North York Moors’ charging policy criticised by the Ombudsman
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has criticised a national park authority for the way it adopted a policy to charge residents for planning enforcement action.
North York Moors National Park Authority (NPA) decided to make a charge to recover some costs when taking enforcement action.
A couple complained to the Ombudsman that the NPA had charged them for enforcing a planning notice.
The Ombudsman’s investigation has found the NPA at fault for the way it made the decision to introduce the charge, and for not properly advising members of the legal and administrative basis on which it decided it was entitled to introduce it.
When the authority introduced the policy in 2014, and when it re-confirmed its position a year later, it took legal advice that found no clear legislation providing for local planning authorities to recover enforcement costs, and no case law on the issue.
Michael King, Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman said:
“In making policy decisions authorities should show a level of evidence reflecting the importance of the issue, and I would expect it to be meticulous for a decision as contentious as charging for planning enforcement.
“In this case, North York Moors National Park Authority’s decision was based on an inconclusive legal opinion and did not take into account all the relevant factors.
“I would expect a decision of this nature to receive thorough scrutiny. But the full implications of the authority’s proposal were not properly communicated to members, so it is questionable how informed their decision making could have been.
“We are also concerned the authority’s rationale for the decision shifted over time – rather than a robust, risk-based decision it appears it sought to justify a desired policy objective on limited and uncertain grounds.”
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman’s role is to remedy injustice and share learning from investigations to help improve public, and adult social care, services.
In this case the NPA has suspended the policy, cancelled the charges made under the policy and issued a refund to any others that have paid.
It should now also apologise to the couple for not properly considering the basis of the charge and for not explaining the basis for that charge.
Latest News from
Draft Public Service Ombudsman Bill laid in Parliament05/12/2016 12:37:21
A new complaints body will provide the public with greater confidence that their voices have been heard.
Norfolk council failed two boys with Special Educational Needs17/01/2019 09:15:00
Norfolk County Council’s provision for children with special educational needs (SEN) has been criticised in two separate investigations after the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman revealed it had already upheld nine similar complaints.
Ombudsman welcomes National Audit Office report15/01/2019 16:25:00
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has today welcomed the National Audit Office's (NAO) report on local authority governance.
Carers leave woman in pain after burns not detected soon enough10/01/2019 09:15:00
A vulnerable Blackpool woman was left “screaming in pain” with serious burns on her leg after carers left her too close to a hot radiator, a Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman investigation has found.
Ombudsman issues rare finding about Wandsworth independent care provider09/01/2019 12:15:00
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has issued a rare public notice against a Wandsworth care provider for not acting appropriately when dealing with a complaint.
Complaints to the Ombudsman about the communication of changes in the state pension age for women20/12/2018 16:15:00
On 8 October, we issued a proposal to investigate a sample of complaints about the communication of changes in the state pension age for women and associated issues.
Failure of Care Quality Commission to make sure NHS employs ‘fit and proper’ directors20/12/2018 12:15:00
A Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman report published yesterday revealed significant weaknesses in the way the Care Quality Commission (CQC) used the NHS ‘fit and proper’ person test.
Elderly man with Alzheimer’s disease died when agency failed to provide night care19/12/2018 09:15:15
An elderly man with Alzheimer’s disease died following a fall from bed when an agency night carer failed to attend his home.