IFS - Inequalities in early child development remained stubbornly high through the 2010s
Inequalities in the early cognitive, social and emotional development of children in the UK, which are so important in shaping later life outcomes, have changed little between those born in the early 2000s and those born in the early 2010s.
New research on UK inequalities in early childhood carried out for the IFS Deaton Review of Inequalities, funded by the Nuffield Foundation, paints a challenging picture:
- Inequalities in early cognitive, social and emotional development have changed little between children born in the early 2000s and those born in the early 2010s. This applies to gaps between the children of high- and low-educated mothers, and between children living in more and less deprived areas.
- Trends in the home environments that children grow up in are mixed. On average, there have been improvements in some aspects of early home environments, such as the frequency with which parents read to their children, but deteriorations in other aspects of the home environment, such as a rising prevalence of maternal mental health problems. Differences in these environmental factors between richer and poorer families remain stubbornly high.
- The lack of change in gaps in early development comes despite unprecedented public investments in the early years over the past 20 years, and evidence that targeted policy interventions – in particular Sure Start – had positive impacts on the poorest families and children. The authors argue that persistence of the inequalities likely reflects the complex and multiple factors affecting child development and the fact that much of the increased public spending has been on childcare places and childcare subsidies for the over-2s, while the primary determinants of early development are in the family home and operate from the very earliest stages of life.
Other key findings include:
- Children’s skills develop highly unequally in the early years, with differences strongly related to family background. For example, at age 3, children raised in the highest-income fifth of families are more than three times as likely to have high cognitive ability (placing them in the top fifth of the distribution) as children from families in the lowest-income fifth. Similarly large gaps exist for social and emotional skills.
- Large differences in the material, emotional and educational aspects of the home environment are key to explaining many of the inequalities in children’s early skills. For example, mothers in the lowest-income fifth of families are almost eleven times more likely to experience psychological distress, when their child is 3, than mothers in the top-income fifth; and 42% of parents on the lowest incomes read to their child daily at age 3, compared with 76% of parents with the highest incomes.
- The early years shape later life outcomes to a remarkable degree. As adults, the children of mothers who left school at 16 or over earn about a third more than the children of other mothers on average. Half of that earnings gap can be explained by the child’s early development, and features of the home environment, up to age 5.
Sarah Cattan, Associate Director at the Institute for Fiscal Studies and an author of the new research, said:
‘It is disappointing that socio-economic gaps in early development changed little when comparing children born in the early 2000s with those born in the early 2010s, especially amid concern that the pandemic has held back development and may have widened gaps further. But we know, through many examples of well-crafted and effective early childhood policies which are emerging around the world, that progress is possible. There is real potential for early childhood intervention to boost development, especially among the disadvantaged. It does, however, require careful design, with consideration of the multiple barriers that hold back the most disadvantaged children.’
Professor Alissa Goodman, Director of the UCL Centre for Longitudinal Studies and an author of the research, said:
‘The environments that children are raised in, and their development of cognitive, social and emotional skills early in life, are not only key determinants of their experience of childhood – they also profoundly shape their prospects as adults. Early years policies in the UK need to focus more on supporting families during the earliest years (ages 0–2), including through adequate income and housing, ensuring high-quality mental health care, and supporting early parenting, attachment and relationships during this vital period.’
Eleanor Ireland, Education Programme Head at the Nuffield Foundation, said:
‘Widening inequalities as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and the cost of living crisis have made it even more crucial that families with young children are given adequate support. A holistic approach to early childhood is needed that will provide families with parenting support, access to mental health services, boosted family incomes and improvements to the physical environments in which children are raised. This support could help to close the disadvantage gap and improve outcomes for children throughout their lives.’
Latest News from
Online sales tax would worsen cost of living crisis, warns IEA paper01/07/2022 09:25:00
An online sales tax would help commercial landlords at the expense of consumers
Adam Smith Institute - Slim Down the Cabinet Office to Ensure Value for Taxpayers29/06/2022 14:20:00
Reduce the Cabinet Office headcount and simplify its structure to ensure greater efficiency says think tank
JRF - New evidence of the ‘year of financial fear’ being endured by UK’s low-income families29/06/2022 13:20:00
2022 has seen low-income families going without essentials, building up arrears and taking on debt just to get by
IEA - Online Safety Bill hands unprecedented censorship powers to Secretary of State and Ofcom, warns new research28/06/2022 15:20:00
Online Safety Bill hands unprecedented censorship powers to Secretary of State and Ofcom, warns new research
Higher debt interest costs should not prevent tax cuts, says IEA economist23/06/2022 15:35:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on the latest ONS public finances data
Mistake to reinstate the pension triple lock, says IEA labour market expert23/06/2022 10:05:00
Professor Len Shackleton, labour market expert at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs commented on the return of the pension triple lock, which will see the state pension rise by 10 per cent in line with inflation.
Work Foundation - Research uncovers ‘digital poverty’ across North West’s rural communities with one in four struggling to complete key tasks online23/06/2022 09:05:00
A new study by researchers at Lancaster University reveals 28% of the population in rural North West England are not confident completing key tasks online, such as applying for a job or making an online call. Most alarmingly, over half of those aged 65 and above and those on lower incomes lack digital skills, meaning those most in need of online services are least likely to be able to access them.
Latest inflation data should not deter the Bank from raising rates more quickly, says IEA economist22/06/2022 16:05:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on the latest inflation data from the ONS