harmonise their corporate tax bases. We need transparency on national tax rulings as well as harmonised tax bases."
S&D President Gianni Pittella (IT) said he "feels indignation for people hurt by big companies that don't pay taxes where the profits were made. Tax avoidance is a world phenomenon and the biggest shame is that it is not even illegal. Therefore the law has to be changed. Mr Pitella proposed three measures: firstly a clear definition of “tax havens”, secondly severe penalties for offenders and thirdly country-by-country tax reporting.
ECR's Kay Swinburne (UK) also called for further action, especially against aggressive tax avoidance and underlined the need for global country-by-country reporting on national tax rulings. "This is long overdue", she said. Parliament should await the outcome of Commissioner Vestager's investigation before judging, she added.
ALDE President Guy Verhofstadt (BE) said the Investigation by the Commission must be completed by the end of the year and deal not only with three countries, but with the problem of tax evasion in general. He also called for a special investigative committee to be set up in Parliament and asked others groups to support this. "This is also a clear case where we need more Europe – to set up common tax compliance legislation and a convergence code not general harmonisation, because we don't know at what level to harmonise" he said.
Gabriele Zimmer (GUE/NGL, DE) asked Mr Juncker to explain his actions as a former Prime Minister of Luxembourg and why he allowed companies the opportunity to avoid tax in his country, and thus limiting the funds available to fight poverty and job creation.
Philippe Lamberts (Greens/EFA, BE) said it was high time to stop the waging tax wars in Europe. "The ones who benefit from this are the multinational companies and the very wealthy ones, whereas the victim is European public finances, hence the EU citizens." ." He asked Commissioner Vestager to broaden the scope of the investigation.
Paul Nuttall (EFDD, UK) said: "Mr Juncker, when you were campaigning during the European elections you stood on a platform of fighting tax evasion by multinationals but indeed you allowed that tax evasion in Luxembourg. Citizens are sceptical, because you want them to ‘do as I say, not as I do’. You have only two options: either to resign or to stand down while the investigation takes place."
Bruno Gollnisch (NI, FR) accused Mr Juncker of using scandals to get more power. He stated that tax harmonisation is not needed but that there is a need to make multinationals pay tax in the countries where they make profits. He also voiced concerns that Commission officials, led by President Juncker, will be responsible for the inquiry into several cases, including in Luxembourg.
Latest News from
State of the Energy Union 2021: Renewables overtake fossil fuels as the EU's main power source27/10/2021 11:20:00
The Commission yesterday adopted its State of the Energy Union Reports for 2021, taking stock of the progress that the EU is making in delivering the clean energy transition, nearly two years after the launch of the European Green Deal.
EU budget: EU accounts signed off for the 14th year in a row27/10/2021 10:25:00
The Commission yesterday welcomed the decision of the European Court of Auditors (ECA) to give the EU annual accounts a clean bill of health, for the 14th year in a row.
European Institute of Innovation & Technology gives boost to sustainable recovery and growth of Europe's cultural and creative sectors27/10/2021 09:10:00
The European Institute of Innovation & Technology (EIT) yesterday launched a new innovation partnership, in the form of a Knowledge and Innovation Community, to support the competitiveness and growth of Europe's cultural and creative sectors and industries.
Boosting Europe's green transition: Commission invests €1.5 billion in innovative clean tech projects26/10/2021 16:33:00
The Commission is launching today the second call for large-scale projects under the Innovation Fund, one of the world's largest programmes for the demonstration of innovative low-carbon technologies, financed by revenues from the auction of emission allowances from the EU's Emissions Trading System.
Speech by President Charles Michel at the World Health Summit26/10/2021 15:25:00
Speech given yesterday by President Charles Michel at the World Health Summit.
EU Climate Action: Progress reports show 2020 emissions down 31% from 1990, 76% of ETS revenues used for green transition26/10/2021 14:20:00
Together with the annual State of the Energy Union Report, the Commission today adopted three reports on the progress of EU climate policies in 2020: the EU Climate Action Progress Report, the Carbon Market Report and the Fuel Quality Report.
Von der Leyen focuses on pandemic preparedness at the World Health Summit26/10/2021 13:25:00
Speaking at the Word Health Summit on 24 October, President of the Commission Ursula von der Leyen said that pandemic preparedness was now at the centre of the EU's action, and that an unprecedented funding of EUR 50 billion euro over seven years was proposed for a health preparedness mission.
Speech by President von der Leyen at the European Sustainable Energy Week26/10/2021 12:38:00
Speech given yesterday by President von der Leyen at the European Sustainable Energy Week.
Antitrust: Commission carries out unannounced inspections in the animal health sector in Belgium26/10/2021 10:38:00
The European Commission is conducting unannounced inspections at the premises of a pharmaceutical company active in animal health in Belgium.