NEF - How do we create a fair economy?
Blog posted by : PERRY WALKER (10th September 2014)
A big question, but answering it was the aim of a recent event organised by the Workers Educational Association Yorkshire and Humber Region, with support from the Sheffield Branch and held at their Learning Centre in Attercliffe.
Using Crowd Wise, a way of promoting open and balanced debate that Idescribed in my last blog, the participants were given five options for achieving the goal and, perhaps surprisingly, ended the event in agreement.
The table below summarises the five options people were initially presented with. It also shows the result of the preference vote that took place at the start of the event. The right hand column shows each option’s score as a percentage of its maximum possible score (so if everyone had put a particular option top it would score 100%).
The intent had been to have a second preference vote at the end, to see how views had shifted after discussion. But this proved unnecessary, as there was consensus in the room. The elements of this consensus were as follows:
Raise money through a wealth tax and through stopping tax evasion.
Use it to fund a basic income.
Also use it to fund new priorities for public spending (health, housing and transport). These can also be funded by reducing public spending in some other areas, such as subsidies for the private rented sector.
The need to change the terms of the debate.
An acceptance both of the difficulty of achieving these policies and that what is happening in the UK is part of a global crisis that needs to be tackled at a global scale.
The experience of the small group who were advocating for option D illustrates the move towards consensus. They initially replaced the idea of a maximum wage with a wealth tax – this proposal was endorsed by everyone. After further reflection they shifted their support from a living wage to a basic income – an idea NEF is yet to work on, but interested to explore in future – on the ground that a basic income doesn’t consider entitlement.
So there was consensus in this event. But what about between events? If you are interested in organising your own debate on this subject, using this approach, we’ll come and help you. Leave a comment below or send me an e-mail.
Latest News from
JRF - Inflation remains high but damage done as costs of essentials are literally unaffordable20/09/2023 11:25:00
Chief Economist at JRF responds to the latest CPI inflation rate, Alfie Stirling
Tata Steel “a bad deal for workers”, says IPPR18/09/2023 09:20:00
Luke Murphy, head of the fair transition unit at IPPR, responded to the government's deal with Tata Steel regarding Britain's largest steelworks at Port Talbot
IPPR - Deliver once-in-a-generation NHS reform to avert killer costs and end second-rate care, landmark report warns14/09/2023 11:20:00
A landmark new report for the cross-party IPPR Commission on Health and Prosperity has revealed that UK health and care services are falling further behind international peers – and sets out a 10-point plan to put them right.
IPPR - Fair tax changes in Scotland could boost spending on key national priorities by hundreds of millions per year, say campaigners14/09/2023 10:20:00
Campaigners are calling on the First Minister to ‘put Scotland’s money where his mouth is’ by beginning to deliver his commitment to explore “bolder” income and wealth tax reforms and to do so ahead of the next Scottish Budget.
Demos - Martha’s Rule – explained11/09/2023 10:05:00
Demos has published a report supporting calls for the NHS to bring in Martha’s Rule, giving patients and their families more power to get a second opinion when they feel they aren’t being heard.
IFS - The triple lock creates uncertainty for pension incomes and savers, as well as the public finances11/09/2023 09:05:00
The pensions triple lock has increased state pension spending and creates uncertainty for current and future generations of pensioners.
Muscular unionism’ approach to devolved nations risks backfiring across the UK, new IPPR research warns08/09/2023 10:10:00
The ‘muscular unionism’ approach to governance adopted by many Westminster politicians in recent years risks backfiring among those who want Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland to remain part of the UK, an IPPR report warns
IEA - Lifting onshore wind ban ‘a step in the right direction’06/09/2023 15:20:00
Andy Mayer, Energy Analyst at the free market Institute of Economic Affairs comments on reports that the government will relax the effective ban on new onshore wind farms in England