National Infrastructure Commission
Passengers facing second-class mobile connectivity on UK rail network
Passengers will continue to experience inadequate mobile services on the UK’s railways due to slow government progress in fixing gaps in connectivity.
The National Infrastructure Commission has warned that progress on mobile connectivity on rail has stalled since the government accepted the findings of the Commission’s 2016 Connected Future report. It is calling for clear ministerial leadership in response to avoid further delays.
Mobile services are essential to everyday life and business productivity, yet the current rate of progress on rail connectivity is, the Commission believes, insufficient to ensure that even basic mobile services – voice calls and 4G data – will be reliably available throughout the UK’s network within the next five years.
In its new report on the progress of its recommendations – Connected Future: Getting back on track – the Commission found that a lack of leadership from government, frequent ministerial changes, and split departmental responsibilities have halted any initial momentum in steps to improve passengers’ access to mobile services. As a result, the gap between an increasingly connected society and a disconnected railway could become even more stark.
In contrast, road users have benefitted from ‘clear, continuous progress’ on connectivity, with UK motorways now offering near universal coverage for voice and data calls and good progress elsewhere across the roads network.
National Infrastructure Commission Chair Sir John Armitt yesterday said:
“We’re all used to having mobile access on the move but for many passengers, loss of coverage while on the train occurs with frustrating regularity. In too many areas our rail infrastructure seems stuck in the digital dark ages.
“As coverage improves elsewhere, people will find it increasingly frustrating that it doesn’t extend to the railway. It would be like finding that the railway only accepts cheques for payment and not debit cards or contactless.
“Government has dropped the ball on this issue and passengers will expect it to get a firm grip and find a solution. It must set out clear plans for delivering railway connectivity and giving passengers the reassurance they need.”
Plugging gaps in rail connectivity
In its original 2016 Connected Future report, the National Infrastructure Commission recommended rail passengers should be able to access ‘high capacity wireless connectivity’, with the necessary trackside infrastructure for an open and accessible telecommunications network being in place by 2025 at the latest, to take advantage of emerging 5G technologies.
While there have been range of trials across the network – such as trials of 5G technology on South Western Railway and a testing programme operated by Network Rail – these have been piecemeal.
The Commission’s research found no evidence of an overall plan exists for rail connectivity. Combined with the cancellation or deprioritisation of a number of other programmes, the research suggests rail will fall further behind road in terms of progress towards seamless mobile connectivity.
With few technical barriers to delivering rail connectivity, it found the lack of progress is largely down to difficulties accessing Network Rail land, commercial barriers created by the costs of installation and associated potential risks, and a failure of leadership.
Momentum developed in government in 2017 to improve mobile connectivity has been lost due to multiple ministerial changes and no clear leadership for the project across the two departments responsible: DCMS and the Department for Transport.
In response, the Commission identifies four areas in which government must improve progress on rail mobile connectivity:
- Leadership and action – appointment of a ministerial lead and publication by the Department of Transport of a clear plan of action by December 2020
- Access to trackside land – Network Rail must put in place by December 2020 arrangements for third party access to trackside land for the purposes of delivering the trackside connectivity network
- Commercial barriers – government should set out plans for a competitive process for delivering connectivity improvements on specific routes, building on lessons from the active trials currently taking place. These processes should begin no later than June 2021
- Filling evidence gaps – Ofcom should regularly report on the extent and quality of mobile coverage on the railways, to ensure progress is tracked and to build consumer awareness.
Maintaining momentum on digital roads
The Commission’s original recommendations on roads – endorsed by government – stated that the necessary infrastructure for an open and accessible mobile telecommunications and backhaul network that is fit for the future, must be in place by 2025 at the latest.
While progress on digital connectivity on UK roads is good, the Commission is calling for Ofcom to publish more consistent tracking of mobile coverage data for roads and in-car coverage, which disaggregates the data for motorways, A roads and B roads, and have this in place for Ofcom’s 2020 Connected Nations report.
Notes to editors
The 2020 Connected Nations is the regulator Ofcom’s annual report looking at all aspects of mobile coverage in the UK, including on roads and rail.
The Commission’s original 2016 Connected Future report recommended:
- Government must create a strong digital champion, backed by a dedicated cabinet minister, to drive change and boost mobile connectivity
- Government and Ofcom must ensure that essential outdoor mobile services – such as basic talk, text and data – were available wherever people live, work and travel
- The government should ensure the trackside infrastructure for 5G is in place on key rail routes and motorways by 2025
- Local authorities should work with network providers to develop approaches that enable the deployment of technology for 5G deployment in urban centres.
Latest News from
National Infrastructure Commission
James Heath speech to CBI Infrastructure Board05/03/2021 16:05:00
The Commission’s chief executive spoke to members of the Confederation of British Industry’s Infrastructure Board today, offering reflections on the government’s National Infrastructure Strategy, the Commission’s priorities for 2021 as set out in our Annual Monitoring Report, and to look ahead to some of the long term infrastructure challenges that the Commission is likely to tackle in its second National Infrastructure Assessment.
Commission welcomes next steps on UK infrastructure bank03/03/2021 15:10:00
The National Infrastructure Commission has welcomed the announcement in today’s Budget on next steps for the creation of a UK infrastructure bank, based in Leeds.
Learning the lessons for a highly renewable future25/02/2021 10:25:00
The last few months have been a busy time for UK energy policy. The government published its long awaited Energy White Paper, The Climate Change Committee produced its 1,000 pages of advice to the government on the level of the next carbon budget, and HM Treasury published its interim report on the costs of the net zero transition. And there’s more to come.
Maintaining operability of highly renewable electricity system possible at little additional cost25/02/2021 09:25:00
Concerns about operating the electricity networks when there are high levels of renewables generation can be overcome without significant costs to the consumer through effective deployment of existing and emerging technologies, according to analysis from the National Infrastructure Commission.
Commission welcomes next steps on Oxford-Cambridge Arc22/02/2021 10:10:00
The National Infrastructure Commission has welcomed government’s announcement of next steps in developing a spatial framework for the Oxford-Cambridge Arc.
Plans of action needed next to deliver strategic goals, says Commission17/02/2021 14:15:00
Detailed plans for decarbonising energy supply, accelerating the roll out of electric vehicle charge points and connecting hard to reach areas with high capacity broadband are among the next steps needed to ensure government can deliver its aims for levelling up and meeting the net zero target, according to the National Infrastructure Commission.
'Aim for gain' to support natural capital assets05/02/2021 14:10:00
Infrastructure developments should aim to leave the environment in a measurably better condition than before to reinforce steps already being taken to protect the UK’s diminishing natural resources, according to a discussion paper published today by the National Infrastructure Commission.
Call for evidence opens on potential of greenhouse gas removal infrastructure to boost UK net zero strategy21/01/2021 11:15:00
The National Infrastructure Commission is inviting businesses, policy makers, scientists, academics, thinktanks and investors to share their views on the potential of emerging technologies designed to remove harmful greenhouse gas emissions directly from the atmosphere and store them.
Focus rail investment on linking key cities in North and Midlands to unlock economic benefits, says Commission16/12/2020 14:15:00
Improving rail links between cities in the North and Midlands should be the first priority of a new approach to end stop-start investments and help level up the UK as part of a wider economic strategy, according to a major new report by the National Infrastructure Commission.