The law as a tool for EU integration could be ending
Poland is not the only EU member state challenging the supremacy of European law, as historic change is happening in how European integration functions.
The Polish Constitutional Tribunal’s ruling that several articles of the European treaties are incompatible with the Polish constitution is prompting much debate, especially in terms of both the similarities and differences between it and rulings by the German constitutional court which have also challenged the European Court of Justice (ECJ).
Pro-Europeans are keen to draw a sharp distinction between the reasoning deployed by the two courts. They see the Polish court’s challenge as an exceptional case which the European Union (EU) cannot ‘tolerate’ because it would lead to the ‘demolition of the EU’s legal order from within’ and argue the EU must take a tough approach to Poland by re-asserting the supremacy of EU law.
But this view misses a bigger long-term shift in the EU. Both the German and Polish cases illustrate some of the basic conflicts within the EU’s legal system for decades. What is being challenged increasingly openly – even since the UK left the EU – is the idea of the EU as a de facto federation in which non-majoritarian institutions such as the ECJ have final say about the quality of democracy in member states.
Click here to continue reading the full version of this Expert Comment on the Chatham House website.
Latest News from
Is sovereign debt impeding Africa's COVID-19 recovery?29/11/2021 17:20:00
Africans realized early on in the pandemic there was a tough period ahead – repeating the long pattern of Africa feeling the worst impacts of global dynamics.
Can Ethiopia avert deep turmoil and prioritize peace?29/11/2021 16:43:00
Ethiopia’s devastating civil war recently entered into its second year and, to achieve peace, both sides in the conflict need to accept some difficult truths.
Can the Biological Weapons Convention address new biothreats?29/11/2021 13:38:00
COVID-19 has highlighted the need for the convention to adapt to a new biothreat landscape and address new pathways to infectious disease outbreaks.
Mining India's troubled history of coal and politics29/11/2021 09:20:00
India drew multiple headlines at COP26, but its role in the pledge to only ‘phase down’ coal highlights a deep-rooted and corrupt political relationship.
A polarized America still showing little sign of unity25/11/2021 13:38:00
Despite policy wins, Joe Biden’s hopes of healing a divided nation remain a distant promise with an electorate entrenched in its partisan views.
Nicaragua chronicle is of a democracy’s death foretold22/11/2021 13:43:00
The recent elections were denounced by more than 40 governments but sanctions had no measurable deterrent effect, so can the international community do more?
Ukraine still backs Zelenskyy despite slow progress18/11/2021 09:20:00
Expectations Volodymyr Zelenskyy would end the armed conflict with Russia or jail corrupt officials have faded, but so have fears he would sell out to oligarchs or the Kremlin.
The trickle-up effect of rights-based climate litigation17/11/2021 12:20:00
With governments failing in their pledges and companies accused of ‘green-washing’, human rights-based litigation is increasingly important for accountability.