Post-16 Skills Plan - A Monopoly on Qualifications?
Blog posted by: Michael Lemin, Thursday, 16 February 2017.
Following a review led by Lord Sainsbury, the government's Post-16 Skills Plan proposes overhauling technical education for 16-18 year olds. The unintended consequences of the policy could potentially cause more harm than good – here we look at the Plan in more detail.
The principles behind the reforms are admirable; aligning the skills system to needs of employers, eliminating 'low value' qualifications that are of little use to learners, and ensuring financial sustainability of the system. Unfortunately, as the policies emerge and are put into practice, there are serious concerns about the negative impact this could have on learners, educators and employers.
The plan proposes moving away from the current model, where colleges, schools and training providers have a choice of Awarding Organisation. The new system will mean skills training is divided into 15 ‘routes’ and a licence given to a single Awarding Organisation to deliver each part of the skills qualification system. The intention is to ensure that the system is more simple and consistent.
Unfortunately, one only has to look at Southern Rail as an example of what can happen when an organisation is awarded a monopoly. Customers (in these cases, colleges, schools and training providers) will not have the option to take their business elsewhere if they’re not happy with the product (qualification) or service offered.
Some Awarding Organisations may feel that the need to provide good customer service disappears in light of having no competition. I can see a situation where learners could find themselves waiting a long time to receive certificates from some Awarding Organisations. The incentive for Awarding Organisations to innovate and invest in developing qualifications for the emerging skills needs of our economy is taken away.
These factors are likely to have a hugely negative impact on skills provision, if not addressed. The problem is that there is such huge reform in the sector, and the skills system is very complex, evolved over decades of interventionist policy making.
It’s difficult for ministers or civil servants to pay due attention to perceived minor details in light of the scale of change. But it is these details that will determine the= success of their plans. The next few years are crucial; if we get it wrong, the results could be wholly detrimental. Employers could walk away; learners could lose confidence in the skills system.
It’s not all doom and gloom, however. It’s been genuinely exciting to see employers taking such an active part in the skills system in recent years. This will help to ensure that we create a system that gives people the skills that employers want. Apprenticeships are back in the limelight and learners are seriously considering them as a viable route in to employment, in light of rising university costs.
We need to build on this early success and work with the government to highlight the need for continued discussion and consideration of the finer details of emerging skills policy. From our unique vantage point, we’re excited about the potential positive impacts that reforms will bring to employers and learners, and we’ll continue to challenge emerging policy and constrictively suggest changes to ensure that the new system works for all.
Latest News from
Spotlight on IT: Srikanth Kataram20/09/2019 12:28:00
We caught up with NCFE Software Delivery Coach, Srikanth Kataram, about his role and life in the IT team at NCFE.
Sexual Health Education: why inclusivity is key20/09/2019 10:10:00
With new government guidance on Relationships, Sex and Health Education (RSHE) rubber-stamped by parliament, schools have 12 months until they must follow the new requirements. Some schools have opted to start using the guidance this September, and others will want to begin their preparations in earnest this term.
Making the most of personal finances20/09/2019 09:10:00
According to research reported recently on fenews.co.uk, ‘98% of employers believe that their employees’ financial wellness has a direct impact on their business performance – especially concerning employee productivity (67%) and engagement (62%).
Tips for Teachers: are you ready for statutory RSHE?17/09/2019 09:15:00
Blog posted by: Jan Lever, CEO, Jigsaw PSHE, 16 September 2019).
Our 5 top tips for building a successful Study Programme16/09/2019 10:25:00
Building a successful Study Programme can be the key to a learner’s success and future employment prospects.
Tips for teachers - improving achievement when delivering NCFE qualifications for schools13/09/2019 11:15:00
We know that you want the best for your students, and improving their achievement rates is not only great for your school, it also boosts your students’ confidence and will support their future education and careers. We’ve complied our top tips for improving achievement rates during delivery of our V Certs and other NCFE qualifications and ahead of the assessment.
The Importance of English Skills in Young People13/09/2019 09:38:00
With the recent Functional Skills reform, it's rare to go a day without hearing about maths and English within education sector news.
Looking forward to the year ahead12/09/2019 11:05:00
As we start afresh and look forward to the year ahead, it’s clear that there are lots of exciting and challenging times awaiting us in the world of further education and training. With change often comes trepidation, but we’re here to help guide our customers through reform and new ways of working to create the best possible experiences for learners, no matter which path they choose.