NEF - Better Courts take time - but they’re worth it
Blog posted by : BY: STEPHEN WHITEHEAD (29th July 2014)
It will come as no surprise to family lawyers that from 2007 to 2013 a third of all care proceedings cases involved mothers who had been through the process before. Whether in the criminal or civil arena, courts working with the most vulnerable see the same faces appearing before them time and time again.
We all know this sad and expensive revolving-door effect is the result of a justice system ill-equipped to tackle the complex social issues which underlie legal cases.
Last month Gazette readers heard from Judge Nicholas Crichton of London’s Family Drug and Alcohol Court (FDAC). Since opening in 2008, the court has handled care proceedings involving parental substance misuse.
At the FDAC, dedicated judges supervise and motivate families through the duration of their case, working closely with a team of specialists to painstakingly unpick the issues that have landed their clients in court in the first place – co-ordinating addiction treatment and more personalised support. This approach is paying off.
It is this kind of court innovation we desperately need to start replicating across the UK, but those wishing to kick-start problem-solving justice projects in their own courts face a long and punishing climb. Courts are inherently, and perhaps rightly, wary of change, and even the merest scraps of funding can take months and years to win.
A challenge then, but not an impossible one. Take Plymouth Community Court, Sefton’s problem-solving court, or the specialist domestic violence courts which exist all over the country. These examples show courts finding new ways to build on their role of legal arbiters to identify and help address complex social issues. There is much we can learn from the FDAC and its contemporaries about what it takes to clear the hurdles to innovation.
Having an obvious, well-understood and well-evidenced target issue is one lesson. When FDAC was conceived, the burden of parental substance misuse on courts, social services and, of course, children, was the subject of major public attention. The fact that 64% of care proceedings in inner London involved parental substance misuse gave Crichton and his colleagues a clear picture of the problem they needed to solve.
Judges should not underestimate the significant role they can play in getting new projects off the ground. They have authority, networks, legal expertise, and first-hand knowledge of the problems facing the courts: star qualities that can make all the difference at the outset. Without the jump-start given to FDAC by Judge Crichton as a founder, advocate and one of the first judges to hear its cases, it is unlikely I would be writing about it today. Judges have the tools, and some might say the responsibility, to respond.
There is power, too, in networks. FDAC was driven by a team of people with a diverse set of knowledge and resources: Judge Crichton himself, but also academics, local authority leaders, independent legal experts and central government officials. Each of them made their own contribution to getting the project off the ground.
The inspiration for FDAC originally came from California’s highly successful Family Drug Treatment Courts – though extensive work was needed to tailor the model to the very different context of inner London. Would-be innovators must become adept at seeing what has worked well elsewhere and how this could be transplanted to their own context.
The bottom line, perhaps, is that innovation takes patience. Securing the necessary permissions and funding for FDAC took years of painstaking work, developing and refining the proposal and building links with the right people in government. Innovators can help courts find better ways of working, but, like the people behind FDAC, they must be imaginative, enthusiastic and above all determined.
Latest News from
IEA - Plan B restrictions “cannot be abolished a moment too soon”20/01/2022 11:35:00
Christopher Snowdon, Head of Lifestyle Economics at free market think tank Institute of Economic Affairs, said: “Plan B restrictions cannot be abolished a moment too soon. Vaccine passports have never worked anywhere and face masks are largely theatrical.
Work Foundation - How well prepared are we for rising living costs in 2022?20/01/2022 10:35:00
This month’s labour market statistics show continued signs that the furlough scheme was successful in protecting employment.
IPPR - Millennial generation leaders need urgent help to prepare for climate crisis ‘crunch point’, says report20/01/2022 09:35:00
JRF - Inflation: Rises in energy and food will be causing real fear for families in poverty19/01/2022 15:25:00
Families on low incomes are facing “real fear” as today’s figures show inflation has hit 5.4%, driven in particular by rises in the cost of transport and energy.
IEA economist responds as UK inflation hits 30-year high19/01/2022 14:25:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on the inflation figures, published today by the Office for National Statistics
JRF - Rising energy bills to ‘devastate’ poorest families, adding to harmful legacy for millions of children sinking deeper into poverty18/01/2022 10:35:00
New analysis from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation finds households on low incomes will be spending on average 18% of their income after housing costs on energy bills after April. For single adult households on low incomes this rises to a shocking 54%, an increase of 21 percentage points since 2019/20.
IPPR - Exposed: The gap between levelling up rhetoric and reality18/01/2022 09:35:00
Landmark ‘State of the North’ report reveals a gulf between levelling up promises and policy reality
Oxfam’s debunked ideas would “entrench poverty, disease and destitution”, says IEA researcher17/01/2022 16:15:00
Matthew Lesh, Head of Public Policy at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on Oxfam’s latest report ‘Inequality Kills’
Government must now legislate to scrap the BBC licence fee, says IEA Director General17/01/2022 15:15:00
Mark Littlewood, Director General at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on the future of the BBC licence fee
‘It is clear that the road to recovery will not be a smooth one for NHS services’ : The King’s Fund responds to the latest NHS hospital performance data17/01/2022 14:15:00
Siva Anandaciva, Chief Analyst at The King’s Fund, commented on the latest monthly NHS performance data and weekly hospital situation report