Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Inappropriate to use the Local Housing Allowance rate, says Committee
The Government should scrap plans to base rent allowances for supported housing tenants on rates used for claimants in the private rented sector, the Work and Pensions and Communities and Local Government Committees conclude in a joint report on the future of supported housing.
- Read the report summary
- Read the conclusions and recommendations
- Read the full report: Future of supported housing
Scrap plan to base supported housing allowances on private sector rates
The Committees say it is inappropriate to use the Local Housing Allowance (LHA) rate and argue that a new Supported Housing Allowance, banded to reflect the actual cost of provision in the sector, should be introduced instead. The Committees note concerns that the Government’s proposed reform could lead to a serious shortfall in the availability of supported housing.
Ministers are right to consider an alternative funding mechanism for emergency accommodation, given the inability of Universal Credit to reflect short-term changes in circumstance. The Committees recommend grants to local authorities, which can commission accommodation and pay providers.
The report also calls a separate funding system for women’s refuges and urges the Government to work with Women’s Aid and providers to devise it. The Committee says it is essential that refuges are able to operate as a national network, unrestrained by local admissions restrictions.
Richard Graham MP, Co-Chair of the inquiry and member of the Work and Pensions Committee, said:
"Supported housing is deeply valued by those who live in it and contributes enormously to their independence and wellbeing. We support the Government’s aims to reform funding for this vital sector to ensure quality and value for money, protect and boost supply, and provide greater local control.
But we are concerned that the proposals, as they stand, are unlikely to achieve these objectives. Our recommendations seek to improve the Government’s plans and ensure it delivers on our common goal of a sustainable, long-term funding solution for supported housing."
Helen Hayes MP, Co-Chair of the inquiry and member of the Communities and Local Government Committee, said:
"The proposals have caused considerable concern. Supported housing providers are reconsidering investment plans, shortfalls in the levels of service are expected to get substantially worse and vulnerable tenants are anxious that they may no longer have the guarantee of a home for life.
Ministers must intervene immediately by scrapping the proposed Local Housing Allowance reform. The sector needs a far more suitable funding system that recognises the consistent cost of provision across the country and provides long term reliability.
Supported housing caters for an incredibly diverse range of people, from long-term sheltered accommodation for older people to short-term emergency housing for those who have recently become homeless or are fleeing domestic abuse. The Government is right to consider alternative funding for emergency accommodation and we urge Ministers to also recognise the unique challenges of refuges with a distinct funding model."
Under the current proposals for supported housing, core rent and service charges for supported housing tenants would be funded up to the level of the applicable LHA rate. For costs above this, the Government would devolve ring-fenced top-up funding.
But the Committee found that the cost of provision is largely consistent across the country, unlike the LHA rate. Consequently, some areas will rely more on top-up than others. As this is considered a less secure funding source, the Committees are also concerned that providers will be put off investing in particular areas, creating a disparity between the supply of homes and services across the country.
The Committees argue that a Support Housing Allowance would ensure tenants only require top-funding in exceptional circumstances. The Allowance would be calculated according to a formula made up of a fixed amount for provision, which is consistent between areas, and a smaller variable amount that reflect differences in land costs.
Central funding of the top-up should be guaranteed for at least the duration of the next Parliament to provide greater certainty. Funding levels should be regularly reviewed to ensure the top-up fund keeps pace with increases in the cost of provision and changes in local demand.
Recommendations and conclusions include:
- The Government should ensure providers are aware that supported housing tenants claiming Universal Credit will not be worse off if they seek employment. A job should be seen as an important milestone towards independence and self-sufficiency.
- The Government should establish a set of national standards to enable monitoring of the quality of provision in all supported housing in England and Wales, with a specific emphasis on improving the quality of life that tenants experience
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Council tax – councils should not be chasing arrears from households that can least afford it, say MPs01/12/2023 17:10:00
The Government should act to ensure local councils are not aggressively chasing council tax debt from those who can least afford it, says the cross-party Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (LUHC) Committee in a report published today.
Government warned to proceed with caution on AI in autonomous weapons01/12/2023 16:10:00
The Artificial Intelligence in Weapon Systems Committee publishes its report Proceed with Caution: Artificial Intelligence in Weapon Systems.
UK government responds to calls for Scotland to be promoted ‘beyond the tartan’30/11/2023 15:25:00
The Scottish Affairs Committee has published the UK Government’s response to its report on Promoting Scotland Internationally, in which MPs found the UK and Scottish Governments often collaborate well when promoting Scotland’s interests abroad but more work is needed to highlight modern Scottish successes.
Our friends in the North: UK strategy towards the Arctic29/11/2023 16:05:00
The House of Lords International Relations and Defence Committee has today published its report, ‘Our friends in the North: UK strategy towards the Arctic’
Financial sector’s progress on net zero risks stalling as Government sends mixed messages, MPs argue29/11/2023 15:05:00
Progress made at COP26 with ambitious commitments to prioritise investment in low carbon industries and into protecting nature risk being undone through mixed messaging from the Government, the Environmental Audit Committee argues today.
Government must act now to fix crisis in local audit, say MPs27/11/2023 16:25:00
Local audit is in crisis and the Government must take urgent action to fix it, says the cross-party Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (LUHC) Committee in a report published recently (Friday).
Connected tech: Smart or sinister?: CMS Committee publishes Government response to report24/11/2023 14:10:00
The Culture, Media and Sport Committee has today published the Government response to the first report from its inquiry Connected tech: smart or sinister?
Administration Committee publishes recommendations on parliamentary communications, highlighting potential for increased engagement with the public23/11/2023 15:20:00
Sir Charles Walker MP, the Chair of the Administration Committee, today launched the Committee’s report focusing on how the House of Commons can improve the way it communicates with the public about Parliament.
Incentivise EV battery supply chain investment to prevent decline of the UK car industry, say MPs22/11/2023 12:25:00
The UK Government is falling behind its competitors and needs to urgently create an attractive environment for electric vehicle (EV) battery production in the UK, according to a report by cross-party Committee of MPs.