RAILTRACK PLACED IN ADMINISTRATION
8 Oct 2001 12:00 AM
Byers Proposes a Private Company Without Shareholders but with the
Interests of the Travelling Public as its Top Priority
Stephen Byers, Transport Secretary, today succeeded in his petition
to the High Court to put Railtrack plc into Railway Administration.
The action was taken following a request from the Board for
additional Government funding otherwise the company would be
insolvent. Mr Byers refused this request on Friday.
He also announced that he had put in place funding arrangements for
the administrator to ensure that the railway continues to run safely
and normally. He also intends to put forward proposals to enable a
transfer of Railtrack plc''s responsibilities to a new company.
Stephen Byers said he believed that the public interest obligations
of the rail network operator would, after the administration, be
better achieved through a private company without shareholders - a
private sector ''company limited by guarantee''. This would have the
interests of the travelling public as its priority, not the need to
increase shareholder value. It would invest any operating surpluses
directly into the network.
Stephen Byers said that he hoped John Robinson, in whom the
Government had complete confidence, would become Chairman of the new
company.
Stephen Byers said:
''The Government cannot justify any more additional public money for
Railtrack. We provided a substantial package of financial assistance
in April, but the company came to me in July asking for additional
public subsidy. They subsequently also requested suspension of the
regulatory regime.
''Railtrack''s costs and poor service penalties are expected to exceed
the Regulator''s October 2000 determination - and the Government''s
April rescue package - by over #2bn over the next five years. This is
before taking account of the additional costs relating to Hatfield.
In addition, projects, such as the West Coast Main Line, are
significantly over budget - the West Coast upgrade may now exceed
#7bn, compared to the original #2.3 bn.
''The Government will stand behind the rail system and is prepared to
spend over #30bn over the next ten years to ensure a substantially
improved rail network, but is not prepared to fund the poor
performance of individual companies.
''As a result of our action today I intend to put forward a scheme for
a new private company without shareholders, which will put proposals
to the Railway Administrator to acquire Railtrack''s core business.
This will be a private sector company, working in the interests of
the whole industry.
From today, Railtrack''s rail network operations will be under the
control of Railway Administrators. They, with the financial support
of the Government, will keep the railway running until the transfer
of Railtrack''s licensed activities out of administration as a going
concern.
Current rail services will continue unaffected and Railtrack staff
will continue to be paid and remain employed by the company under the
control of the administrators. The Administrators are already working
closely with the Health and Safety Executive to ensure that whilst in
administration Railtrack continues to meet the Railway Inspectorate''s
safety requirements.
The decision to petition for Railtrack to be placed into Railway
Administration was taken when it became apparent that the company
could not finance its activities on being told that the further
significant financial support it had sought from Government would not
be provided.
Stephen Byers continued:
''Since John Robinson approached me in July, I have had a number of
discussions with the company, and have given full and proper
consideration to our response. I reached the conclusion on Friday
that it would not be right to provide additional public support to
the company.
Following the administration, I believe the public interest would be
better served if the interests of the rail network operator were
aligned with the interests of the whole industry. This can be
achieved if the future management were freed from the requirement to
deliver returns on publicly traded shares.
''This is not renationalisation. The new private company without
shareholders to be proposed to the administrator would have members
initially appointed by the Strategic Rail Authority who will include
key industry stakeholders. Unlike shareholders, these members would
not receive dividends or other returns and any financial surplus
would be re-invested in the network. This proposal would create a
business independent of Government operating on a fully-commercial
basis.
I hope that John Robinson will become Chairman of the proposed new
network operator. He has the Government''s full confidence. He only
recently joined Railtrack and has worked hard to tackle the huge
problems the company faces. I believe John Robinson can make an
important contribution to rebuilding the industry.
''I also plan to legislate, when Parliamentary time allows, to
rationalise the present regulatory structure to provide stronger
strategic direction while reducing the burdens of day to day
interference in the industry and a self-defeating system of penalties
and compensation. This will deliver clearer accountability and end
perverse incentives.
Railtrack''s position as a floated company which is dependent on
Government paying around two thirds of its revenue was unique. The
Government remains fully committed to its programme of public private
partnerships.
''I believe the announcements I am making today will start the process
of rebuilding the rail industry. We need a strong, well managed new
company to come out of administration and unite the rail industry
under stronger strategic direction and deliver the improvements that
passengers and freight-users deserve, and a better deal for
taxpayers''.
