Financial Conduct Authority
FCA takes action against debt packager firms
Following an FCA review of the practices of debt packager firms, 5 firms have stopped providing regulated debt advice until further notice and the FCA has used formal powers to stop another firm from providing regulated advice.
The FCA has also published correspondence between Sheldon Mills and Dean Beale, CEO of the Insolvency Service setting out how the 2 organisations are approaching these issues and working together to protect consumers who need debt advice and ensuring co-ordinated regulation across the 2 organisations.
Debt packager firms advise consumers on how to deal with their debts, often referring them to an Insolvency Practitioner or debt management firm, for which they receive referral fees. These fees can be many times higher when the firms refer consumers to an Insolvency Practitioner to potentially enter into an Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA), or Protected Trust Deed (PTD) in Scotland, than for other debt solutions. The FCA has made very clear to firms that it expects them to manage this conflict of interest to ensure that their advice is right for consumers, not just firms’ financial interests.
The FCA has identified concerns that some debt packager firms appear to have manipulated consumers’ income and expenditure to meet the criteria for an IVA or PTD; used persuasive language to promote these products to consumers without fully explaining the risks involved; and provided advice that did not accurately reflect their conversations with consumers or information that consumers had given. In some cases, the FCA’s view is that firms failed to sufficiently take into account consumers’ circumstances and vulnerabilities, including mental health issues and economic abuse.
Sheldon Mills, Executive Director, Consumers and Competition at the FCA, commented: ‘The practices we’ve seen in this sector fall far short of the standards we expect from firms, let alone those claiming to offer help to people in need. We will not allow firms to profit from debt advice which puts their customers at risk of harm.’
Following the review, the FCA wrote to 5 firms identifying significant concerns over their practices and making clear its concern that the firms were continuing to offer advice to consumers while those issues remained unresolved. The firms all subsequently applied for voluntary requirements to be imposed, which mean that they can no longer provide regulated advice services until the FCA is satisfied that they can comply with the rules.
The FCA has also used its formal powers to remove another firm’s permission to provide debt advice. This firm was using a script for contact with consumers that appeared weighted towards recommending a debt solution that would have generated a referral fee for the firm, whether or not that was suitable for individual consumers.
As part of its priority work to ensure that consumer credit markets work well for consumers, set out in its Business Plan for 2021-22, the FCA is also considering policy changes to address the significant potential for harm through poor advice that the debt packager business model poses. If it concludes that changes are needed, the FCA will consult on proposals later this year.
Consumers who are wrongly advised to sign up to an IVA or PTD may suffer significant harm. They may struggle to keep up the repayments and if they cannot do so, their IVA/PTD may fail. If it fails at an early stage, repayments already made may have largely gone towards the fees for the IVA/PTD rather than paying down debts; they may have backdated interest and charges added to outstanding balances by creditors; and they could be made bankrupt.
There are wider concerns about debt advice and the market for IVAs and PTDs which sit beyond the remit of the FCA, as described in the Woolard Review published by the FCA earlier this year.
Consumers who need help with their debts can get free and impartial advice from the MoneyHelper website or by telephone on 0800 138 7777, provided by the Money and Pensions Service.
Notes to Editors
- The 5 firms which applied for voluntary requirements are listed below. Please note that the FCA is not attributing any of the specific practices found in its review of the debt packager market, as listed above, to any of these individual firms:
- Assist UK Group Limited (769143) https://register.fca.org.uk/s/firm?id=001b000003d4fXSAAY#what-can-this-firm-do-restrictions
- Two Financial Services Limited (671355) https://register.fca.org.uk/s/firm?id=001b000000k3cNrAAI#what-can-this-firm-do-restrictions
- Consumer Money Worries Ltd (811724) https://register.fca.org.uk/s/firm?id=0010X00004AWiY6QAL#what-can-this-firm-do-restrictions
- Faith Financial Solutions Ltd (674375) https://register.fca.org.uk/s/firm?id=001b000000khguSAAQ#what-can-this-firm-do-restrictions
- Debt Help Limited (782878) https://register.fca.org.uk/s/firm?id=001b000003rsZEvAAM#what-can-this-firm-do-restrictions
- The firm whose permission to provide debt advice was removed using formal FCA powers is Action On CIO (770254) https://register.fca.org.uk/s/firm?id=001b000003ekdYVAAY#disciplinary-and-regulatory-action
- Letters sent to debt packager firms in 2018 and 2020
Latest News from
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA charges Simon Day with one offence of money laundering23/07/2021 09:20:00
Following a joint investigation by the Financial Conduct Authority and City of London Police, the FCA has charged Simon Day with one offence of money laundering, contrary to Section 327(1) of the Proceeds of Crime Act.
The FCA and the Bank of England encourage market participants in a switch to RFRs in the LIBOR cross-currency swaps market from 21 September21/07/2021 16:20:00
Following close engagement with authorities across LIBOR jurisdictions and with market participants, the FCA and Bank of England support and encourage liquidity providers in the LIBOR cross-currency swaps market to adopt new quoting conventions for interdealer trading based on risk-free rates (RFRs) instead of LIBOR from 21 September this year.
FCA secures conditional resolution of proceedings against Park First and its senior management21/07/2021 10:05:00
The FCA has secured a conditional agreement with the defendants in proceedings seeking compensation for approximately 4,500 investors in the failed Park First Scheme. The conditional agreement should see a further £25 million made available for compensation to investors.
FCA consults on post-Brexit divergence for PRIIPS regulation20/07/2021 15:05:00
The FCA has set out proposals to change disclosure documents provided to retail investors under the Packaged Retail and Insurance-based Investment Products (PRIIPs) regulation.
FCA commits to being a more innovative, assertive and adaptive regulator16/07/2021 10:25:00
The FCA yesterday made a commitment to be a more, innovative, adaptive and assertive regulator.
FCA bans convicted fraudster from carrying out regulated activity15/07/2021 10:25:00
The FCA has banned director Matthew Creed from performing any regulated activity.
Stephen Allen pleads guilty to forgery14/07/2021 10:25:00
Yesterday at Southwark Crown Court, Stephen Allen pleaded guilty to forgery, following a criminal charge laid by the FCA. He will be sentenced on 24 September 2021.
Statement on supervision of commodity position limits09/07/2021 13:10:00
In December 2020, we published a Supervisory Statement setting out our approach to the operation of the MiFID markets regime after the end of the EU withdrawal transition period.
FCA fines LBGI £90 million for failures in communications for home insurance renewals between 2009 and 201709/07/2021 10:25:00
The FCA has fined LBGI (Lloyds Bank General Insurance Limited, St Andrew’s Insurance Plc, Lloyds Bank Insurance Services Limited and Halifax General Insurance Services Limited) £90,688,400 for failing to ensure that language contained within millions of home insurance renewals communications was clear, fair and not misleading.