Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Students need a new fairer deal for studying after school
The system of post-school education in England is not a system. It is unbalanced in favour of full time university degrees, and as a result offers poor value for money to individuals, taxpayers and the economy. It requires immediate reform.
- Report: Treating Students Fairly: The Economics of Post-School Education (HTML)
- Report: Treating Students Fairly: The Economics of Post-School Education (PDF)
- Evidence: Economics of higher, further and technical education
- Summary pamphlet ( PDF 299 KB)
- Economic Affairs Committee
The 2012 reforms to university financing have failed to create an effective market allowing undergraduate degrees to dominate when this might not be in the student or the country’s best interest. The low quality and inconsistent availability of options, caused in part by a lack of funding, have made the problem worse.
The Committee has found that the decision to switch almost all higher education funding to tuition fees financed by student loans has hidden the true cost of public spending on higher education.
The 2012 reforms have also led to a collapse in flexible and part-time learning, with student numbers decreasing over the last six years by 60 per cent. Careers for life are disappearing, and the ability to retrain will become increasingly necessary to succeed in the modern economy. Compared to other countries, England is producing far less people with Level 3 (A-Level equivalent) qualifications, and not providing the skills employers in the UK need.
The report calls for a new deal for post-school education funding which promotes all types of learning regardless of where or how it takes place. The report recommends the abolition of the Institute for Apprenticeships, increasing the powers of the Office for Students to act as a single regulator for all Level 4 and above qualifications, including for higher and degree apprenticeships, and the introduction of a single regulator for all other post-school qualifications at Level 3 and below.
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean, Chairman of the Economic Affairs Committee, said:
"The way we expect students to access higher and further education is deeply unfair. We must create a single system, including apprenticeships, that offers more choice and better value for money.
"Maintenance support should be available for all students studying at Level 4 and above. The means-tested system of loans and grants that existed before 2016 should be re-instated, and total support increased to reflect the true cost of living.
"The accounting trickery attempted by the Government in 2012, in which the high rate of interest on student loans created the fiscal illusion that Government borrowing is lower than it actually is, has had a devastating effect on the treatment of students in England. It is unacceptable to expect future taxpayers to bear the brunt of funding today’s students.
"We recommend that the interest rate charged on post-2012 student loans should be reduced to the level of the ten-year gilt rate. This would mean reducing the interest rate from around about 6 per cent today, to 1.5 per cent. No student should incur interest while studying."
The Committee's report sets out a package of reforms to post-school education. Its key recommendations are:
Other post-school options need more funding
- Funding for post-school education is too heavily skewed towards degrees. Public funding across all forms and institutions in higher and further education should be better distributed. There should be a single regulator for all higher education (Level 4 and above) and a single regulator for other post-school education (Level 3 and below).
Reversing the decline of part-time and flexible learning
- The decline in part-time learning in higher education is a result of restrictions around accessing loans for students who already have a degree, the increase in tuition fees in 2012 and the lack of maintenance support for part-time students (which will be available from 2018/19). Similar funding restrictions have also led to a decline in part-time study in further education. A credit-based system whereby people can learn in a more modular way and at their own pace should be introduced.
- The Government's target of three million apprenticeships has prioritised quantity over quality, and should be scrapped. The apprenticeship levy has encouraged the rebadging of training activity. Over half of apprenticeship training providers did poorly in recent Ofsted inspections. The Government must renew its vision for apprenticeships, concentrating on the skills and choices that employers and individuals really need. The Institute for Apprenticeships should be abolished and replaced with a new regulator for Level 3 and below qualifications, and the Office for Students should take responsibility for those at Level 4 and above.
The national accounts mask the true cost of higher education
- The Government expects that around half of the value of student loans being issued currently will never be paid back. These write-offs will not appear in the national accounts for more than 30 years. A recognition of this by including projected write-off in public spending at the time the loan is issued would allow for a better discussion of where public money in post-school education should be directed. The Department for Education have forecast that the total student loan book will be worth £1.2 trillion in nominal terms by 2049/50.
Reforms to student loans and widening maintenance support
The Government claims the high level of interest charged on student loans makes the system progressive, but it is middle-earning graduates who end up paying back most in real terms. The interest rate should be reduced to the 10-year gilt rate, currently 1.5 per cent, from the current rate of RPI plus 3 per cent.
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Senior parliamentarians criticise failures in government security planning20/09/2021 09:20:00
A Parliamentary committee concerned with national security strategy says there are serious weaknesses in the workings of UK Government structures that deal with national security, as exemplified by both the covid-19 pandemic and recent events in Afghanistan.
Reforms required if Parliamentary scrutiny of treaties is to be effective, report finds17/09/2021 13:15:00
The International Agreements Committee has today published a new report on Working Practices. It reflects on our experience of parliamentary treaty scrutiny and proposes further reforms to make scrutiny more effective.
Scottish renewables progress hampered by grid connection charges17/09/2021 11:05:00
The Scottish Affairs Committee calls for transmission charges and grid investment to be equally shared across the UK to help strengthen the Scottish renewables sector.
European Statutory Instruments Committee publishes fourth report16/09/2021 15:05:00
Following the Committee's meeting on Tuesday 14 September, its fourth report of Session 2021-22 has been published.
Treasury Committee publishes additional Government response to Tax after Coronavirus Report14/09/2021 11:20:00
The Treasury Committee today publishes a further Government response to its report on Tax after Coronavirus.
Key provisions in Equality Act 2010 not implemented10/09/2021 13:33:00
The House of Lords Liaison Committee publishes its fourth follow-up report; The Equality Act 2010: the impact on disabled people Follow-up report.
Climate Change – Government must listen to the public, says Business Committee Chair09/09/2021 13:05:00
The Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee has today published the Government’s response to the BEIS Committee’s Climate Assembly UK: where are we now? report (which was published on 8th July 2021).
New inquiry into digital regulation launched08/09/2021 11:05:00
How well co-ordinated is digital regulation and do regulators have the power, capability and expertise to keep pace with developments? These are some of the issues to be explored by the Communications and Digital Committee as it launches a new inquiry.