Restoring confidence in medical devices. Action Plan after the PIP scandal tightened control in Europe
The EPSCO Council has discussed the joint actions taken by the European Commission and the Member States to restore confidence following the scandal of defective breast implants produced by the French PIP company. These measures were included in the Joint Plan for Immediate Actions under the existing Medical Devices legislation (the so-called PIP Joint Action Plan) agreed in 2012 (See IP/12/119).
“Consumers are safer today than they were when the PIP scandal was discovered”, said Neven Mimica, Commissioner for Consumer Policy. “Thanks to close cooperation between Member States and the European Commission, today's rules on medical devices are better enforced. We succeeded in particular to tighten the control of notified bodies. Some key improvements, however, require a reinforced legal basis. This is why I called on the Member States to reach a political agreement before the end of this year in order to allow rapid adoption of this vital dossier.”
The PIP scandal made it clear that immediate improvements in the oversight of medical devices were needed. This is why the European Commission and Member States agreed on an Action Plan aiming at improving the control on the basis of existing legislation. It focusses on four key areas: the functioning of notified bodies; market surveillance; coordination in the fields of vigilance; communication and transparency.
Main achievements under the Joint Action Plan
The Plan has resulted in substantial progress, in particular in the following areas:
Based on a Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 920/2013 of 2013 clarifying the criteria to be met by notified bodies, Member States have re-assessed the qualifications and the scope of activities of their notified bodies. This resulted in corrective measures or limitations in the scope of activities of notified bodies in 8 countries;
By May 2014, voluntary joint audits of notified bodies by teams involving auditors from several Member States and the Commission have been carried out in 22 out of 23 countries having notified bodies. The last audit in the remaining country has already been scheduled. The audits have resulted in the identification of problems in the way notified bodies operated. Where major shortcomings were identified, immediate corrective action was taken, including temporarily suspending or limiting the scope of activities of the notified body concerned. In one case, the notified body is no longer able to issue certificates. Where necessary, a re-assessment of all certificates issued was requested. For one notified body of the 689 certificates checked, 45 were suspended and 18 withdrawn.. Under the new Commission Implementing Regulation, such joint audits were made mandatory for new designations and re-designations of notified bodies. 20-25 such audits are foreseen for 2014.
PIP highlighted the weaknesses in vigilance which existed in the system. The Action Plan tightens up this system by recommending that notified bodies shall carry out unannounced audits of manufacturers. Notified bodies have reported that they now are carrying out or are in the process of launching such audits. However, no reliable information is available so far on the number of unannounced audits or their effects.
Monthly vigilance teleconferences with Member States, chaired by the Commission services, now take place and are improving coordination between Member States. More than 70 specific cases have been presented for coordination. In addition, the Commission Joint Research Centre has started to analyse trends on incidents.
The Commission Staff Working Document discussed in the EPSCO Council contains a detailed analysis of these elements as well as additional work arising from the action plan such as a Commission Recommendation on the use of a specific system for traceability of medical devices adopted in April 2013, ongoing discussion on improving product registers, Member States reports on their market surveillance activities as basis for further improvement, or discussions on incident reporting from medical practitioners and patients.
The analysis shows that on certain aspects of the Joint Action Plan progress has been limited and continued work is necessary until the new legislation comes into force. These aspects concern in particular:
The organisation of unannounced audits and their effectiveness;
Development of a common understanding of market surveillance and better co-ordination and communication on surveillance data;
Assessment of how to make best use of registers for providing data and identifying problems on the long term with devices;
Identification of mechanisms to detect signals, trends and increased incident frequency more effectively based on a JRC project to be presented mid 2014;
Assessment with Member States of the need for, and possibilities of, organising peer training programmes.
The implementation of the Joint Plan has been a success. However, it is a series of short term measures designed to maximise the potential of existing legislation. A long term solution requires a thorough revision of the legal framework. The adoption of the proposed new Regulations is necessary to solve a number of outstanding issues. This relates in particular to:
the scope of the legislation,
the governance of the system and its transparency,
certain obligations of notified bodies, in particular in relation to mandatory unannounced audits,
the risk classification of devices and the safety and performance requirements,
the obligations of economic operators,
the reporting of incidents by users and patients to the Competent Authorities,
certain aspects relating to vigilance system and market surveillance,
the role and the functioning of the database Eudamed and the access of notified bodies to Eudamed, and
the traceability of devices.
Each of these points is pivotal towards ensuring patient and consumer safety.
David Hudson (+32 2 296 83 35)
Andreana Stankova (+32 2 295 78 57)
For the public: Europe Direct by phone 00 800 6 7 8 9 10 11 or by email
Latest News from
Immigration liaison officers: Council Presidency and European Parliament reach provisional agreement19/02/2019 16:25:00
The EU is strengthening the cooperation & coordination between liaison officers deployed to third countries by member states or the EU to deal with immigration-related issues.
EESC goes to Belfast to listen to concerns over #Brexit19/02/2019 14:10:00
The EESC, the EU house of organised civil society, represented by its Diversity Europe Group, met at Queen's University in Belfast on 15 February 2019 to take stock of the Brexit process and focus on its consequences for the Northern Ireland peace process.
European Coordinated Plan on Artificial Intelligence19/02/2019 12:25:00
The Council has adopted conclusions on the Coordinated Plan on the development and use of Artificial Intelligence Made in Europe.
EC welcomes first-ever EU standards to reduce pollution from trucks19/02/2019 11:37:00
The European Parliament and the Council have reached provisional agreement on a Regulation setting, for the first time in the EU, strict CO2 emission standards for trucks.
EU and global securities regulators welcome agreement on data transfer19/02/2019 09:25:00
The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) welcome the Opinion of the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) on their administrative arrangement for the transfer of personal data between European Economic Area (EEA) Financial Supervisory Authorities and non-EEA Financial Supervisory Authorities.
ESMA to recognise three UK CCPs in the event of a no-deal Brexit18/02/2019 16:25:00
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has announced that in the event of a no-deal Brexit, three central counterparties (CCPs) established in the United Kingdom (UK) – LCH Limited, ICE Clear Europe Limited and LME Clear Limited – will be recognised to provide their services in the European Union (EU).
Ensuring basic air connectivity in the event of no-deal Brexit – Council sets its position18/02/2019 14:10:00
The EU is taking measures to mitigate the severe disruption to air connectivity for passengers and freight between the EU and the UK in the event of the UK leaving the EU without a deal.
New EU rules cut red tape for citizens living or working in another Member State as of tomorrow18/02/2019 13:43:00
New EU rules to cut costs & formalities for citizens living outside their home country now apply across the European Union.
EU steps up efforts to keep unsafe products off the internal market18/02/2019 11:25:00
The EU is introducing new rules which will ensure that products placed on the single market are safe & compliant with EU legislation protecting public interests, such as health & safety in general, health & safety at the workplace, consumers, the environment and public security.