NIESR: International study demonstrates importance of new legislation to help Britain’s insecure workers
A new study carried out by the National Institute of Economic and Social Research for the TUC reveals that the UK has seen significant growth in insecure forms of employment compared to other EU countries. The study, published this morning, links the growth to relatively weak legal protections for those in bogus self-employment, agency work and on zero-hour contracts.
NIESR researchers found that:
- The UK had the largest increase in the number of self-employed workers for EU countries from 2008 to 2015
- The UK had the third largest increase in the number of temporary workers for EU countries from 2008 to 2015
The UK’s high placement for growth in these categories of work cannot be explained simply as a result of strong employment growth overall. Germany had the fastest overall employment growth of any EU country during the period, but its number (and proportion) of temporary and self-employment workers has fallen.
The report finds that the absence of effective legislation in the UK to regulate insecure work has allowed the growth of atypical employment, like zero-hours contracts. By contrast, atypical workers elsewhere in the EU tend to have stronger legal protections and greater job security. For example:
- In France, workers can only be on a fixed-term contract for 18 months, and Germany has introduced a maximum hiring period of 18 months for temporary agency workers.
- Zero-hours contracts do not exist in many EU countries, and are strongly regulated in others (e.g. Netherlands, Italy, Germany), but only lightly regulated in the UK. In the Netherlands, for example, employers are required to pay for 3 hours per shift, and to provide regular hours when the worker reaches a certain number of weekly hours over a given period.
NIESR Researcher Nathan Hudson-Sharp said: “While insecure work in other European countries has been characterised by the emergence of regulation and policy, the UK has noticeably lacked much needed new legislation.
“The UK therefore stands out for having very precarious forms work, and for creating arrangements where workers are at particular risk of insecurity.”
TUC General Secretary Frances O’Grady said: “We don’t need to accept insecure jobs as a necessary evil to get more people into work. In Germany, employment growth has been the strongest in the EU, but at the same time insecure employment has declined.
“It’s time Britain stopped being a soft touch on bad bosses. Otherwise the dodgy practices we’ve seen from employers like Hermes and Sports Direct will spread to more and more working people.
“All the parties must explain in their election manifestos how they will improve the rights of working people. There are millions of insecure workers in Britain who need a government that will flex its muscles to fight their corner, and stand up to bosses who treat them badly.
“If countries like France, the Netherlands and Germany can give their working people more protection, Britain can too.”
Notes to Editors:
- The full report International Trends in Insecure Work can be found here:
- The report focuses on:
- Temporary employment: workers with zero-hour contracts, fixed term contracts, or doing agency work.
- Marginal part-time employment: part-time jobs that have particularly low hours and high insecurity.
- Self-employment: workers classified as self-employed contractors, but who have a subordinate relationship with a single employer.
For queries related to the research and methodology, please contact:
Paola Buonadonna E: firstname.lastname@example.org T: 020 7654 1923 or 07710 484152
For queries related to the TUC please contact:
Press Office T: 020 7467 1248 E: email@example.com
Latest News from
Work Foundation - New Work Foundation Index reveals UK workers suffering most from insecure employment26/05/2022 12:25:00
New in-depth analysis of UK job market data reveals women, disabled people, ethnic minorities and young workers have been consistently trapped in insecure employment over the last twenty years.
IEA - Government should go further in liberalising GMO regulations26/05/2022 09:25:00
Matthew Lesh, IEA Head of Public Policy commented on upcoming legislation to speed up the development and marketing of “gene-edited” crops
IEA - Police training should focus on implementing the rule of law, not identity politics25/05/2022 15:10:00
Marc Glendening, Head of Cultural Affairs at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to the National Police Chiefs Council plan to impose the mandatory teaching of ‘black history’ upon every officer as part of a Race Action Plan
IFS - Inflation for poorest households likely to increase even faster than for the richest, and could hit 14% in October25/05/2022 12:20:00
In April 2022 Ofgem’s tariff cap increased by 54%, or nearly £700 per year for an average household. Yesterday the CEO of Ofgem said that Ofgem expect the default tariff cap to increase by another £800 in October, leading to a cap of £2,800 on average annual gas and electricity bills.
JRF - Family finances under major strain, as benefits hit 40 year low24/05/2022 14:25:00
Families with children are being faced with price rises of £400 per month on basic items such as food, rent and heating. The impacts of inflation are being felt sooner and harder by those on the lowest incomes, who spend a higher proportion of their incomes on essential items.
“The public finances remain in a mess”, says IEA economist24/05/2022 13:15:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs comments on the ONS public sector finances data.
Rich List: Huge gains of wealthiest should be taxed more to help households with cost of living crisis, says IPPR23/05/2022 10:10:00
As Sunday Times Rich List shows record number of UK billionaires, their gains should be taxed the same as income from work
IFG - Government must do more to ensure policy coherence on net zero20/05/2022 16:05:00
The government needs to tackle incoherent policy making if it is to meet its net zero target, argues a new Institute for Government report.