Differing Net Zero definitions must ‘mesh’ say Met Office scientists
A new paper published in Nature has highlighted a fundamental mismatch in the way greenhouse gas emissions are measured which could mean that Net Zero could be met in one definition up to five years ahead of the other.
Golden wheat harvested at sunset with combine harvester generated by artificial intelligence
The IPCC report shows that global temperature will stop increasing when we reach ‘net zero’ emissions of CO2. To achieve this, human activity cannot put more CO2 into the atmosphere than it removes – we need to massively reduce our emissions, with some removal of CO2 to help areas which are really hard to decarbonise. This sits behind the principle of Net Zero, which countries including the UK hope will be reached by 2050.
The paper by Gidden et al, highlights the differences between the two key greenhouse gas accounting systems: one which underlies the IPCC statement that net zero will halt global warming; and the other from how nations produce a National Greenhouse Gas Inventory (NGHGI) to report to the UNFCCC (United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change).
Professor Chris Jones, who is the Met Office’s lead on carbon budgets, was asked to write a discussion document alongside the paper.
Chris Jones said: “Both of the key systems for measuring greenhouse gas emissions work well on their own. But there is a challenge when they have to work together in one view. It’s a little like having a bank account and spending in one currency, while trying to save in another. Both currencies work fine on their own, but merging the two together requires an exchange rate mechanism otherwise you risk financial jeopardy by spending beyond your means.”
The mismatch surrounds the different treatments of flows of carbon on so-called managed lands, such as croplands or plantations; these flows can be reported either as natural or human-induced depending on the definition being used. Under the IPCC definition, carbon cycle processes happening on managed lands (such as plantations) are considered natural (and therefore don’t contribute towards progress to net-zero), whereas under the UNFCCC definition the same processes are considered human-caused.
“Although these differences may sound negligible, the result is that the mismatch could add as much to five years to the difference between Net Zero being declared in one system and confirmed by the other. This matters hugely because Net Zero could be being celebrated for several years while billions of tonnes of emissions are still being released to the atmosphere which would cause further warming. The two processes must mesh – or we will miss our climate targets.”
Latest News from
Wet and windy weather to continue21/02/2024 16:15:00
Met Office warnings have been issued with wet and windy weather continuing for many through much of this week.
A precautionary approach required to avoid large-scale collapse of the Amazon forest16/02/2024 13:15:00
The Amazon is a complex dynamical system with extraordinarily diverse terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems which are home to more than 10% of Earth’s biodiversity, as well as 40 million people.
Turning cold06/02/2024 15:15:15
Cold air moving in from the north will see temperatures fall for many this week, increasing the chance of wintry hazards and a warning for snow issued for some.
Our changing weather patterns: a tale of abrupt transitions06/02/2024 11:15:00
Our weather is notoriously changeable – that is partly what makes it one of the nation’s talking points. But peering through the statistics a striking pattern emerges: one where the weather oscillates abruptly between different and contrasting phases lasting for a while before the next phase in the sequence begins to dominate.
A month of contrasts for January’s weather05/02/2024 16:15:00
January 2024 brought a month of contrasts to the UK weather, with three named storms, a significant spell of cold, wintry weather and finally a new UK daily maximum temperature record for January.
Turning colder with snow risk for some05/02/2024 14:10:00
Cold air from the north will drop temperatures for many this week, with an increased chance of wintry hazards and a warning for snow issued for some.
Solar maximum in sight – but when will it be?30/01/2024 13:15:00
Throughout autumn and winter there have been a number of sightings of the Northern Lights, or the aurora borealis, in the UK.
Why have there been so many storms in the UK this year?24/01/2024 15:15:15
Storm name number ten was given when Jocelyn was named hot on the heels of Isha in what has felt like an unusually stormy autumn and winter for the UK.