Ofcom finds BBC in breach of due impartiality rules
Ofcom has found the BBC in breach of due impartiality rules in relation to a news item broadcast on The World at One, BBC Radio 4, on 24 February 2021.
The news item discussed the dispute between the Scottish Government and former First Minister, Alex Salmond over its handling of harassment complaints against him and the consequent Holyrood inquiry.
It included an interview with Baroness Ruth Davidson who expressed, at length, strongly critical views about the Scottish Government without due weight being given to alternative perspectives.
We received a complaint about the programme, which had completed the BBC First process.
After investigating the complaint against our broadcasting rules, we found that the BBC failed to preserve due impartiality.
About our investigation
In reaching our decision, we took careful account of the broadcaster’s and audience’s rights to freedom of expression.
We also considered the following factors:
- The gravity of Ruth Davidson’s accusations regarding the Scottish Government and her strong and continued criticism
- The fact that she was able to express her views at length without alternative perspectives being given due weight
- The absence of a clear link to the subsequent afternoon programme which continued to cover the story.
Find out more about the Broadcasting Code and how we assess complaints.
Latest News from
Ofcom to probe cloud, messenger and smart-device markets23/09/2022 10:15:00
Ofcom is to examine the position of Amazon, Microsoft and Google in cloud services, as part of a new programme of work to ensure that digital communications markets are working well for people and businesses in the UK.
Providers must think carefully about price rises23/09/2022 09:33:00
This speech was delivered by Lindsey Fussell, Ofcom's Group Director, Networks and Communications, at the Connected Britain conference earlier this week.
Lindsey Fussell speech to Connected Britain, 20 September 202222/09/2022 15:15:15
Lindsey Fussell speech to Connected Britain, 20 September 2022.
Have you saved money by switching to a social broadband tariff?08/09/2022 09:05:00
Have you, or someone you know, benefited from a social tariff to get a better mobile or broadband deal? If so, we'd like to hear from you.
Supreme Court will not hear RT appeal against Ofcom decisions on impartiality failings05/09/2022 12:33:00
The Supreme Court has confirmed it will not hear an appeal from RT against Ofcom’s decisions finding serious and repeated breaches by RT of our broadcasting rules.
Update on complaints received about this year’s Love Island series30/08/2022 13:25:00
Now that the sun has set on the eighth series of ITV2’s Love Island, we have completed our assessment of all the complaints we received about the show this year.
Could a price comparison service help you to get a better phone or broadband deal?23/08/2022 16:05:00
Amid rising living costs, lots of people are looking at ways to save money on the services we use every day.
Ofcom imposes sanctions on Samaa TV and Studio 6623/08/2022 13:10:00
Ofcom is today imposing two financial penalties for breaches of our broadcasting rules.