|Printable version||E-mail this to a friend|
IPPR: Many unanswered questions on emergency brake
• Who would decide whether the emergency brake can be pulled? Some reports have suggested that the European Council will decide whether a member state can pull the emergency brake. But there is a risk for the Prime Minister that they would block a UK request. On the other hand, if the European Commission has the final say, then such a deal may struggle to receive public support in the UK.
• For how long could the emergency brake be used? Reports have suggested that the Prime Minister is arguing for in-work benefit restrictions to be in place for seven years, before permanent changes can be agreed. But such an extensive ban may not be countenanced by other EU leaders.
• Is the proposal possible without treaty change? If not, then it will require ratification by all 28 member states. On the other hand, a change to secondary legislation would only need a qualified majority in the Council of Ministers (as well as a majority in the European Parliament).
Marley Morris, Research Fellow at IPPR, said of the proposed deal:
“There are many unanswered questions about this newly touted ‘emergency brake’. Who should decide when it can be used? What objective measure should be used to determine whether it can be pulled? And how high should the bar be set? If – as No 10 sources suggest – the UK’s current circumstance would trigger the use of the emergency brake, then how is this agreement materially different to the UK’s original proposal, which was rejected as discrimination by other EU leaders? If the Prime Minister can overcome these political and legal hurdles, then a deal may be in sight.”
Sofie Jenkinson - email@example.com 07981 023 031
Lester Holloway - firstname.lastname@example.org 07585 772 633
Notes for editors
After negotiations with European Council President Donald Tusk this weekend, no deal has yet been reached. If a deal can be found, Tusk is expected to publish a draft text of the agreement tomorrow. However, the nature of the agreement on the most contentious area – freedom of movement and welfare – is still very unclear. No 10 has signalled a significant step forward on the UK’s proposal to limit in-work benefits for EU migrants. A No 10 source says the Prime Minister has found agreement for the UK to pull an ‘emergency brake’ to restrict benefits immediately after the EU referendum.
IPPR has published two briefings on how the Prime Minister can negotiate changes to EU free movement rules as part of the current negotiations:
On changes to EU migrants’ access to benefits: http://www.ippr.org/publications/freedom-of-movement-and-welfare-a-way-out-for-the-prime-minister
On changes to free movement rules relating to crime, public services, labour markets, and integration: http://www.ippr.org/publications/unlocking-the-eu-free-movement-debate
Latest News from
Demos - Peer pressure means alcohol remains ‘social glue’ and ‘rite of passage’ for students and young workers22/09/2016 13:35:00
New Demos research finds that despite an overall declining trend in youth alcohol consumption, harmful drinking remains rife in both offices and campuses.
JRF - Inclusive Growth Commission: Economic growth must reach our small towns and cities22/09/2016 12:35:00
Responding to the RSA Inclusive Growth Commission interim report, Julia Unwin, chief executive of the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation and a member of the Commission, said the UK must promote economic growth benefiting everyone:
Kings Fund - Clear and credible plan needed for digital health22/09/2016 11:35:00
Government ministers and NHS leaders should set out a definitive plan for expanding the use of digital technology in the health service, according to a new briefing published by The King’s Fund.
Policy Exchange - Government will miss its housing target unless Housing Associations are given more freedoms to build22/09/2016 10:35:00
Government will miss its housing target unless Housing Associations are given more freedoms to build
Civitas - The Real Sterling Crisis: Why the UK needs a policy to keep the exchange rate down20/09/2016 10:25:00
The fall in the value of sterling since the vote for Brexit has had commentators wringing their hands with concern. But why are so many so quick to assume that a cheaper pound is a bad thing?