Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Veterans are not ‘mad, bad or sad’, says Defence Committee
The public perception that most Servicemen and women are damaged by their service is wrong, according to a Report by the House of Commons Defence Committee on the extent of mental illness among Armed Forces personnel.
- Read the summary
- Read the conclusions and recommendations
- Read the full report: Mental Health and the Armed Forces, Part One: The Scale of mental health issues
The vast majority of veterans leave with no mental damage, and suggestions to the contrary may actually discourage those who need help from seeking it. The Committee also believes that too much attention may be being placed on PTSD, whereas conditions such as depression are much more common.
The MoD has reported that some 3% of serving personnel were diagnosed with mental health problems last year – a significant increase over the previous decade, but still slightly lower than the level found within the general population. However, as the Department can record only those who seek help, its data probably underestimate the true figure. Academic research suggests that about 10% of veterans who served over the past 20 years may eventually develop mental health problems requiring treatment, with some groups – such as soldiers in combat roles, as well as Reservists – being at higher risk following deployment to Afghanistan or Iraq.
Provision of Care
The MPs believe that more must be done to care for the small minority of serving personnel and veterans who do suffer mental health problems. According to the Committee “it is still taking too long for veterans to access treatment when they need it, and levels of care vary across the UK”. Some Service leavers are also “still falling through the gaps”, especially during transition to civilian life.
The Committee intends to examine this further and, having completed its examination of the scale of the problem, is today launching its follow-up inquiry into the adequacy of the provision of mental health care to serving personnel and veterans.
One of the principles of the Armed Forces Covenant is that, when conditions are Service-related, veterans should receive priority treatment subject to clinical need. Yet the Committee found that this principle has been inconsistently applied. There is palpable confusion over how to implement it, and this adds to the perception that the Health Service is failing veterans. The Committee urges the Ministry of Defence to clarify the position as part of its forthcoming Veterans Strategy.
A lack of regional understanding
The Committee also found that the MoD has an inadequate understanding of the extent of veterans' mental health issues across the UK. The provision of healthcare may be devolved, but the MoD is still accountable for how the principles of the Armed Forces Covenant are implemented. More needs to be done to assess to what extent numbers of veterans with mental health problems might vary across the four nations.
Defence Committee chairman, Dr Julian Lewis MP, says:
"Contrary to public perception, most Servicemen and women leave with no mental ill-health and, to help veterans, we need to dispel the myth that many suffer psychological harm. But the MoD must ensure that the few who do develop mental health problems are receiving the level of care promised to them in the Armed Forces Covenant. At the moment they are not, and we shall examine the situation in more detail in our follow-up inquiry, launched today."
Ruth Smeeth MP's comments
Defence Committee member and Chair of the APPG for the Armed Forces Covenant, Ruth Smeeth MP, says:
"Effective support during transition, as you leave the military, is essential to ensure that our service personnel experience a positive move into civilian life without any unnecessary stress. If they are already receiving support for mental health issues while serving, they must receive what they need as they move into NHS care. Yet, clearly, some leavers are falling through the gaps and the MoD needs to do much better in working with health economies across the UK to stop this from happening."
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
COP26 – Government should spell out how it will measure success at the UN Climate Change conference05/03/2021 12:20:00
The Government’s ambitions for the COP26 climate summit need to be clearer, says the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee in an interim report on Net Zero and COP26 published today.
Government has “no plan” for achieving Net Zero, two years after setting target in law05/03/2021 11:20:00
As it gears up to host the international climate summit COP26 a few months from now the UK Government "lacks a plan for how it will achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050" despite setting the target - in law - almost two years ago.
New inquiry: Long-term funding of adult social care05/03/2021 09:33:00
The Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee yesterday launched a new inquiry to investigate how covid-19 has impacted the adult social care sector and its long-term funding needs following the pandemic.
No case for reform of the Human Rights Act, says Joint Committee on Human Rights04/03/2021 11:38:00
Today the Joint Committee on Human Rights has published its response to the Government’s Independent Human Rights Act Review, which concludes that the HRA has had an enormously positive impact on the enforcement of human rights in the UK, and finds that there is no case for reform under the terms of reference of the Government’s review.
Committee report on EU transport policy and potential rule change on clotted cream03/03/2021 11:38:00
The European Scrutiny Committee has highlighted the significance for the UK of EU strategy in the area of transport, where the EU has ambitious plans for, among other aspirations, zero emission planes and ships.
Universal Credit and survival sex: Work and Pensions Committee publishes Government response to previous committee report03/03/2021 09:25:00
The Work and Pensions Committee has published the Government response to the previous committee’s report on Universal Credit and survival sex.
Tax reform needed to address unsustainable public finances, warns Treasury Committee02/03/2021 11:38:00
The public finances are on an unsustainable long-term trajectory, primarily due to projections of rising age-related spending based on existing Government commitments, which has been exacerbated by the fiscal impact of the coronavirus pandemic.
Committee publishes Government response to Iran report01/03/2021 15:33:00
The Foreign Affairs Committee recently (26 February 2021) published the Government’s response to the committee’s report “No prosperity without justice: the UK’s relationship with Iran”.
Government to consider requiring online marketplaces to collect old electronics from customers01/03/2021 11:38:00
The Government could require online retailers and marketplaces to collect old electronics from consumers to ensure there is an equal obligation for the collection of e-waste as physical retailers.