Time to protect learners from the FE loan scandal
Blog posted by: Nick Linford, Writing exclusively for NCFE, 28 February 2017.
FE loans are a relatively new way to fund courses but through no fault of their own, adults are already being left with government debts for cancelled courses.
The short-term solution for government, to write the debt off, is both simple and obvious. But it is important to also learn from why and how the loans were introduced.
Before August 2013, people aged 24 or over that started a vocational course at level 3 or above would have typically shared the cost with the government.
For example, someone looking to change career and get qualified as a personal fitness instructor might pay £1,500 and the Skills Funding Agency (SFA) on behalf of the government would pay the other £1,500.
The college or training provider would then have £3,000 to deliver a level 3 qualification in personal fitness instruction.
This co-investment funding model as it’s known, where the costs are shared between the learner and the government, had been working well for many years.
However, the government obsession with cutting departmental budgets by up to 40 percent changed all that when they converted both the £1,500 learner and the £1,500 government contribution into a loan.
An advanced learning loan, as they were named, isn’t classed as government expenditure, so as far as the Treasury is concerned a budget cut had been achieved.
In the example above, the full £3,000 is paid to the college or training provider by the Student Loans Company (SLC).
The learner pays nothing until after the course finishes and, like a loan to study at university, only once they are earning over £21,000 and with a relatively low interest rate.
So assuming the learner is still willing to take out a £3,000 income contingent loan the provider still receives their funding and the provision continues.
So far so sensible, but now comes the insanity.
The SFA gave people running companies with no history of receiving public funding access to millions in loans cash from the SLC.
These people would fill out online forms with the SLC to receive the funding and often pay other companies to deliver the training via subcontracts.
The sadly predictable outcome of giving a few individuals access to millions in public funding is a growing list of liquidated companies and thousands of learners with debts for courses they are unable to finish, as increasingly reported in the pages of FE Week.
The SFA has slowly begun to address the problem, by tightening up the way they set and increase access to loan funding, as well as gradually banning the use of subcontracting.
But they also need to acknowledge their early failings by changing their policy towards learners left with debts for courses they cannot complete.
Cancelling the loan for these learners would not only end an injustice – it should also be a simple policy to implement, given this is already what happens for others.
Learners using loans for level 3 Access to Higher Education qualifications don't have to pay them back if they go on to pass a degree, a policy the then skills minister, John Hayes, implemented.
The current skills minister, Robert Halfon, should now ensure learners let down by a negligent SFA should also have their loan written off.
It really should be an easy policy change to end an obvious injustice.
Over to you Mr Halfon.
Latest News from
Turning learning loss into learning gains – adapting and evolving is key30/04/2021 09:25:00
‘Learning loss’ is a well-documented challenge faced by parents, learners and educators during the course of the pandemic.
NCFE Aspiration Awards – a past winner looks back on achievements22/04/2021 16:15:00
Each year, we enlist your help in recognising and awarding the many educators and learners who are going above and beyond in our sector, with our Aspiration Awards.
Building T Level learner confidence in the classroom and the workplace20/04/2021 11:15:00
Education and Childcare learners at Cardinal Newman College are building confidence and gaining essential workplace skills on the first year of the T Level programme.
Extend pupil premium and offer full year of education recovery to support student catch-up14/04/2021 11:25:00
Association of Colleges has published results from a survey of colleges, revealing the extent of damage to students’ education during the pandemic. A staggering three quarters (77%) of 16 to 18-year olds are performing below normal expectations, between one and four months behind, with a similar number of adult students (69%) also below where they would normally be at this point in the academic year.
NCFE’s remote invigilation supporting NHS keyworker to success31/03/2021 09:15:00
Jake Reading is a Functional Skills learner and NHS healthcare assistant and is completing his assessment through remote invigilation so he can take the next step in his journey to becoming a mental health nurse.
Tricky RSHE topics – finding a developmental approach is key29/03/2021 09:15:00
Consent, LGBT+, pornography and FGM – these are aspects of Relationships and Sex Education that we are frequently asked about in Sex Education Forum (SEF) training sessions, and the question is generally the same.
Join us at the FED National Education Summit23/02/2021 14:15:00
On 1 – 4 March, the Foundation for Education Development (FED), supported by NCFE, is holding a virtual National Education Summit to explore how a long-term plan for education is needed for our country – with over 100 high profile speakers across 4 days and more than 32 hours of thought leadership discussions.
How employers can re-build their communities through inclusive apprenticeship programmes11/02/2021 10:10:00
In celebration of National Apprenticeship Week 2021, NCFE has produced a podcast with some well-known voices from the apprenticeship and skills sector, discussing the relevance of qualifications as part of the recruitment process.