Office for Standards in Education (Ofsted)
Ofsted: Let us inspect multi-academy trusts (MATs)
Yesterday’s report recommends that Ofsted be empowered to inspect trusts in order to strengthen their accountability.
Ofsted yesterday published a report: Multi-academy trusts: benefits, challenges and functions, which looks at MATs’ influence on day-to-day practice in their schools and the extent of their impact on leaders and teachers.
Three quarters of academy schools now belonging to a multi-academy trust and Ofsted wants to be able to inspect the trusts, as well as individual schools.
Ofsted research finds academy schools are strongly held to account by MATs, but there is weak accountability of the trust itself.
The report finds that many MATs play a central role in setting school policies, monitoring performance, recruitment, and training. They are also legally responsible for their schools and therefore for the governance of them. However, the report also finds there is weak internal accountability at trust level.
Currently, Ofsted can only carry out summary evaluations of the quality of education provided by a MAT by inspecting a sample of their schools. It cannot inspect the trust itself nor make graded judgements.
Ofsted Chief Inspector, Amanda Spielman yesterday said:
Three quarters of academy schools now belong to a multi-academy trust, whose job it is to make important decisions - not just about the financial management of their schools, but also what is taught in them, and how it is taught and assessed. Some MATs may control as many as 50 or more schools.
Given the power and influence of MATs, it’s important that they are properly accountable to parents. The fact that Ofsted is unable to inspect trusts directly means parents and policy makers are only given a partial view of what is happening in our schools. This presents some very real risks, which we have seen highlighted by the recent failures of some academy trusts.
The report highlights that schools in larger trusts benefit from economies of scale, back-office support, training, career progression and recruitment. However, size has its drawbacks, and some MATs took on a large number of schools in difficulty quickly, without always having the central capacity and leadership required to improve them.
The report also finds that schools in a MAT are able to share data and expertise, which many staff reported had particular benefits for pupils with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND). However, getting everyone together in the same place can be costly, time-consuming and frustrating, particularly if the geographical spread of a MAT is wide.
The report recommends that trusts make full use of opportunities to standardise functions provided by the MAT structure. Developing subject curriculums, which may be beyond the capacity of individual schools, is one example where more trust-level activity could be beneficial.
For this research, Ofsted visited 41 MATs and 121 schools with a diverse range of characteristics.
Evidence was gathered from over 700 interviewees, including:
- MAT chief executive officers (CEOs)
- local governors
- middle leaders
- representatives from MAT boards
70 Petty France
Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 6pm 0300 013 0415
Out of hours duty press officer 07919 057 359
Latest News from
Office for Standards in Education (Ofsted)
Research into further education subcontracting launched07/11/2019 11:15:00
Ofsted is launching a new research project to look at the subcontracting landscape within further education (FE).
Ofsted publications during pre-election period06/11/2019 13:10:00
Information about what Ofsted will publish during the pre-election period running from November 6 to December 13 2019.
HMCI commentary: the initial teacher education curriculum17/10/2019 12:15:00
Ofsted's Chief Inspector, Amanda Spielman, recently (15 October 2019) discussed upcoming changes to how we inspect initial teacher education (ITE) partnerships.
Home education: a choice or last resort?15/10/2019 13:15:00
Home education is often being chosen by parents of children with complex needs as a last resort.
Three convicted of running an illegal school04/10/2019 10:15:00
Local authorities were misled into paying thousands of pounds of public money for children to be educated in an unsafe unregistered school, following Ofsted’s investigation.
Two convicted of running illegal school in London13/09/2019 14:10:00
A head teacher and her father have been found guilty of running an unregistered school in south London, in only the second prosecution of its kind.
HMCI commentary: managing behaviour research13/09/2019 10:15:00
Ofsted's Chief Inspector, Amanda Spielman, summarises our findings so far on managing behaviour in schools and our future projects (11 September 2019).
What’s changing at Ofsted in autumn 2019?02/09/2019 12:15:00
You may notice some changes to some of the Ofsted services and GOV.UK pages. Here’s a round-up of these changes.