Need for a rethink on vocational FE
NCFE recently teamed up with Campaign for Learning to launch a new policy paper titled: ‘No 16-18 year old left behind’. In this article, FE Policy Analyst, Mick Fletcher, shares his highlights of the paper:
A couple of years ago, I sat in a college foyer waiting for a meeting as students came out from their classes for morning break. I was struck by how many of them were in uniform; the engineers in blue overalls, the hairdressers in dazzling white, catering students in their aprons and those preparing for a career in sport and recreation in their relevant kit. Even the art and design students had their distinctive, if informal ‘uniform’ of a sort. It struck me forcefully that as well as learning skills vocational students are beginning to assume an occupational identity. Unlike school uniforms, these occupational uniforms were worn with pride. It is a vital but underrated aspect of vocational FE – a way of giving self-respect and meaning to young people for whom academic schooling didn’t meet their individual learning style..
This observation was brought back to me on reading ‘No 16-18-year-old left behind’ – the collection of essays commissioned by NCFE and the Campaign for Learning.
The need for a focus on the educational development of young people rather than training in a limited set of prescribed skills comes through most directly perhaps in the contribution from Sue Pember from HOLEX. Her comment: “there is no pride in saying ‘I’m on a transition programme’” captures exactly what the issue is about the pejoratively titled ‘lower level further education’ – it doesn’t recognise the many ways in which courses with an occupational focus can motivate studentsand help them to achieve their career goals by alternative means.
Alternative routes to success
The same criticism is made of the English and maths resit policy, with Kevin Gilmartin from the Association of School and College Leaders talking of it as “rubbing their noses in disappointment”. It is not that the policy isn’t well intentioned; it’s simply blinkered and doesn’t take into account the fact that there are many routes to success, including alternative qualifications such as Functional Skills.
The need for consistent funding
The policy blindness when it comes to those who don’t wish to study A levels is compounded by the systematic underfunding of FE compared with schools. As John Widdowson from New College Durham reminds us, if, despite all the odds, a young person does succeed in transitioning to a Level 3 programme after a year, the funding for the second year of that Level 3 programme is subject to a further cut of 17.5%.
Apprenticeships and vocational FE – both of value
The persistent oversight by Government to demonstrate the value in programmes at Levels 1 and 2 in their own right runs the risk that colleges will cease to invest in them. In many ways to focus on Level 3 provision for better motivated and more able students offers a more secure role for institutions, many of which are already struggling to stay afloat. If that were to happen then it would compound the difficulties caused by changes in the apprenticeship system, well documented in this collection of essays by Kathleen Henehan from the Resolution Foundation. Apprenticeships offer the same benefits to young people as well constructed vocational FE – learning skills, but more importantly, making the complex transition from school to working life.
It is perhaps surprising that Government recognises in apprenticeships what it doesn’t seem to value in vocational FE. It is more surprising that there has been so little attention paid to reversing the steady decline in opportunities for 16-18 year olds via the apprenticeship route. Without a change of direction and some serious investment, a good proportion of our 16-18 year olds really will be left behind.
The full ‘No 16-18 year old left behind’ policy paper with articles from authors including the Education Policy Institute, Association of Colleges, Learning and Work Institute and the Resolution Foundation is available to view and download now.
Latest News from
Supporting learners through COVID-19 with Learning Curve Group27/05/2020 14:15:00
While there is a huge amount of uncertainty in the world surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, one thing is clear - there is still a huge appetite for learning.
Learning at Work Week takes to the air for 202026/05/2020 09:25:00
Employers across the UK are being invited to take part in a first-of-its-kind virtual learning event this week as Learning at Work Week returns, but with a few twists!
Mental Health Awareness Week 2020 – George’s story20/05/2020 17:05:00
In the lead up to Mental Health Awareness Week which started on Monday 18th May we spoke to George, a Samaritans listening volunteer, who wanted to share his story and advice.
How to engage learners while working remotely18/05/2020 09:20:00
Last week, the UK Government laid out its COVID-19 economic recovery plan, which outlines its broad objective to get pupils in certain year groups back into schools and colleges in some form by 1 June.
Supporting Mental Health Awareness Week – raising awareness, encouraging conversations and showing a little kindness12/05/2020 11:15:00
Once again, CACHE is getting involved in this year’s Mental Health Awareness Week, an annual campaign hosted by the Mental Health Foundation. This year’s campaign takes place 18th-24th May and will focus on the theme of kindness.
Addressing the impact of COVID-19 on post-16 education17/04/2020 09:15:00
In light of the ongoing situation with COVID-19, there has been a great deal of disruption across the education sector at all levels, the impact of which will be felt long into the next academic year and possibly beyond.
Peer Tutor – online peer-to-peer support for your learners09/04/2020 11:15:00
Peer Tutor is a mobile app that allows learners to receive online support from verified, high achieving peers.
NCFE announces Campaign for Learning acquisition08/04/2020 12:15:00
In a move which will strengthen their positions as purpose-led and influential authorities in the education sector, education and skills charity, NCFE, and independent learning charity, Campaign for Learning, yesterday announced plans for further alignment of their organisations.