Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Post-Brexit Channel Tunnel sovereignty and safety solutions recommended
The European Scrutiny Committee of the House of Commons has made a series of recommendations on the way safety rules are set for the Channel Tunnel.
- Read the report: Brexit: The future operation of the Channel Tunnel Fixed
Link | PDF version
- Inquiry: Brexit: The future operation of the Channel Tunnel Fixed Link
- European Scrutiny Committee
The recommendations are contained in a new Committee report, Brexit: The future operation of the Channel Tunnel Fixed Link.
The ‘Fixed Link’ is the official name for the infrastructure made up of the Channel Tunnel and the two terminals for it at Folkstone in the UK and Coquelles in France.
In July 2020, the European Commission published proposals outlining how the Channel Tunnel should operate at the end of the post-Brexit transition period. These were that: (1) EU rail safety law should continue to apply on the UK-side of the Tunnel; and (2) the European Court of Justice should be the final arbiter of any dispute between the UK and France. In response, the Government rejected these proposals. The Committee endorsed this Government stance and, in today’s report, makes a number of recommendations concerning the future operation of the Channel Tunnel.
The Committee’s recommendations – set out in more detail below - are deemed necessary because of the departure of the UK from the EU and the current absence of a long-term agreement between France and the UK on the way safety regulations in the Tunnel are governed.
The recommendations stem from the likelihood that any future adjustments to safety rules from the French side could be proposed under EU law – which no longer applies in the UK. It is also necessary for any changes to be safe, transparent and legally sound for the public, stakeholders and Parliament. To explain the recommendations, some context is required.
The Tunnel and terminals are currently regulated through a combination of the Anglo-French arrangement first established to build the link – the 1986 Treaty of Canterbury – and, more recently, EU law. The UK/EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement that came into force at the end of December 2020 did not cover the Channel Tunnel. Therefore, since the UK is no longer bound by EU law, the governance of the only surface transport connection linking the UK to mainland Europe has reverted to the terms of the Treaty of Canterbury.
However, the safety and governance issues arising from EU laws, which on the UK side have been retained in domestic law since the end of the transition period, are vital to the effective functioning of the Channel Tunnel. So far, only short-term extensions of the current arrangements arising from EU law - for example, for the safety permissions for trains to run on certain tracks - have been agreed.
Any failure to agree clear guidelines following Brexit could create uncertainty over safety and cause serious business continuity issues for the private concession holder currently running the tunnel (Getlink, formerly known as Eurotunnel) and the train operators.
Having reached the end of the Brexit transition period without a long-term agreement with France on the future operation of the Tunnel, the management of safety issues falls back to the French rail safety authority, the Établissement Public de Sécurité Ferroviaire, and the UK Office of Rail and Road, with each taking responsibility for their respective sides of the Tunnel. This fallback position appears to be very similar to the ‘bi-national approach’ advocated by the Government as a permanent solution for the future management of the safety issues at the Tunnel.
The Committee recommended that this bi-national approach be formalised and that new management structures be agreed to provide for joint working and the solving of disputes. These structures should be made clear to the public and stakeholders such as Getlink.
The Committee also recommended in its report that the Government commit to inform Parliament about any changes and update the Committee on a monthly basis on the progress of negotiations.
The Committee further recommended that the Government establish mechanisms for the UK to be given sufficient advance notice of any future EU proposals that cover the Tunnel and terminals. This would guard against the possibility of France, as an EU member, being required to implement EU rail safety standards which the UK may not wish to apply on the UK side and give time for negotiations.
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Chancellor should seek long-term solutions to fire-up business recovery, say MPs26/02/2021 15:33:00
The Chancellor should use next week’s Budget to address gaps in financial support, affecting the self-employed, mothers who have recently taken maternity leave, and those working in sectors such as the creative industries, say the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee in an interim pre-budget report on The impact of Coronavirus on businesses and workers, published today.
Transport Committee to investigate the roll-out and safety of Smart Motorways26/02/2021 11:38:00
The benefits and safety of Smart Motorways are to be investigated by the Transport Committee in a new inquiry, launching today.
Access to pension savings inquiry launched23/02/2021 12:25:00
The Work and Pensions Committee investigates access to pension savings in the second part of its broad inquiry into the impact of the pension freedoms and the protection of savers.
Children in care homes: Education Committee to launch new inquiry18/02/2021 15:33:00
The Education Committee is to carry out an inquiry into children’s homes, as part of its continuing work examining the issues faced by left behind groups.
MPs to discuss petition relating to the movement of goods between Great Britain and Northern Ireland17/02/2021 14:38:00
On Monday 22 February, MPs will discuss a petition relating to the movement of goods between Great Britain and Northern Ireland in the latest e-petition session scheduled by the Petitions Committee.
Government must set out how and when it will lift lockdown restrictions with economic and epidemiological modelling to support it16/02/2021 13:33:00
The Treasury Committee has published the third report of its inquiry into the Economic Impact of Coronavirus – ‘Gaps in Support and Economic Analysis’.
Vulnerable Children and public services16/02/2021 11:25:00
Peers will examine how well public services tackle underlying causes of child vulnerability in families including domestic abuse, poor mental health and addiction.
Report: Foreign Involvement in the Defence Supply Chain15/02/2021 15:33:00
The Defence Sub-Committee yesterday published its report on Foreign Involvement in the Defence Supply Chain.
EU Committee seeks Government’s view on extending provisional application of the Trade and Cooperation Agreement15/02/2021 11:38:00
Following the announcement that the EU is seeking an extension to the provisional application of the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement, to give time for the completion of ratification procedures, the Chair of the European Union Committee, Lord Kinnoull, recently (12 February 2021) wrote to the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, Rt Hon Michael Gove MP.