Why Auntie is Right
Blog posted by: Charlotte Pickles, Director at Reform, 12 June 2019.
“As someone who used to work for the BBC I am ashamed of them for this decision”, tweeted Tory leadership candidate Esther McVey in response to the BBC’s decision to scrap free TV licences for over 75s. The broadcaster, McVey went on, has “forgotten the public they are supposed to serve”, which presumably is why she has promised to reinstall the benefit if she becomes Prime Minister.
With the exception of those certified as blind (who get a 50% discount on the fee), old age is the only qualifying criteria for free access to the BBC’s television output. It is an oddly discriminatory position. McVey’s comments imply that elderly people are a special category of “the public” for which the BBC was constituted to serve. This, of course, is nonsense. The BBC’s mission is to serve “all audiences”.
Is this outrage, then, because pensioners are least likely to be able to afford the licence? That may have been the case in the past, but not today. Working-age adults are now more likely than pensioners to be in poverty. And adults with children are particularly at risk. If the concern is affordability, shouldn’t those so affronted at the BBC’s behaviour be agitating for a free licence for poor families?
In fact, the BBC is continuing to prioritise pensioners; poor pensioners. Any household with at least one person on means-tested Pension Credit will still receive a free licence. For many elderly people struggling with loneliness their television is a lifeline – the £155 annual fee should not be a barrier. But where over-75s can afford to pay, there is no rational reason why they shouldn’t.
This new approach will cost half a billion less which, the BBC claims, will allow it to continue providing services that benefit a wider cross section of the public. Social media is saturated with calls for the Beeb to instead slash its eye-watering presenter pay packets – but whether or not you think Gary Lineker is worth £1.8 million, the total annual spend on presenters is nowhere near the £500 million saving. The real problem is that the BBC is competing against other broadcasters and content providers, which means it has to attract and retain top talent, but is subsidised by what is effectively a tax. Surely the real answer is to scrap the fee entirely and move to a subscription model.
But in the absence of such a radical shift, rather than castigating the BBC, politicians might like to take a moment to recognise the broadcaster’s courage. Throughout David Cameron’s austerity government, pensioners were protected from cuts to benefits. While the state pension increased in value year to year thanks to the generous ‘triple lock’, working-age benefits, those given to people struggling to make ends meet, were frozen. Free bus passes, TV licences and non-means tested Winter Fuel Payments remained untouched.
The BBC has dared to go where grey-vote-fearing politicians have not. Their decision is fair and financially responsible. Tory candidates for Prime Minister could learn a lot from Auntie.
|Tweets by @reformthinktank|
Latest News from
Digital Public Services: What's Next?19/01/2021 12:25:00
The challenges that arose with service delivery during COVID-19 – from lockdown and remote working to increased demand – further cemented the benefits of having the right digital infrastructure in place.
Reformer Thoughts: 'a New Deal For Prevention'11/01/2021 11:05:00
This Reformer Thoughts discusses the benefits of a preventative approach to public health and the obstacles that stand in the way of its realisation.
Reform Think Tank Responds to Electoral Commission Decision on Brexit Party Name Change07/01/2021 15:05:00
The Electoral Commission yesterday certified the Brexit Party’s application to rename itself ‘Reform UK’.
Towards a New Model of Prevention10/12/2020 12:33:00
This briefing gives an overview of the discussion at the event ‘Towards a new model of prevention’.
All Hands on Deck: Public Private Partnerships During Covid-1908/12/2020 12:33:00
This Reform Perspectives examines how government has worked with the private sector to respond to COVID-19.
Driving The UK’s Leadership in Vaccine Research And Innovation03/12/2020 12:33:00
This Reformer Thoughts discusses how the UK can drive innovation and research into vaccines, even beyond the Covid-19 pandemic.
Good For, Bad For: Reform's Spending Review 2020 Breakdown26/11/2020 12:33:00
Yesterday’s one-year Spending Review held few surprises. We knew the finances were exceptionally bad, and the latest OBR data confirms that: the ‘central’ scenario has the economy contracting by 11.3% this year, unemployment peaking at 7.5% and long-term GDP scarring at 3%.
A Global Science Superpower: The Future of Medicines Valuation18/11/2020 16:25:00
This briefing gives an overview of the discussion at the event, 'A global science superpower: the future of medicines valuation'.