Serious Fraud Office
SFO’s Alstom case concludes with sentencing of Alstom Network UK Ltd
Alstom Network UK Ltd has today been ordered to pay a total of £16.4 million for conspiracy to corrupt relating to a contract to supply trams in Tunisia. This sentence comprises £15 million in fines and £1.4 million in costs.
The company was convicted in April 2018 of conspiracy to corrupt, having paid an intermediary called Construction et Gestion Nevco Inc. (Nevco) €2.4 million to secure an €79.9 million contract with Transtu, the company responsible for running the Tunis Metro. To satisfy internal compliance checks and make its agreement with Nevco appear a legitimate contract for services, Alstom helped to produce paperwork as ‘evidence’ of services rendered. In reality, Nevco was simply a conduit for bribes. This was acknowledged by Alstom Network UK itself when it decided not to make a final payment of €240,000 in its original €2.64m contract.
Graham Hill, Robert Hallett and Alstom Network UK were acquitted in the same trial of alleged corruption in relation to transport contracts in India and Poland.
This concludes the SFO’s Alstom case, which has seen three individuals, Alstom Network UK Ltd and Alstom Power Ltd convicted of conspiracy to corrupt.
Lisa Osofsky, Director of the Serious Fraud Office said:
“This sentencing brings to an end a case which involved cooperation from over 30 countries and concerned conduct across Europe and beyond.
“It shows that we will work tirelessly with law enforcement around the world to root out bribery and corruption.”
The SFO’s wide-ranging investigation arose from the actions of Alstom subsidiaries in power and transport projects in Europe and around the world. In addition to the conviction of Alstom Network UK Ltd for bribery in relation to the Tunisian contract, John Venskus, Göran Wikström and Alstom Power Ltd pleaded guilty to bribing senior Lithuanian figures in order to win contracts to upgrade and refit a power station, the Lithuanian Power Plant (LPP), with tenders invited by the European Bank of Reconstruction and Development. Alstom Group companies paid over €5 million in bribes to secure the €240 million contract. As with the Tunisian conduct, papers were falsified to circumvent checks put in place to prevent bribery by Alstom staff responsible for preventing corruption.
Alstom Power Ltd was fined more than £6 million, required to pay nearly £11 million in compensation and ordered to pay £700,000 in costs. John Venskus received a three year and six month sentence and was ordered to pay £410,000 of costs and Göran Wikström received two years and seven months’ imprisonment and was ordered to pay £40,000 of costs. A third individual, Nicholas Reynolds, was found guilty by a jury of the same conduct, being sentenced to four years and six months’ imprisonment and ordered to pay £50,000 in costs.
Alstom Network UK and three more individuals – Michael Anderson, Jean-Daniel Lainé and Terrence Watson – were also charged in relation to allegations of bribery over a €229 million contract to provide rolling stock for the Budapest Metro System. All defendants were acquitted by a jury in November 2018.
The SFO’s investigation involved cooperation from more than 30 countries including France, Canada, USA, Hungary, Denmark, Austria, Slovakia, Czech Republic, Liechtenstein, India, Sweden, Lithuania, Switzerland and Tunisia.
Notes to Editors
- The SFO investigation commenced in 2009 as a result of information provided by the Office of the Attorney General in Switzerland concerning the Alstom Group, in particular Alstom Network UK Ltd.
- The charges brought against the companies and individuals across all three linked cases were conspiracy to corrupt, contrary to s1 of the Criminal Law Act 1977 and s1 of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1906.
- Alstom Network UK Ltd has 28 days to pay the £16.4million.
- Nicholas Reynolds (17 August 1965) was Global Sales Director for Alstom Power Ltd’s Boiler Retrofits unit, based in Derby. John Venskus (1 June 1943) was employed by Alstom Power Ltd as a Business Development Manager and on retirement by Alstom Power Sweden AB as a Relations Manager in Lithuania. He pleaded guilty on 2 October 2017. Göran Wikström (19 July 1950) was employed by Alstom Power Sweden AB as Regional Sales Director in Växjö, Sweden. He pleaded guilty on 22 June 2018.
- Alstom Power Ltd entered a guilty plea to one count of conspiracy to corrupt in relation to a contract to upgrade the burners at the Lithuanian Power Plant on 10 May 2016.
- Alstom Network UK Ltd, Terence Watson and Jean-Daniel Laine were acquitted of a charge of conspiracy to corrupt on 28 November 2018.
- Michael Anderson was acquitted of the same charge on 29 November 2018.
- Michael Anderson (18 January 1961) was Business Development Manager at Alstom Transport SA with responsibility for Eastern Europe, based in Paris. Jean-Daniel Lainé (7 April 1948) was, from 2006, Senior Vice President for Ethics and Compliance within Alstom International Network and a Director of Alstom Network UK, based in Paris. Terence Watson (13 November 1959) was, from 2006, Senior Vice-President for Europe and Central Asia within Alstom International Network, based near Paris.
- Graham Hill (13 July 1944) was Senior Vice President in Alstom’s Country Network based in Paris and a Director of Alstom International Ltd. Robert Hallett (31 May 1963) was Managing Director of Alstom Transport India. They were acquitted by jury on 10 April 2018.
Latest News from
Serious Fraud Office
Lisa Osofsky address to the Cambridge Symposium on Economic Crime09/09/2020 14:33:00
Lisa Osofsky address given recently (07 September 2020) to the Cambridge Symposium on Economic Crime.
Three former G4S executives charged with fraud against taxpayer08/09/2020 16:15:00
The Serious Fraud Office has charged three former executives of G4S Care and Justice Services (UK) Ltd (G4S C&J) with multiple offences in relation to a multi-year scheme to defraud the Ministry of Justice (MoJ).
SFO secures £5.45m confiscation order against ex-Afren CEO and COO03/08/2020 13:05:00
The SFO recently (31 July 2020) secured confiscation orders totalling £5,450,000 against the former Chief Executive Officer and Chief Operating Officer of Afren.
SFO charges GPT and three individuals following corruption investigation31/07/2020 09:33:00
The Serious Fraud Office has brought charges against GPT Special Project Management Ltd and three individuals in connection with its investigation into allegations concerning the conduct of GPT’s business in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
HMCPSI Inspection of SFO’s response to COVID-19: 16 March to 8 May 202030/07/2020 16:38:00
The HM Crown Prosecution Service Inspectorate (HMCPSI) conducted a review of the SFO’s immediate response to Covid-19. It can be accessed here.
Applying SSRO guidance to costs affected by COVID-1921/07/2020 13:05:00
The SSRO has published a note to assist the MOD and contractors in identifying and applying relevant SSRO guidance to qualifying contracts affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.
SFO receives final approval for DPA with G4S Care & Justice Services (UK) Ltd17/07/2020 17:17:17
The Serious Fraud Office has today received final approval to enter into a Deferred Prosecution Agreement with G4S Care and Justice Services (UK) Ltd (G4S C&J) relating to a scheme to defraud the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) in connection with contracts for electronic monitoring of offenders.
Former Unaoil executives guilty of giving corrupt payments for oil contracts in post-occupation Iraq14/07/2020 13:05:00
The SFO has secured convictions against two former oil executives who conspired to give corrupt payments to secure contracts in Iraq.
SFO receives approval in principle for DPA with G4S Care and Justice Services (UK) Ltd13/07/2020 14:38:00
Following the announcement from G4S Plc, the Serious Fraud Office can confirm that it has received approval in principle to enter into a Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) with G4S Care and Justice Services (UK) Ltd (G4S C&J), a wholly-owned subsidiary of G4S Plc.