Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Many public appointments need more rigorous scrutiny, say MPs
The Treasury Committee publishes 'scrutiny of appointments' report in the same week that Members of the Committee table an amendment to the Bank of England and Financial Services Bill.
The amendment would give the Committee a veto over the appointment and dismissal of the Chief Executive of the Financial Conduct Authority.
- Report: The Treasury Committee's scrutiny of appointments
- Report: The Treasury Committee's scrutiny of appointments (PDF 243 KB)
- Treasury Committee
Rt Hon. Andrew Tyrie MP, Chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, said:
"Public appointments to quangos need more rigorous scrutiny. They have needed it for years. More of the most powerful appointments – of the Chief Executive of the FCA and the Governor of the Bank of England – should be subject to full pre appointment scrutiny. The Government continues to disagree, appealing to the ‘market sensitivity’ of these appointments. That is not an adequate explanation.
The time has come to entrench the independence of the post of Chief Executive of the FCA. On behalf of the Treasury Committee, I have tabled an amendment to the Bank of England and Financial Services Bill to give this effect. The Chief Executive of the FCA should be able to operate with the confidence that he or she cannot be dismissed without Parliament’s – the Treasury Committee’s – approval. The public, too, need to have confidence that the Government is not interfering with independent supervisors and regulators.
The OBR provides an appropriate precedent. In 2010 the Chancellor agreed that the appointment and dismissal of the head of the OBR should be subject to Select Committee approval. He also agreed that this would bolster the independence – and the perception of independence – of Robert Chote, to the benefit of both the Chancellor and the country. And so it has proved. The Chancellor has frequently alluded to the Chairman of the OBR’s independence from the Treasury to reinforce the credibility of the forecast. A similar arrangement should also be put in place to entrench the FCA's independence.
The OTS' independence certainly needs to be bolstered. The OTS cannot achieve much if it appears – whether fairly or not - to be a creature of the Treasury. It is crucial that the scope and limitations of its independence are fully understood by HM Treasury, the OTS, Parliament and the public."
Appointments to the Office of Tax Simplification
The placing of the Office for Tax Simplification (OTS) on a statutory basis is welcome. To secure the independence of the Office for Tax Simplification's senior staff, the Government should ensure that those nominated as the Chair and Tax Director of the OTS are available for pre-appointment hearings before this Committee. The legislation should ensure that such appointments, and any dismissals, should only be made with the consent of the Treasury Committee. This will mirror the processes adopted for appointments to the Budget Responsibility Committee of the Office for Budget Responsibility. This is all the more important given that the OTS will be classed as an independent Office of the Treasury. (paragraph 12)
It is crucial that the scope and limitations of that independence are fully understood by HM Treasury, the OTS, Parliament and the public. (paragraph 13)
Appointment of the Governor of the Bank of England
This Committee agrees with its predecessor that giving Parliament the effective veto over the appointment and dismissal of the Governor of the Bank of England would bolster his or her independence. We therefore recommend that the draft Bank of England Bill be amended to reflect this. (paragraph 20)
Appointments to the Prudential Regulatory Committee
The Bank of England and Financial Services Bill will create a Prudential Regulation Committee (PRC). Should the Bill be enacted, it is the intention of this Committee to hold appointment hearings with those who will sit on the PRC, in line with the present arrangements for those who sit on the Monetary Policy Committee and the Financial Policy Committee. The Treasury Committee will use the same criteria of personal independence and professional competence to assess appointments to the PRC as it does to the other policy committees of the Bank of England. (paragraph 23)
The Chief Executive of the Financial Conduct Authority
The previous Treasury Committee have recommended that there should be pre-appointment hearings for the Chief Executive of the FCA. We agree, and therefore the Government should ensure that it nominates its preferred candidate for the current vacancy in good time so that this Committee can undertake a pre-appointment hearing. However, in line with our recommendation on the appointment of the Governor of the Bank of England, to ensure their independence this Committee should have a statutory veto on appointments and dismissals to the post of Chief Executive of the FCA. (paragraph 26)
It has been the practice of previous Treasury Committees to consider two criteria when considering appointments to the Monetary Policy Committee, the Financial Policy Committee, the Budget Responsibility Committee and the Office of Tax Simplification. These criteria are personal independence and professional competence. The Committee will continue with that practice for all appointments to these bodies during this Parliament. (paragraph 42)
In considering the appointment of the Governor of the Bank of England, the 2010-15 Treasury Committee acknowledged the additional executive responsibilities of the position, reflected in its questioning and reporting. Governors and Deputy Governors of the Bank of England, or those who hold executive functions within an organisation may also expect additional commentary, along with the Committee's consideration of their personal independence and professional competence. (paragraph 27)
Consideration by the Treasury Committee of appointments to the Chair of the Court of the Bank of England or to the Chair of the Financial Conduct Authority will be more wide-ranging, and the Committee may set out a more detailed conclusion in its Reports on appointments to these posts. (paragraph 28)
Should the Treasury Committee disagree with any appointment which it has scrutinised, and should the person making the appointment, whether the Chancellor or another, not be swayed by its disapproval, it may refer its Report on that appointment for a debate by the whole House, as the previous Treasury Committee stated it might do when considering the appointment of the Governor of the Bank of England. (paragraph 29)
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Report published on the impact of COVID-19 on Parliament14/05/2021 10:05:00
The Constitution Committee publishes its report COVID-19 and Parliament as part of its inquiry into the Constitutional implications of COVID‑19.
All eyes on Government Heat and Buildings Strategy as Ministers dodge EAC recommendations to improve energy efficiency of homes13/05/2021 15:05:00
The Government’s response to the Environmental Audit Committee’s report on Energy Efficiency of Existing Homes has been published today.
Treasury Committee comments on responses to Greensill inquiry correspondence07/05/2021 13:15:00
The Committee has received responses to the Chair’s letters. It is unable to publish these letters during Prorogation, but will do so when Parliament returns next week, ahead of the evidence session with Lex Greensill on Tuesday.
Committee receives Government response to key report on procedure after coronavirus restrictions07/05/2021 09:15:00
The Procedure Committee publishes the Government’s response to its detailed report setting out a procedural roadmap for coming out of the current lockdown.
Change the law now to ensure end to blanket bans on care home visits, urges Joint Committee05/05/2021 11:15:00
The Joint Committee on Human Rights has prepared a draft statutory instrument to lay before Parliament to secure legal protection for care home residents deprived of family visits, and therefore, their human rights.
Supply chain for battery electric vehicles inquiry launched04/05/2021 15:05:00
In the latest stage of its Technological Innovation and Climate Change inquiry, the Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) announces that it is to look at the supply chain for battery electric vehicles.
Privileges Committee publish key report on select committee powers03/05/2021 10:20:00
The Committee of Privileges publishes a key report on select committee powers, setting out preliminary proposals to ensure the committee powers to call for persons, papers and records can be enforced and that witnesses before committees are treated fairly.
MPs urge Government to level playing field for meat and seafood exporters30/04/2021 13:05:00
The Government must take a 'pragmatic' approach in discussions with the EU to reduce 'considerable' non-tariff barriers—including red tape and checks— that the new GB-EU trading environment has created for British companies.