Requesting additional safeguards to ensure that children’s rights and best interests are upheld during the coronavirus outbreak
The Children’s Commissioner Anne Longfield has written to both the Permanent Secretary for the Department for Education and the Permanent Secretary for the Department of Health and Social Care requesting additional safeguards for particular measures to ensure that children’s rights and best interests are always upheld.
Find the full letter below;
Dear Jonathan and Chris,
I appreciate that these are unprecedented times, and as such it is reasonable and necessary for the Government to seek emergency powers through the Coronavirus Act in order to protect public health. However, I am concerned that some of the legal protections for the most vulnerable children may be overturned in the enactment of the Act and therefore I am requesting additional safeguards for particular measures to ensure that children’s rights and best interests are always upheld.
Children with disabilities and additional care needs
Children with disabilities and additional care needs are a group who may be most negatively affected. Local Authorities will no longer have to comply with their duties under the Care Act to asses children’s needs for continuing care after the age of 18. The Act also removes the duty under the Children Act to provide support for young people who may need continuing care after 18 if their assessments have not been completed under the Care Act. Without assessment of their needs and clear support plans in place, a group of children turning 18 in the next few months are likely to be facing a very precarious future. In addition, without this help in place not only may their own health be in danger, but they may also pose a public health risk if they are not supported to self-isolate or stay at home.
In addition, the bill grants powers to the Secretary of State to relax duties on Local Authorities to provide appropriate education and health care to children with additional needs, to admit those children to their chosen school, and review their plans annually. Local Authorities would then only have to make ‘reasonable endeavours’ to meet those duties. I would appreciate clarity on what reasonable endeavours include, and how they will be monitored. I would also like to be notified if and when the Secretary of State issues a notice to use those powers.
I would like to see schools, community health services and other services co-ordinating information to identify children who may be at risk without additional support, and establishing clear plans for how families will be helped to care for these children.
The Act also removes the duty to assess the needs of young carers – we know that around 100,000 children are caring for family members, and this is likely to increase in the coming months. In doing so they will be providing immense support to health and care services. It will be important that they are able to continue to receive assessments to identify what help they need.
It is essential that clear guidance is given to Local Authorities informing them that their duties to young carers and children with additional needs under the Care Act and Children Act may only be ignored as a last resort, and for monitoring to be introduced of the numbers of children and young people whose need for an assessment could not be met.
Powers to detain children under the Mental Health Act
I understand the need to reduce the burden on health staff, however granting powers to detain under the Mental Health Act on the approval of one doctor, rather than the usual two, could increase the risk of children being inappropriately detained. One thousand children were detained under the Mental Health Act last year, and it is vital that we ensure robust protections for them continue. I would like there to be an expectation that children should be prioritised when it comes to having a second doctor, and it would be helpful if the number of detentions authorised by one doctor is recorded. Additional guidance may be required here. The risk of inappropriate detention is compounded as CQC has suspended their routine inspections, advocacy services are going online, and Mental Health Act tribunals may be conducted without doctors or lay members. I would like to see children prioritised for full tribunals, and to be well supported to access remote advocacy services.
Investigations into deaths related to Covid-19
Although thankfully children seem to be less affected by Covid-19, there is still a risk – particularly to those children with additional health needs. While I appreciate the proportionality of removing the requirement for inquests to be held with a jury, I would like confirmation that if any deaths of children from Covid-19 occur – including those in institutional settings, such as children’s homes, young offenders institutions and mental health wards – that appropriate investigations into these will still take place, to understand what measures could have prevented them.
Detaining children on public health grounds
The Act also introduces new powers to detain children on public health grounds, for a period of up to fourteen days. I agree that this may be necessary in order to prevent the further spread of disease, however I am concerned that the Act allows this to be done without consent from someone with responsibility for the child, and only requires ‘reasonable steps’ to be taken to inform someone with responsibility of the detention. I would like to see protections for children in these circumstances strengthened, with timescales in place for when those with responsibility will be informed about a child’s detention. I would also like data to be made available to me on all instances where a child is detained using these powers.
With further guidance, careful monitoring and a clear understanding that these measures will only be applied as a last resort, I believe the Government will be better able to balance the pressure on all services and the need to protect children’s rights. It would be very helpful for Government Departments to provide updates to Parliament on how the rights and needs of children are affected by the measures in the Act.
Children’s Commissioner for England
Latest News from
Anne Longfield responding to the Government’s plan to reopen schools to all children in September02/07/2020 15:20:00
Anne Longfield responded to the Government’s plan to reopen schools to all children in September.
We are running out of time to set up vital summer schemes for children24/06/2020 12:20:00
Blog posted by: Anne Longfield Children’s Commissioner for England, 23 June 2020.
Fact checking claims about child poverty23/06/2020 14:20:00
At Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) on 17 June, there was disagreement between the Leader of the Opposition, Keir Starmer, and the Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, on trends in the level of child poverty.
Children’s Commissioner for England Anne Longfield responds to Government announcement on extra funding for schools19/06/2020 14:43:00
Anne Longfield, Children’s Commissioner for England, has responded to the Government’s announcement on extra funding for schools.
Anne Longfield responding to reports on the use of restraint and the use of separation in youth custody19/06/2020 13:38:00
Anne Longfield, yesterday responded to two reports on the use of restraint and the use of separation in youth custody.
Anne Longfield responds to extension of free school meals over summer holidays17/06/2020 09:20:00
Anne Longfield, Children’s Commissioner for England, yesterday responded to the extension of Free School Meals over the summer holidays.
How the Covid-19 crisis has affected children’s right to an education15/06/2020 14:25:00
As the Children’s Commissioner argued in the Yorkshire Post last week, the right to education has been the defining child right’s struggle of the past 200 years. The aim being that poor children were taken out of the workplace, and into the classroom.
The numbers behind homeschooling during lockdown11/06/2020 17:02:00
In light of recent announcements that many students may not go back to school before September (if then), the Children’s Commissioner’s Office has undertaken some preliminary research on the homeschooling provided to children during lockdown.
The IMO Podcast: an award nominated podcast featuring open and honest conversations with care leavers11/06/2020 16:10:00
The IMO Podcast has been nominated for Best New Podcast in the British Podcast Awards. In this blog we take a look at why we started the podcast, how we went about making it, and highlight some of the guests we’ve spoken to.