Taxpayer-funded activism declines in England, but soars regionally & in the EU says new IEA report
IEA releases the next in a series of research on use of public money to lobby government
Following on from research published between 2012 and 2014, a new report from the Institute of Economic Affairs finds that the use of public money to oppose free market policies has become less blatant in England, while remaining common occurrence in Scotland, Wales, and the European Union.
The report “Hand in Glove? A re-examination of state-funded activism” highlights evidence which suggests that campaigning with money from central government has declined in the UK. This change may have been brought on by a combination of austerity measures, new grant standards, and the creation of quangos to act on behalf of activist groups and as advocacy organisations in their own right.
But while activist groups in the UK appear to be receiving less money from Whitehall, state-funded activism is not on the decline regionally. It appears to have grown in Scotland and Wales. Despite budget cuts in recent years, local councils are still able to find money for like-minded pressure groups to support their activities.
State-funded activism continues to be endemic at the EU level. The majority of organisations mentioned in IEA research in 2013 receive more money from EU bodies now than they did in 2011, and most of them rely on the EU for the majority of their income.
Quango-style pressure groups that receive state funding, labelled ‘sock puppets’ in previous IEA research, tend to lobby for politics favoured by politicians and/or civil servants. While there have been improvements in some areas, mutual back-scratching and feather-nesting remains, notably in the green sector and nanny state sector.
With ‘civil society’ dominated by taxpayer-funded organisations, there is a risk that important stake-holders, not least ordinary consumers, are squeezed out of decision making.
State-funded activism in the UK
Activist groups appear to be receiving less money from Whitehall than they did five years ago. It is difficult to ascertain whether this is because of budget cuts or because of the new grant standards. Whatever the reason, the use of public money to oppose the free market has become less blatant in England while remaining common in Scotland, Wales and the EU.
- The devolved governments of Scotland and Wales are funding campaign groups such as Alcohol Focus Scotland, Stonewall, the Scottish Fair Trade Forum, Obesity Action Scotland and Action on Smoking and Health.
- Local authorities are funding campaign groups such as Balance Northeast, Sustain, Fresh, the Birmingham Food Council, Food Active and Give Up Loving Pop.
Increase in state-funding for the European Commission’s favoured ‘civil society’ organizations
Of the civil society groups that were members of the European Year of Citizen Alliance in 2013, more than 70 per cent rely on EU funding for most of their income.
The EU continues to be the major benefactor of a range of partisan political pressure groups and pro-EU think tanks, including Friends of Europe (€1,085,907, 39 per cent of income) and the Socialist Educational International (€102,233, 42 per cent of income).
- The European Movement is heavily funded by the European Commission (over half its budget in 2016), as is European Alternatives (€300,000 of its €500,000 budget).
- Both taxpayer-funded groups actively oppose Brexit and supported the October 2018 People’s Vote march calling for a second referendum.
Most of the big ‘green’ NGOs have seen their EU funding increase since 2011 and a multitude of like-minded groups receive grants from a €20 million EU programme.
Commenting on the report, author Christopher Snowdon, Head of Lifestyle Economics at the Institute of Economic Affairs said:
“Despite ‘austerity’, millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money continue to be used to fund political lobby groups. The problem is endemic at the EU level, and the devolved governments of Scotland and Wales are not far behind.
“Even local authorities, which have seen the biggest squeeze in their budgets, are effectively paying people to lobby the government for higher taxes and more regulation. These organisations have the right to be heard, but there is no justification for the government giving them a slush fund to amplify their voice.”
Notes to editors:
For media enquiries please contact Nerissa Chesterfield, Head of Communications: email@example.com 020 7799 8920 or 07791 390 268
To download the IEA’s paper “Still Hand in Glove? A re-examination of state-funded activism” click here.
Author Christopher Snowdon is Head of Lifestyle Economics at the Institute of Economic Affairs.
The IEA has published several reports, also written by Christopher Snowdon, on state-funded activism, including “Sock Puppets: How the government lobbies itself, and why” (2012), “Euro Puppets: The European Commission’s remaking of civil society” (2013), and “The Sock Doctrine” (2014).
The mission of the Institute of Economic Affairs is to improve understanding of the fundamental institutions of a free society by analysing and expounding the role of markets in solving economic and social problems and seeks to provide analysis in order to improve the public understanding of economics.
The IEA is a registered educational charity and independent of all political parties.
Latest News from
Work Foundation - Rapid action needed for people to meet challenges of changing world of work25/04/2019 14:35:00
Governments need to overhaul their approach to employment and jobs to reduce further social and economic tensions, according to a new report from the OECD. Without rapid action, many people, particularly the low skilled, will be left behind in the fast-changing world of work.
NIESR: Prospects for the World Economy25/04/2019 14:25:00
Tailwinds from accommodative financial conditions and the US fiscal stimulus boosted global economic growth during the past two years. As these have subsided, global growth has retreated somewhat from its cyclical peak.
JRF response to Food Foundation and Trussell Trust reports on food poverty25/04/2019 13:35:00
Campbell Robb, Chief Executive of the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation, responded to the publication of the Food Foundation’s Children’s Future Food Inquiry and the Trussell Trust’s annual food bank data
IEA - Customs union membership will cost UK economic, trade and foreign policies25/04/2019 12:35:00
Remaining in a customs union with the EU would make it impossible for the UK to establish an independent trade policy, and render reclaiming policy areas such as agriculture and state aid an impossibility, an IEA briefing argues.
NIESR: Prospects for the UK Economy25/04/2019 11:37:00
Our main-case forecast is broadly for a continuation of current economic conditions.
IFS - Deficit low by historical standards, but debt much higher than pre-crisis25/04/2019 11:35:00
Yesterday, the Office for National Statitics (ONS) published their March 2019 public sector finance numbers for the UK. This bulletin presents the first provisional estimates of UK public sector finances for the latest full financial year (April 2018 to March 2019).
Policy Exchange - The Speaker should allow a third meaningful vote on the Brexit deal25/04/2019 10:35:00
By Sir Stephen Laws QC, Senior Fellow at Policy Exchange, and former First Parliamentary Counsel from 2006-12
IFS - Universal credit to hit 1.9 million by over £1,000 per year – though for many these losses are temporary25/04/2019 09:35:00
11 million adults (and a third of working-age ones) will be in households entitled to some universal credit (UC). Around 4.2 million of these will be at least £100 per year better off than under the current system and 4.6 million will – after transitional protection expires – be at least £100 per year worse off.