Ends
Notes to Editors
Railtrack was privatised in 1996 and has operated within a standard
regulatory framework for a utility network company. The Rail
Regulator, the independent regulator of licensed railway operations
in the UK, determines the level of expenditure and outputs to be
delivered and the level and sources of income within each five year
regulatory Control Period. The second regulatory Control Period (CP2)
started on 1 April 2001.
The Regulator''s final determination of his Periodic Review for CP2,
published in October 2000, provided Railtrack with #14.7bn (98/99
prices) for operating, maintaining and renewing the network over the
next five years, of which nearly #8bn was for a substantial programme
of renewals investment. In view of the exceptional nature of this
large renewals investment the government decided that the programme
should be supported by #5bn of direct capital grant to Railtrack,
rather than through access charges to train operators.
As a result of the additional financial costs faced by Railtrack,
primarily following the accident at Hatfield, the Government
subsequently agreed in April this year to advance #1.5bn of grant
support Railtrack was due to receive in future control periods into
CP2. In addition, Railtrack was to receive around #500m of
additional grant to cover a shortfall in income from freight
operators from the level assumed in the periodic review.
In July 2001, following John Robinson''s appointment, the Board of
Railtrack Group concluded that it had insufficient revenue to allow
it to finance its activities throughout the remainder of CP2 and
approached Government seeking yet more financial support and a
suspension of the economic regulatory regime. This request included
an open-ended financial commitment on government for the next three
to five years, which the Board believed was necessary to allow
Railtrack to address its increasing operational and financial
difficulties.
The Transport Secretary has rejected this request.
Appointment of Railway Administrators
Alan Bloom, Chris Hill, Scott Martin and Mike Rollings of Ernst &
Young were today appointed joint special Railway Administrators on
the making of a Railways Administration Order in the High Court under
the provisions of the Railways Act 1993..
Rail operations during Railway Administration
The Railway Administrators are under a legal duty to manage the
company so as to keep the rail network operational throughout Railway
Administration and to seek to agree the terms on which the licensed
activities currently undertaken by Railtrack would be transferred out
of Administration as a going concern.
The Railway Administrators have indicated that they intend to conduct
the Administration in a way that minimises the disturbance
experienced by passengers, the Train Operating Companies and other
stakeholders.
Management and employees
The Railway Administrators have confirmed that employees'' pay and
conditions will not be affected by the Railways Administration Order
and that there are no plans for redundancies as a result of
Administration. Any transfer of the core licensed network activities
would comply with the relevant TUPE regulations.
Funding Railtrack though Railway Administration
The Government has committed to provide the Railway Administrators
with the financial support necessary to ensure that the rail network
can remain fully operational throughout Administration.
Impact on creditors
The Government has committed to provide the Railway Administrators
with sufficient funds to allow them to continue to pay trade
creditors as invoices fall due for payment. Suppliers who are
creditors of the company and whose invoices are approved for payment
by the company in the normal way will continue to be paid. Orders
for goods and services will continue to be issued by the company''s
staff. There will be a review of the larger contracts but in the
meantime contractors will be requested to work on these contracts in
line with existing work schedules.
Suppliers who provide goods and services during the Railway
Administration will be paid from the company''s operating cash flow.
The Government has also committed to provide sufficient funds to pay
non-default interest, lease rentals and scheduled principal
repayments (mainly Commercial Paper) and all other non-default debt
service obligations for an initial period of at least 45 days. This
arrangement will continue for finance creditors who have signed up to
certain standstill arrangements until a transfer scheme is proposed.
Government intends to bring forward a scheme to enable a proposal to
be made to the Railway Administrators which would, if accepted,
result in the transfer of both the business of the company and the
debt of the finance creditors participating in the standstill to a
new company designed to operate the railway post Administration.
Under this proposal, such debt would be transferred to the new
company which will be financially sound and have (at the time of
transfer) a long-term credit rating of at least BBB/Baa2 and a
short-term credit rating of at least A-2/P-2 (Standard & Poor''s
Rating Services / Moody''s Investors Service Inc.). Indebtedness would
be transferred on broadly the same economic terms (e.g. coupon and
maturity), applicable in the absence of any default, as applied
immediately before administration.
Impact on Railtrack Group shareholders
The financial consequences of today''s actions for shareholders in
Railtrack Group will depend on the terms of any scheme proposed by
the Administrators as appropriate for the transfer of Railtrack plc
out of administration as a going concern. But no public monies will
be available to support shareholder value.
Public Enquiries: 020 7944 3000
DTLR website: http://www.dtlr.gov.uk