Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Sports clubs not addressing accessibility needs should face legal action
The Culture, Media and Sport Committee report says it is "very clear" that sports clubs, notably many of those with very considerable income and resources, have not done anywhere near enough for sports fans with disabilities in recent years, despite the increase in income many of those clubs have enjoyed.
- Read the report conclusions and recommendations
- Read the full report: Accessibility of Sports Stadia
Premier League clubs lagging behind on accessibility infrastructure
The Committee applauds the efforts made by many football clubs, rugby league, rugby union and county cricket clubs but says it is completely unacceptable that a number of Premier League clubs—some of the richest sporting organisations in the UK—have failed to carry out even basic adaptations in over 20 years.
Finance a priority over access improvement
Some clubs are still prioritising finance over improving access, even when it is well within their means to do so: West Ham’s changes to the Olympic Stadium have resulted in some former wheelchair spaces being allocated a dual use, for wheelchair users or for hospitality facilities.
The Committee says it expects the needs of disabled fans to receive priority over the desire to charge a premium for extra hospitality accommodation, and, given the huge public investment in converting the Olympic Stadium into a Premier League football ground, all the partners involved should at the very ensure that West Ham becomes an exemplar regarding disabled access.
The report describes the difficulties faced by sports fans with disabilities wanting to attend their favourite events at every stage from the very outset: getting information about fixtures and booking, to travelling to and accessing facilities, to availability and siting of seats.
Improvement works postponed due to "random" cost estimates
The Committee heard that the suggested figure of £100 million as the cost to football clubs to make the necessary changes was "random" and "absolute nonsense" and that suggesting such a large figure merely enables clubs to postpone thinking about the issue, including improvements that might be made cheaply and immediately.
In evidence the Premier League suggested it would consider imposing sanctions on clubs that fail to provide sufficient accessibility. However, given 20 years of comparative inactivity by the football leagues, the Committee is not convinced that the Premier League would impose suitable penalties on clubs, even for failing to meet building regulations, never mind taking a the broader view of the quality of the overall experience for supporters with disabilities.
Anonymous system of problem reporting should be in place
The Committee says those who face barriers to attending fixtures may also be afraid to complain about poor access and facilities for fear of being labelled a trouble maker or even having tickets removed. Clubs should have anonymous systems for reporting problems and making suggestions to get around this.
Damian Collins MP, Chair of the Committee, said:
"When we see examples of good practice at some clubs that are already providing disabled supporters with a good experience when they attend matches, it is especially disappointing that some of the rich clubs are not doing more. Sports fans with disabilities are not asking for a large number of expensive changes - only to have their needs taken into account in the way sports stadia are designed and operated. It is high time that sports clubs, especially for example those with plenty of resources as in football's Premier League, changed their mindset. This isn’t really about money, it’s about the will to do it.
It is in clubs’ own interests to pay more attention to the often very moderate needs of such a large proportion of the UK population. Most clubs do not sell all the tickets for games, and a reputation for being well adapted and welcoming to disabled supporters should enhance their reputations generally. Conversely, it should be considered a reputational risk—and one which sponsors would have to take seriously—if clubs continue to fail to engage with reasonable adjustments and are also therefore actually in breach of the law. The Equality and Human Rights Commission has told us that it is minded to start legal proceedings against clubs that continue to flout the law. We support them in this."
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Committee wants more scrutiny of N. Ireland Brexit issues09/04/2021 14:05:00
The House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee has called on the government to provide it with more information, and in a timelier manner, concerning the December 2020 Brexit agreement with the European Union (EU).
New Report: Government has gathered momentum to act on food security, but must now find 'impetus'07/04/2021 11:05:00
Government Ministers mobilised their departments to prevent food insecurity during the covid-19 pandemic, but the impetus to do so must be sustained as the country re-opens.
Treasury Committee launches ‘Jobs, Growth, and Productivity after Coronavirus’ inquiry06/04/2021 11:25:00
The Treasury Committee recently launched a new inquiry into jobs, growth, and productivity after coronavirus.
Chair comments on the use of military sites for asylum accommodation01/04/2021 13:33:00
The Home Affairs Committee has published correspondence from the Home Office in relation to the use of former military sites, notably at Napier and Penally, for asylum accommodation.
MPs urge Government to seize tidal power potential01/04/2021 11:38:00
The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) yesterday emphasised the substantial potential of the tidal power sector to contribute to the UK’s renewable energy mix.
Private rented sector needs roadmap out of lockdown to avoid debt crisis31/03/2021 13:05:00
Repeated, last minute extensions to the ban on evictions must be replaced by a coherent exit plan to help the private rented sector emerge from lockdown, the Housing Communities and Local Government Committee has found.
Common frameworks can strengthen the Union, says Lords Committee31/03/2021 12:05:00
The Common Frameworks Scrutiny Committee publishes its first report.
Report published on the impact of COVID-19 on courts and tribunals in England and Wales31/03/2021 09:05:00
The Constitution Committee publishes its 22nd report of the session and the first of three reports on the constitutional implications of COVID-19, focussing on the impact of the pandemic on courts and tribunals in England and Wales.