Ombudsman calls for national review of former NHS Trust’s failure to keep patients safe
The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman yesterday called for a national review into years of potential failings to ensure patient safety at the North Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (NEP) .
This follows the Ombudsman’s investigations into the deaths of two vulnerable young men, which found a series of significant failings in their care and treatment. Both of their families suffer the ongoing injustice of knowing that their sons did not receive the standard of care they should have done, which has caused them unimaginable distress.
NHS Improvement (NHSI) has agreed to establish a review in line with our recommendations and will share any learning it identifies across the NHS as needed. The review will only commence once a current Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation into NEP has concluded. The review will also consider whether there is sufficient evidence for a recommendation to be made to the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care for a public inquiry.
The Ombudsman’s investigations
Mr R died in 2008. He was admitted to the Linden Centre at NEP with an early diagnosis of ADHD and was at risk of taking his own life.
The Ombudsman’s investigation into Mr R’s case found that there were missed opportunities to mitigate the risk of him taking his own life. While NEP acknowledged that staff did not respond adequately when Mr R threatened to harm himself, the Ombudsman found the Trust failed to adequately manage his ward leave and properly assess and manage risk.
Matthew Leahy died in November 2012, aged 20. On 7 November 2012 the police brought Matthew to NEP’s Linden Centre as a place of safety and he was admitted under the Mental Health Act. He had been previously diagnosed as having delusional disorder.
While some aspects of Matthew’s care and treatment were in line with relevant guidelines, the Ombudsman’s investigation found that NEP did not have an updated care plan in place, he was not adequately observed, NEP did not properly allocate a keyworker to him or respond appropriately when he reported being raped. Finally, NEP’s record keeping was not robust as some paperwork was lost and Matthew’s care plan was written after his death.
The Ombudsman also found in Matthew’s case that NEP’s investigation into his death was inadequate and the Trust was not open and honest with his family about what was being done to improve safety at the Linden Centre.
Rob Behrens, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, yesterday said:
‘These vulnerable young men and their families were badly let down by North Essex Partnership Trust. The lack of timely safety improvements following their deaths is completely unacceptable and it’s important the NHS understands why this happened and what lessons can be learned to prevent the same mistakes happening again.
‘I am pleased that NHS Improvement (NHSI) has accepted our recommendation to review what happened at the Trust and to share the findings from this with parliament and the wider health system.’
As part of the investigation into Matthew’s death, the Ombudsman developed a timeline of other evidence indicating systemic failings in properly addressing issues of patient safety at NEP over more than a decade. This evidence includes the findings from a Coroner’s inquest, a number of critical Care Quality Commission (CQC) inspection reports and criticisms by Essex Police, which although not reaching the evidential threshold for a charge of manslaughter, identified ‘clear and basic failings’ in its investigation.
Melanie and Michael Leahy, parents of Matthew, yesterday said:
‘The passing of our son Matthew James Leahy has left a void that nothing can fill. Not a day passes when we do not miss him and despair at the thought of how his life was cut short, so needlessly.
‘Our son was ready to go travelling and celebrate his 21st birthday. He should never have died. Sectioned under the Mental Health Act, he was alone, scared and failed in the most appalling way by those entrusted with his care.
‘We want the public to know what happened to our son so this never happens again.’
Following the Ombudsman’s investigation into Mr R’s case, the Trust paid his family £1,250 in recognition of the distress caused, wrote to them to formally apologise and set out the action taken to improve its services.
Following Matthew’s case, the Ombudsman recommends that within two months, the Essex University Partnership NHS Foundation Trust should:
- write to his mother, Mrs Leahy, to formally apologise and acknowledge the failings,
- provide a detailed action plan explaining what has been done to prevent recurrence of the failings, and
- make a payment of £500 to Mrs Leahy in recognition of the distress caused by the receipt of inaccurate information about safety changes in February 2015.
 Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (EPUT) was established on 1 April 2017 following the dissolution of North Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (NEP) and South Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (SEPT).
Latest News from
Draft Public Service Ombudsman Bill laid in Parliament05/12/2016 12:37:21
A new complaints body will provide the public with greater confidence that their voices have been heard.
Folkestone council chastised by Ombudsman over housing complaint21/02/2020 09:15:00
Folkestone and Hythe council has been heavily criticised by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman for the way it responded to a complaint about its treatment of a homeless family.
1 in 5 mental health patients don’t feel safe in NHS care, Ombudsman finds20/02/2020 16:15:00
A new survey published yesterday by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman found that one in five people did not feel safe while in the care of the NHS mental health service that treated them.
Carolyn Hirst, Anu Singh and Linda Farrant join the Board as non-executive directors18/02/2020 14:15:00
Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman are delighted to welcome Carolyn Hirst, Anu Singh and Linda Farrant to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman's Board as non-executive directors.
Ombudsman reminds councils about care home top-up fees13/02/2020 09:15:00
Councils across England are being reminded by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman of their duties under the Care Act to administer ‘top-up fees’ for people contributing towards relatives’ care.
Luton to review some of its special educational needs services following Ombudsman’s investigation07/02/2020 14:15:00
Luton Borough Council has agreed to create a detailed action plan to improve some of its services for children with special educational needs after the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman uncovered significant concerns during a recent investigation.
Derby girl misses out on education because of council delays06/02/2020 12:15:00
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has criticised Derby City Council after a girl with autism missed out on around 18 months of special education support because of council delays.
Daventry District Council fails to tackle industrial noise complaint properly30/01/2020 09:15:00
Some homeowners on a new housing development in the Daventry area have been plagued by excessive noise from a nearby industrial estate because the district council has not done enough to investigate their concerns, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman reports.
Council makes serious unsubstantiated allegations about asylum seeker during Ombudsman investigation23/01/2020 12:15:00
Sandwell council refused to let a vulnerable mother have her representative present at an important meeting – and made serious and unsubstantiated allegations about both of them during an investigation by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman.