National Infrastructure Commission
NIC and CCC call for urgent action to protect infrastructure from climate risks
The National Infrastructure Commission and Climate Change Committee have written jointly to government urging ministers to take steps to improve the resilience of key infrastructure services to the effects of climate change.
Building on recent reports by both organisations, the advisory bodies set out five steps to accelerate national adaptation planning to protect key networks:
- Setting clear and measurable goals for resilience, and action plans to deliver them
- Ensuring these standards are developed in time to inform forthcoming regulatory price control periods (which set investment levels for operators)
- Giving explicit duties for resilience to all infrastructure regulators
- Cabinet-level oversight of interdependencies and whole-system resilience
- Embedding resilience in infrastructure planning as we move to an economy more reliant on electricity
The letter was sent to Oliver Dowden MP, Deputy Prime Minister and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, and Thérèse Coffey MP, Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs yesterday (26 April).
The full text of the letter is below.
Dear Secretary of State
Improving infrastructure resilience and adapting to the change in climate
Record breaking storms and temperatures in 2022 brought widespread disruption to energy and transport networks, with substantial impacts for people living and working across the UK. As the climate continues to change, these impacts are likely to intensify. We urge you to develop more effective plans to improve the resilience of infrastructure, which is so critical to the UK’s economic prosperity.
Our two organisations have presented separate reports to Parliament in recent weeks: the Climate Change Committee’s biennial Adaptation Progress Report and the National Infrastructure Commission’s annual Infrastructure Progress Review. These reports each highlight significant gaps in delivering climate-resilient infrastructure for the country. The new National Resilience Framework is welcome, but national adaptation planning is falling behind.
We recommend five steps to close the resilience gap:
Translate the present high-level objectives into delivery plans, with clear goals and measurable outcomes for resilience. The Climate Change Committee’s recent Adaptation Progress Report found very limited evidence of the implementation of adaptation at the scale needed to prepare fully for climate risks facing UK infrastructure, or more broadly for cities, communities, the economy and ecosystems. Credible planning for climate change was only found for five out of the 23 infrastructure and built environment adaptation outcomes examined. The next National Adaptation Programme (NAP3), expected this summer, must set clear goals for resilience and measurable outcomes against which to monitor progress. As part of this, implementation of resilience standards, as the National Infrastructure Commission recommended three years ago in its Resilience Study, should be a priority. A set of annually reported indicators and data sharing across infrastructure providers are needed to monitor progress and ensure whole-system resilience.
Align policymaking for resilient infrastructure with regulatory cycles. Between now and 2029 there will be new price controls for electricity, gas, twice for water and a new control period for Network Rail. Adaptation and resilience policy needs to be aligned with these regulatory cycles. Most critically, if new outcome-based resilience standards are not developed until 2030, every single one of those cycles will be missed and the window of opportunity for investment to meet those standards will be pushed back until the 2030s.
Give essential duties to Regulators that presently do not have them. Ofwat’s resilience duty has been central to resilience planning in the water sector and similar duties need to be given to Ofgem, Ofcom and the Office of Rail and Road. This would also be an opportune time to ensure each of these regulators has a duty to support delivery of Net Zero.
Strengthen resilience coordination between infrastructure systems to head-off cascading impacts. Interdependencies between infrastructure systems mean that climate impacts in one system cascade and interact with others. There are numerous recent examples of these failures, including power outages during Storm Arwen, which then disrupted water supplies, and the flooding of a gas pipe in Sheffield following a broken water main. The UK requires better mechanisms to identify and track these cascading risks, with clearer accountability for key institutions to mitigate them. Both our organisations have emphasised the need for Cabinet-level oversight of interdependencies, a recommendation supported by the Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy in its recent inquiry into climate adaptation and critical national infrastructure. Common resilience standards, data sharing between infrastructure providers and the type of transparent progress monitoring set out above are also needed to ensure whole-system resilience, including mandatory reporting by infrastructure operators under the Adaptation Reporting Power.
Embed net zero and climate adaptation in infrastructure planning. Through the Government’s Net Zero strategy, the UK is preparing for a major programme of infrastructure investment. The need for resilient and reliable infrastructure systems must be designed-in from the start, including when building low carbon homes and new networks such as hydrogen. Across the transition, there are also risks that must be monitored and managed, particularly as we electrify the Net Zero economy. As our dependence on the decarbonised electricity system increases, risks like storm damage to overhead wires could become more disruptive. System planning must account for extreme events and weather-related uncertainty such as low wind.
Government has two imminent opportunities to embed better climate adaptation in this way:
- Clarify important delivery milestones for the National Resilience Framework. Last year’s publication of the Framework was welcome, but Government must follow it up with clarity on what will be delivered, clear milestone dates and development of common resilience standards as soon as practicable. This will ensure critical opportunities in price review cycles are not missed.
- Show real vision in the Third National Adaptation Programme (NAP3). Government has already recognised that greater ambition is needed in the country’s adaptation programme. A new plan must demonstrate how this will be delivered. Recent research for the CCC has shown that, across all sectors, additional investment of up to £10 billion per year for climate adaption may be needed this decade. NAP3 is the opportunity to provide clarity and direction on how this will be funded, financed and delivered.
The Climate Change Committee and the National Infrastructure Commission continue to work independently, but our advice on these critical issues is fully aligned. We must not delay improving the resilience of UK infrastructure to protect the country from the well-understood risks of the UK’s changing climate.
Baroness Brown of Cambridge, Chair, Adaptation Committee
Sir John Armitt, Chair, National Infrastructure Commission
Latest News from
National Infrastructure Commission
Submission of final water plans marks important step in tackling England's supply gap31/08/2023 16:10:00
Today is the deadline for water companies to submit long term plans for how they will manage public water supplies
Winser report on energy networks offers plan for necessary transformation04/08/2023 14:15:00
An independent report by Nick Winser, in his capacity as government’s inaugural Electricity Networks Commissioner, has been published today (4 August 2023).
Jim Hall: NAO report highlights "stuttering progress" on waste reduction03/07/2023 10:10:00
Report reflects Commission concerns about need for swift action to support a more sustainable economy and delivery of net zero objectives
Cornwall's green energy ambitions09/06/2023 10:20:00
Bold plans for net zero leadership evident in latest regional visit ahead of NIA2
Commission welcomes net zero duty for Ofgem09/06/2023 09:20:00
Change to Energy Security Bill in line with Commission recommendation to boost investment in resilient net zero infrastructure
Creating a more sustainable approach to infrastructure construction02/06/2023 09:10:00
The Commission backs the principles set out in a new cross-industry statement of intent
Letter to Ofwat on water company asset management19/05/2023 13:15:00
Letter to Ofwat on the need for a more consistent understanding of long term asset health
Clean energy and better recycling among North Yorkshire's infrastructure priorities02/05/2023 11:15:00
Members of the Commission team were in Harrogate and Knaresborough recently (26 April) meeting local political leaders and businesses from across North Yorkshire and learning more about the county’s priorities around delivering net zero, creating a low-waste economy and the challenges of digital connectivity in what is a largely rural region.
Stronger coordination of environment and community benefit needed to get planning timescales back on track18/04/2023 12:25:00
A new data platform to share environmental information and effective ways of addressing the impact of proposed infrastructure projects will enable stronger protection for natural habitats and speed up schemes crucial to the net zero transition, according to a new report by the National Infrastructure Commission.