Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Chair comments on the use of military sites for asylum accommodation
The Home Affairs Committee has published correspondence from the Home Office in relation to the use of former military sites, notably at Napier and Penally, for asylum accommodation.
- Home Office written evidence on use of former military sites for asylum accommodation
- Home Affairs Committee
In response to the correspondence from the Home Office, Yvette Cooper yesterday said:
“These documents raise a further set of serious questions for the Home Office about the use of Napier and Penally barracks as asylum accommodation during the pandemic. It is unacceptable for the Home Secretary to claim that the sites were set up “in such a way as to be safe” when we know that there was an outbreak of 197 covid cases in one of these sites during the winter and that clinically vulnerable people were being housed in dormitory accommodation during a public health crisis.
“The Home Secretary has failed to address the clear contradiction between the evidence she and the Permanent Secretary gave to the Committee on 24th February that Public Health England advice was followed at “every stage” of the process, and the findings of the ICIBI who stated that PHE advised the Home Office in September 2020 that opening dormitory accommodation was not supported by guidance but that both sites were opened before recommendations had been actioned. The Home Secretary must provide an explanation for the contradiction between these accounts. The Home Office must either explain why it believes ICIBI’s statement is wrong or confirm that PHE guidance was not followed in September. They cannot have it both ways.
“We have noted the Home Office refusal to provide us with a copy of the guidance or advice from PHE in September and we will continue to pursue this issue, taking account of the timetable for litigation that is underway.
“The Home Secretary refers to PHE guidance published in December 2020 which sets out how non self-contained accommodation should be used if self-contained accommodation is not available. That guidance also states that cohorting decisions should be made in partnership with the local PHE HPT and must account for “clinical and social vulnerabilities of the residents”. However the document published from the local public health team makes clear that “open-style dormitories do not facilitate effective social distancing and measures to reduce the numbers on site and create individual sleeping accommodation are recommended”. Therefore this appears to be another deeply concerning example of the way in which guidance was being breached contrary to the statements made by the Home Secretary and Permanent Secretary.
“These documents also show once again, that significant risks were flagged to the Home Office about the use of this accommodation, including on the management of fire risks and the potential for covid outbreaks. Clearly the actions taken by the Home Office to mitigate those risks were insufficient. The Committee is seeking assurances following the fire and covid outbreak at Napier barracks that early recommendations were actioned and that these incidents are being investigated now. The Committee will be pursuing this further with PHE and with the Home Office.
“We remain seriously concerned that so many people were placed by the Home Office in accommodation that was wholly unsuitable to a public health crisis and which encouraged the spread of covid-19. We are also waiting for the full ICBI report and will continue to seek answers from the Home Office about how this was allowed to happen.”
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Committee receives Government response to key report on procedure after coronavirus restrictions07/05/2021 09:15:00
The Procedure Committee publishes the Government’s response to its detailed report setting out a procedural roadmap for coming out of the current lockdown.
Change the law now to ensure end to blanket bans on care home visits, urges Joint Committee05/05/2021 11:15:00
The Joint Committee on Human Rights has prepared a draft statutory instrument to lay before Parliament to secure legal protection for care home residents deprived of family visits, and therefore, their human rights.
Supply chain for battery electric vehicles inquiry launched04/05/2021 15:05:00
In the latest stage of its Technological Innovation and Climate Change inquiry, the Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) announces that it is to look at the supply chain for battery electric vehicles.
Privileges Committee publish key report on select committee powers03/05/2021 10:20:00
The Committee of Privileges publishes a key report on select committee powers, setting out preliminary proposals to ensure the committee powers to call for persons, papers and records can be enforced and that witnesses before committees are treated fairly.
MPs urge Government to level playing field for meat and seafood exporters30/04/2021 13:05:00
The Government must take a 'pragmatic' approach in discussions with the EU to reduce 'considerable' non-tariff barriers—including red tape and checks— that the new GB-EU trading environment has created for British companies.
European Statutory Instruments Committee publishes twenty-fourth report29/04/2021 16:10:00
Following the Committee's meeting on Tuesday 27 April, its twenty-fourth report of Session 2019-21 has been published.
Mineworkers’ pensions - Government should fix ‘historic injustice’ felt by Scheme members29/04/2021 11:15:00
The Government should review the surplus sharing arrangements in the Mineworkers’ Pension Scheme to ensure they are fair and deliver a better outcome for pensioners, say the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee.
Sub-Committee on Foreign Involvement in the Defence Supply Chain publishes Special Report29/04/2021 10:20:00
The Defence Sub-Committee on Foreign Involvement in the Defence Supply Chain publishes its Special Report outlining the Government’s response to its report.