National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE)
How giving a committee voice to people with a learning disability added value to NICE quality standards
Chris Bird, Quality Standards Programme Manager, tells us how NICE developed the latest learning disability quality standards.
NICE has recently published 2 quality standards aimed directly at those designing services for people with a learning disability and behavior that challenges and at improving care and support for people growing older with a learning disability.
Our team set itself an ambitious target to transform the formal process of developing the quality standards, which includes stakeholder and public consultation and two formal committee meetings, to make it accessible for people with a learning disability to take part.
For this the team recruited two lay members with a learning disability, referred to as ‘experts by experience’, to sit on each committee. Their involvement brought a lived-perspective to the discussions and decisions of the committees. Key information was presented to the committee in an easy-read format. An independent facilitator was also provided to support the experts by experience throughout the process.
During the 10-month development of these quality standards, NICE conducted user research with all key participants including the committee chairs, NICE technical analysts, independent facilitator, experts by experience and committee standing members. The evaluation included pre- and post-committee interviews and a survey of all committee members at the end of the process.
All participants in this research agreed that involving people with a learning disability in the discussion was important and beneficial to the committee, to the population covered and to the final published quality standards.
Elements of the process that the experts by experience found particularly positive were:
- Flexibility of the NICE quality standards team to action requests from the experts by experience, or to provide a clear explanation if it was not possible to accommodate their requests.
- An additional meeting with the facilitator prior to the committee meeting allowed for discussion and clarification. This helped the experts by experience articulate their thoughts better in the meeting and gave them more confidence.
- The facilitator being independent of NICE.
- Good chairing of the meetings and being treated equally with other committee members.
An important lesson the team drew from their experience is that there’s no standard approach to involvement. Alternative engagement approaches may have to be considered for example, to support individuals with more complex learning disabilities or those who are less familiar with working in guideline committee settings. The assistance of a skilled and independent facilitator was crucial both to support and give confidence to the people with a learning disability on our committees and as a source of advice to the technical team leading the development of these standards.
Both of the final, published quality standards emphasise to providers and commissioners the importance of an annual GP health check for people with a learning disability, which is likely to lead to the identification and management of underlying health problems at an earlier stage. This aligns with the objectives in the NHS Long Term Plan on improving health outcomes for people with a learning disability, and supporting them to better manage their health.
Latest News from
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE)
Digital and mobile interventions could support regular health services in helping people stop smoking and reduce their risk of obesity, says NICE24/01/2020 11:15:00
Health professionals can consider digital and mobile interventions as a supplement to regular services to support behaviour change in people at risk of developing chronic conditions.
Care matters – Working together to get support right for adult carers23/01/2020 11:15:00
Dame Philippa Russell, Vice-President of Carers UK and Topic Adviser for the NICE guideline on Supporting Adult Carers.
NICE encourages further data collection on ‘game changing’ histology independent cancer drugs17/01/2020 14:10:00
Larotrectinib (also called Vitrakvi and made by Bayer), a new treatment for a range of cancers, can’t be recommended for use in the NHS because at its current price, it doesn’t have the potential to be cost-effective.
Make use of community pharmacists’ skills, says NICE17/01/2020 13:05:00
Community pharmacy teams have the potential to play a greater role in health promotion and prevention says NICE, in a new draft quality standard.
Breast cancer patients to have further NICE-approved drug combination option on Cancer Drugs Fund17/01/2020 11:15:00
Another potentially life-extending drug combination for some people with advanced breast cancer will now be available on the Cancer Drugs Fund (CDF) following its approval by NICE in final guidance published recently (15 January 2020).
Implantable cardiac monitors detect atrial fibrillation after stroke of unknown cause recommended for routine NHS adoption15/01/2020 11:15:00
Doctors can check on their patients remotely using Reveal LINQ monitor.
Shared Learning Awards 2020 now accepting entries07/01/2020 14:15:00
Submit your shared learning entry by 4 March 2020 for a chance to be one of our 20 finalists at this year’s NICE Conference.
Additional evidence needed to assess histology-independent cancer drugs says paper co-authored by NICE staff03/01/2020 10:15:00
Paper looks at how histology-independent cancer drugs might be appraised.
Use of out-of-area rehabilitation placements for adults with complex psychosis should be curtailed says NICE20/12/2019 14:15:00
A new draft NICE guideline published today (20 December 2019) on the rehabilitation of adults with complex psychosis and related mental health conditions says they should have access to rehabilitation services in their local area and the use of out-of-area placements limited.