WIREDGOV

The German company comtech GmbH markets electrical and electronic equipment. On its website, it displays the telephone number of an after-sales service containing the prefix 0180, which is used in Germany for support services at a single national rate. The cost of a call to that special (nongeographic) number exceeds the amount that the consumer would incur at normal connection rates for calling a standard (geographic) fixed or mobile number.

A German association promoting the commercial interests of associations and undertakings (Zentrale zur Bekämpfung unlauteren Wettbewerbs Frankfurt am Main e.V.) has brought an action against comtech before the Landgericht Stuttgart (Regional Court, Stuttgart, Germany), seeking an injunction prohibiting that commercial practice, which it claims is unfair. The Landgericht has referred a question to the Court of Justice seeking a preliminary ruling as to whether the Directive on consumer rights precludes the charging of such a rate.

In yesterday’s opinion, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar proposes that the Court should answer that question in the affirmative.

Mr Szpunar points out that, under the Directive, the Member States must ensure that, where the trader operates a telephone line for the purpose of contacting him by telephone in relation to the contract concluded, the consumer, when contacting the trader, is not bound to pay more than ‘the basic rate’.

That means, according to the Advocate General, that the charge to the consumer cannot be higher than that for a standard call at normal market prices. Thus the consumer must not incur charges higher than the normal costs which he would incur for calling a standard (geographic) fixed or mobile number.

Click here for full press release