Ministry of Justice
Why it's important to have diversity in leadership
I was once categorically told by a course teacher that you don’t find people who exhibit a ‘facilitator’ leadership style (people-focused over task-focused, empowering over directive) in leadership positions. “Apart from perhaps as the HR Director,” she said disparagingly. What a ridiculous thing to say, I thought. The sad part is, it’s true, ‘facilitator’ types are much less represented in senior positions compared to the population as a whole, and what’s worse is nearly half of women identify as this personality type.
For me, the end goal of diversity in leadership is to have a balance in styles and thought processes - not just to have equal numbers of men and women in leadership. The balance in styles maximises our ability to identify the right strategy and motivate everyone to deliver it. However, women heavily outnumber men in personality types underrepresented in leadership positions, so gender balance is a good proxy measure.
But one person with a different style is not enough. They will usually ‘fit in’ with the presiding culture, negating their impact on the diversity of thought of the organisation. It is also widely recognised that without role models that we can relate to, we don’t imagine the role is suitable for us and don’t work towards it. We are stuck in a cycle!
Men are also victims of this perception. I know many very capable men who are people-focused and open to others’ ideas that didn’t see a future for themselves and switched careers, all because they didn’t see people like themselves in leadership positions.
We all benefit because if the culture of the organisation changes, it creates more space for people to grow, take ownership and contribute to strategy at all levels.
|Traditional ‘driver’ leadership style||Alternative ‘facilitator’ leadership style|
|sets direction; is directive and assertive||collaborates; wants to understand context & different points of view|
|‘owns’ ideas (even if they didn’t come up with them)||amplifies the individuals and teams who were the source of ideas|
|expresses direction with authority, certainty, and conviction||openly acknowledges uncertainty|
|expects subordinates to toe the line||is accepting of challenge, and in return expects ownership at all levels|
|focuses on their vision as the single right answer||acknowledges there are many different ways of moving forward (and helps their teams to pick one!)|
In reality, a good leader chooses the right approach in the right situation. Leaders need to be adept at using other styles as well as their natural approach. If there is a crisis or a large capability gap in the team, the facilitator approach isn’t likely to get the results needed and may result in disaster.
Without a strong focus on diversity in our leadership, we aren’t exposed to all approaches. Future ‘facilitator-leaning’ leaders don’t emerge as they leave to pursue other careers. Existing leaders don’t recognise there is a missing string to their bow as they rarely see others using this approach. We all continue to believe that those who don’t fit the mold, aren’t fit to be leaders. We all miss out on the opportunity to work in a rounded culture that values people as well as outcomes and acknowledges emerging context and strategy, not just the HIPPO (highest paid person’s opinion).
Latest News from
Ministry of Justice
Sobriety tags launched in England to tackle alcohol-fuelled crime31/03/2021 13:10:00
Sobriety tags and drinking bans aimed at reducing alcohol-fuelled crimes launch in England today (Wednesday 31 March), following a successful rollout in Wales.
In Review: The 2020 Justice Services Conference30/03/2021 16:15:00
Blog posted by: Joanne Lumsden and Nikola Goger, 29 March 2021 – Categories: a great place to work, collaboration, Events, Our People.
Nightingale court opens in Bolton stadium30/03/2021 13:05:00
The home of Bolton Wanderers Football Club will begin a new life as a temporary court this week, joining the national effort to tackle the impact of coronavirus on the criminal justice system.
£1 million voucher scheme to help families resolve disputes outside of court29/03/2021 13:15:00
Separating parents will be helped to avoid stressful court battles through a new million-pound mediation scheme launched recently (26 March 2021) by the government.
A simple hiring process is a better hiring process26/03/2021 13:15:00
Blog posted by: Bola Olaofe, 25 March 2021 – Categories: a great place to work, Our services, Recruitment.
Conference on Disarmament: Minister Cleverly's Address on the UK Integrated Review26/03/2021 12:34:00
Minister James Cleverly addressed the Conference on Disarmament following the publication of the UK Integrated Review of Security, Defence, Foreign Policy and Development.
Women in Tech: My career transformation into coding22/03/2021 15:15:15
Blog posted by: Kate Smith, 19 March 2021 – Categories: developer, Digital skills.
GPS tags to hunt burglars and cut theft18/03/2021 15:15:15
Burglars, thieves and robbers released from prison will be made to wear GPS tags to track their movements in a world first scheme to crack down on neighbourhood criminals.