Ruling regarding minimum wage for off-shored public contracts
The minimum wage fixed in the context of the award of public contracts may not be extended to employees of a subcontractor established in another Member State, where those employees perform the contract at issue exclusively in that State
It is incompatible with the freedom to provide services to require the payment of a minimum wage without any connection with the cost of living in that Member State
A Law of the Land of North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) provides that certain public service contracts may be awarded only to undertakings which, at the time of the submission of the tender, have agreed to pay their staff a minimum hourly wage of €8.62 for the performance of the service. That law seeks to ensure that employees are paid a reasonable wage in order to avoid both ‘social dumping’ and the penalisation of competing undertakings which grant a reasonable wage to their employees.
The city of Dortmund, applying that law to a tender for a public contract relating to the digitalisation of documents and the conversion of data for its urban-planning service, required that thesuccessful tenderer guarantee a minimum wage of €8.62 even for workers employed by a subcontractor established in another Member State (in this case, Poland) and who would carry out the work exclusively in that State. Since the competent German Public Procurement Board, hearing an action brought by Bundesdruckerei, a German undertaking concerned by that invitation to tender, has doubts as to the compatibility of the legislation at issue (as applied by the city of Dortmund) with European Union law and, in particular, with the freedom to provide services, it referred a question to the Court of Justice.
In today’s judgment, the Court replies that, in a situation such as that at issue in the present case, in which a tenderer intends to carry out a public contract by having recourse exclusively to workers employed by a subcontractor established in a Member State other than that to which the contracting authority belongs, the freedom to provide services precludes the Member State to which the contracting authority belongs from requiring the subcontractor to pay a minimum wage to workers.
The Court declares first of all1that such legislation is capable of constituting a restriction of the freedom to provide services. The imposition of a minimum wage on a subcontractor established in another Member State in which minimum rates of pay are lower constitutes an additional economic burden that may prohibit, impede or render less attractive the provision of services in that otherMember State.
The Court notes however that such legislation may, in principle, be justified by the objective of protecting employees.
However, in so far as it applies solely to public contracts, such legislation is not appropriate for achieving that objective if there is no information to suggest that employees working in the private sector are not in need of the same wage protection as those working in the context of public contracts.
1 After holding that, in contrast to the Rüffert case, in particular (see the judgment of the Court of 3 April 2008 in Case C-346/06 and press release No 20/08), the present case does not concern the posting of workers.
In any event, the national legislation at issue, in so far as its scope extends to cover a situation such as that in the dispute, appears disproportionate.
By imposing a fixed minimum wage corresponding, to that required in order to ensure reasonable remuneration for employees in Germany in the light of the cost of living in that country, but which bears no relation to the cost of living in the Member State in which the services relating to the public contract at issue are performed (in this case, Poland) and thereby preventing subcontractors established in another Member State from deriving a competitive advantage from the differences between the respective rates of pay, that national legislation goes beyond what is necessary to ensure that the objective of employee protection is attained.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of European Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Latest News from
Sahel and Central Africa: €210 million in EU humanitarian aid12/05/2021 09:25:00
The EU is reaffirming its solidarity with vulnerable people in countries in the Sahel and Central Africa through a humanitarian budget of €210 million in 2021.
Security and defence: EU to move forward on common security and defence11/05/2021 15:25:00
The Council yesterday approved conclusions affirming its determination to move forward on implementing the EU's security and defence agenda, enabling the EU to take more responsibility for its own security.
Trade of dual-use items: new EU rules adopted11/05/2021 13:25:00
The EU has upgraded its legislation on the export controls applicable to sensitive dual-use goods and technologies such as cyber-surveillance tools.
Conference on the Future of Europe: make your voice heard10/05/2021 15:25:00
Conference on the Future of Europe: make your voice heard.
Porto Social Summit: all partners commit to 2030 social targets10/05/2021 13:25:00
Partners have signed up to the three 2030 headline targets set in the Commission's European Pillar of Social Rights Action Plan in a joint Porto Social Commitment.
Speech by Vice-President Jourová at Riga StratCom Dialogue 202110/05/2021 12:38:00
Speech given recently (06 May 2021) by Vice-President Jourová at Riga StratCom Dialogue 2021.
Remarks by Commissioner Stella Kyriakides at the press conference on the EU Strategy for the development and availability of therapeutics10/05/2021 09:25:00
Remarks given recently (06 May 2021) by Commissioner Stella Kyriakides at the press conference on the EU Strategy for the development and availability of therapeutics.
PESCO: Canada, Norway and the United States will be invited to participate in the project Military Mobility07/05/2021 15:25:00
Following the requests of Canada, Norway and the United States of America to participate in the PESCO project Military Mobility, the Council yesterday adopted positive decisions authorising the coordinator of this project – the Netherlands – to invite the three countries. Canada, Norway and the United States of America will be the first third states to be invited to participate in a PESCO project.
Coronavirus: Commission proposes EU Strategy for the development and availability of therapeutics07/05/2021 13:25:00
The European Commission yesterday complemented the successful EU Vaccines Strategy with a strategy on COVID-19 therapeutics to support the development and availability of much-needed COVID-19 therapeutics, including for the treatment of ‘long COVID'.