Ministry of Justice
New Bill hands additional tools to judges
More powers will be given to judges as new legislation delivers on the Government’s pledge to ensure the courts are not open to abuse and delay.
- New Judicial Review and Courts Bill introduced in parliament today
- Measures will reduce delays in the High Court, saving money for the taxpayer
- Delivers on commitment to ensure the courts are not open to abuse
The Judicial Review and Courts Bill, introduced to parliament today (21/07/2021), will equip judges with the tools to give more tailored solutions in judicial review cases. It will also create a better balance between the rights of citizens to challenge executive decisions through judicial review and the need for effective government.
These measures will allow the courts to delay the time it takes for their orders to come into force, allowing parties time to prepare. They will also reduce the impact on third parties who have relied on a power that the courts deem unlawful.
It will also remove the inefficient ‘Cart’ judicial reviews which can create unnecessary delay including in immigration and asylum cases and introduce a range of steps to improve court processes.
This follows a thorough examination of trends in judicial review undertaken by the expert Independent Review of Administrative Law. The Government then launched a public consultation on a range of proposals, which informed this Bill.
Lord Chancellor, Robert Buckland QC MP, said:
The Government has pledged to ensure that the courts are not open to abuse and delay. Today we are delivering on that commitment.
We are giving judges the powers they need to ensure the Government is held to account, while tackling those who seek to frustrate the court process.
This legislation will empower judges to modify quashing orders by introducing two changes, to be used at the discretion of individual judges:
- Suspending the effects of a quashing order – this means that a judge can delay the point at which a government action will be overturned. This will improve the public policy making process by, for example, allowing time for a Department to consult on the best way to replace an administrative regime, rather than creating a rush to do it immediately.
- Limiting or removing the retrospective effect of quashing orders – meaning judges can determine the Government’s action unlawful, without invalidating any prior actions. For example, if a Judicial Review judgment found that an employment regulation which gave workers healthcare was found unlawful, it would jeopardise their access to a particular form of healthcare under current law. The new laws mean that a judge can ensure that continuing access to that healthcare was lawful even though the regulation had been ruled unlawful.
The so-called ‘Cart’ judgment will be reversed as part of this Bill to prevent parties who have already been refused permission to appeal by both the First-tier and Upper Tribunal from trying a third time through a judicial review in the High Court.
Research found that these claims – which are the most numerous judicial review cases – have a success rate of only around 3% compared to a 40-50% success rate for all other cases. This is estimated to cost the taxpayer over £300,000 per year, which could be better spent on dealing with outstanding cases that exist in the High Courts.
Many Cart cases arise from immigration and asylum appeals and despite the claim eventually failing it can be used as a delaying tactic to prevent removals.
Notes to editors:
- A range of other courts measures will be introduced in Parliament today.
- The Independent Review on Administrative Law was launched in July last year: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-launches-independent-panel-to-look-at-judicial-review
- The full IRAL report and the consultation can be found here: https://consult.justice.gov.uk/judicial-review-reform/judicial-review-proposals-for-reform
- The legislation will not address the issue of nullity as set out in the consultation. Instead, the new remedial powers make express provision that the operation of nullity does not constrain their use.
- The legislation will not address ouster clauses in the way set out in the consultation. Instead, it is expected that the legal text that removes the Cart judgment will serve as a framework that can be replicated in other legislation. This will draw a line under decades of uncertainty and confusion as to their proper use.
Latest News from
Ministry of Justice
Criminal barristers to receive 15 percent fee rise in September30/06/2022 16:05:00
Criminal barristers will receive a 15 percent fee rise from the end of September, the government has confirmed today (30 June 2022).
Parole hearings to be heard in public for the first time30/06/2022 13:05:00
Victims, members of the public and the media will be able to ask for a parole hearing to be heard in public for the first time, following law changes being made today (30 June 2022).
Pre-recorded evidence for rape victims rolled out to more North-West courts30/06/2022 09:25:00
More victims of rape and sexual violence will be spared the stress of being cross-examined in court under a scheme rolled out to a further 10 Crown Courts yesterday (29 June 2022).
Public safety boost as major justice reforms come into force28/06/2022 15:10:00
Landmark reforms to better protect the public and make our streets safer come into force today (28 June).
Bill of Rights to strengthen freedom of speech and curb bogus human rights claims22/06/2022 11:15:00
Freedom of speech and the views of elected lawmakers will be given greater weight in law under a Bill of Rights introduced to Parliament today (Wednesday 22 June).
£500 million boost to create thousands of new prison places20/06/2022 11:25:00
New houseblocks to be built at 6 prisons - accommodating more than 2,600 prisoners.
New pilots to boost support for rape victims in court16/06/2022 12:15:00
Rape victims will receive enhanced support at 3 Crown Courts under a new pilot scheme launched by the government today (16 June 2022) as part of efforts to drive up prosecutions and convictions.
Prison leavers tagged to cut alcohol-fuelled crime15/06/2022 14:05:00
Alcohol-fuelled crime will be cut as offenders released from prisons in England face alcohol bans and having their drinking electronically monitored from today (15 June 2022).