Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC - formerly IPCC)
Learning for Met officer over Finsbury Park arrest
An Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) investigation of a complaint by a driver who was stopped and searched in Walworth, south London, found no case to answer for misconduct but has resulted in three Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) officers being told to attend a community stop and search event.
We recommended that the officers should attend this to understand the impact felt by those in the community who have been subjected to the tactic. The MPS has also agreed to write a letter to the driver detailing that he was not connected with any wrongdoing at the time of the incident and apologise for any inconvenience caused.
The 38-year-old man was stopped while driving in Walworth Road, SE17 on 5 May 2020 and a video from the incident was shared widely on social media. The driver and his car were searched under the Misuse of Drugs Act, and although handcuffs were not used it was suggested by one of the four officers present that they could be.
We began our independent investigation on 19 May 2020 after the man complained that the officers racially profiled him prior to the search, and that he was subsequently treated differently because of his race. The man believed that as he had previous interaction with the same officers, this initial encounter influenced the officers’ decision to search him. He also complained that the officers failed to observe social distancing rules.
Our investigation was completed in May this year. The evidence we gathered did not suggest the complainant was racially profiled. We found the decision to make the stop was based on local intelligence including knowledge of drug dealing and gang activity there. We confirmed through body worn video (BWV) that the officers did not know who was in the car before it was stopped, as it had tinted windows.
As part of our investigation we also reviewed the officers’ previous stop and search records and the rationale provided by the officers for their actions.
Based on the evidence gathered, we found no case to answer for misconduct for any of the officers. However, we did identify a number of performance issues where the officers’ behaviour had fallen short of public expectations. These included making or failing to challenge comments which, while not made within earshot of the complainant, could have been construed as disrespectful. Social distancing guidelines were breached by three officers during the incident and BWV was not used in accordance with policy.
The force accepted that while these breaches did not meet the threshold for disciplinary action, the officers should be subject to reflective practice. Following our recommendations this included three of them having further equality and diversity training; attending a community event on stop and search to listen to and understand the impact felt by those in the community who have been subjected to the policing tactic; and to further reflect on their conflict management and use of de-escalation tactics.
IOPC Regional Director Sal Naseem yesterday said:
“Stop and search is an important policing tool but its use must be reasonable, proportionate and necessary.
“It is an intrusive power which disproportionately affects Black communities. The community needs to have confidence that racial bias plays no part in how this policing power is used. Without this, the trust and confidence they have in the police service will diminish.
“In this case we found no case to answer for misconduct, but we did find that this incident could have been handled better and identified learning in the form of reflective practice. That’s why we recommended the police officers involved engage with the community itself to understand the impact their actions can have.”
Evidence gathered during our investigation included taking statements from the complainant, the officers involved and other witnesses. We also looked at BWV footage, and studied policing policies concerning stop and search, BWV and the use of personal protective equipment.
Latest News from
Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC - formerly IPCC)
Investigation concludes into incident during Met’s traffic stop of 70-year-old in Bromley09/12/2022 10:05:00
We have concluded our investigation into an incident in Bromley, south-east London on 13 September 2021 during which a 70-year-old male motorist was arrested by Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) officers.
Former Cheshire officer to appear in court charged with misconduct in public office02/12/2022 12:25:00
Following an Independent Office for Police Conduct investigation, a former Cheshire Constabulary police constable has been charged with misconduct in public office. He is accused of abusing his position for a sexual purpose.
Former City of London Police officer charged with inflicting GBH01/12/2022 13:20:00
A former City of London Police officer will appear in court to face a charge of inflicting grievous bodily harm (GBH), following an investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).
Essex Police officer convicted of assaulting man after he had been handcuffed30/11/2022 09:10:00
An Essex Police officer was recently (28 November) convicted of assault by beating for using unnecessary force against a man after his colleagues had arrested and handcuffed him.
Merseyside Police officer charged with misconduct in public office28/11/2022 09:05:00
A Merseyside Police officer is due to make his first appearance in court after being charged with misconduct in public office and computer misuse offences following an Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) investigation.
Investigation concludes into use of force used on man in East London22/11/2022 16:10:00
Two Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) officers, who used force during the arrest of a man during an altercation in East London and later died in hospital, acted in accordance with the relevant policies and procedures, an Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) investigation concluded.
Former Northamptonshire Police staff member jailed for child sexual offences21/11/2022 09:10:00
A former Northamptonshire Police support staff member has been given a two-year jail sentence for child sexual offences following an investigation directed by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).